Beyond The Hype - Understanding AI's Impact On Human Rights
Author: LawSphereX
Category: Constitutional & Human Rights
Published:
Updated:
BEYOND THE HYPE: UNDERSTANDING AI'S IMPACT ON
HUMAN RIGHTS Saee Ranjeet Hingmire, BA LLB, Shankarrao Chavan Law College, Pune, Maharashtra
ABSTRACT
Artificial Intelligence, often trimmed to AI, has made rapid growth in recent years. The concept primarily focused in science fiction has emerged as an integral part of our daily lives. What we once saw as a futuristic technology, is now a driving force behind countless innovations. What we thought was impossible some 10 years ago can now be done within seconds. Companies often use the term to attract investments or researchers to find the required information. It plays a crucial role in decision-making, system control and creative tasks. But the challenge which has arisen is to ensure that these systems are conceived thoughtfully, utilised responsibly and fairly. This article explores the opportunities created by AI and its influences on human rights, consisting of problems including privacy, equality, and duty.
It examines the challenges and possibilities posed by means of AI technologies and advocates for a human-centric method to AI improvement and governance that prioritises the safety and merchandising of human rights.
Introduction
The Artificial Intelligence sector has rapidly evolved in recent years. This technological revolution brings in loads of opportunities, offering the potential to enhance efficiency, drive innovation and solve complex problems. It has now become an integral part of our daily lives. When we talk about AI, we refer to machine systems capable of performing tasks that normally require human interpretation and effort. This consists of information about natural language, spotting styles, solving issues, and making choices. It decorates productiveness by way of collecting, processing, and publishing statistics in different methods. The ultimate goal of AI is to create human-like thinking or perform tasks that normally require human activity. But it also offers a complex interplay of opportunities and dangers for human rights.
While AI has the ability to strengthen human well-being and address increasing global problems, its development and implementation raise significant ethical concerns. 1 Artificial intelligence, the modern-day alchemy of turning data into decision-making magic, has a history as rich and complex as humanity itself. Its roots trace back to ancient myths of automatons and the philosophical musings of human intellect. The digital age ignited the AI flame, reworking theoretical concepts into tangible reality. Early pioneers like Alan Turing, John McCarthy laid the foundation for what actually became a technological revolution. Today, AI stands tall as a massive phenomenon, it has a penetrating influence in every aspect of our lives. From the mundane to the extraordinary, AI is there, learning, adapting, and shaping our world.
Understanding AI Artificial Intelligence is a stimulation of human intelligence processes by machines. It is the science of stimulating computers which ordinarily require human intelligence. This involves tasks like problem solving, reasoning, learning, language understanding. In essence AI is about creating intelligent agents that can interact with the world. These systems work on data algorithms and data. AI systems need a large amount of data ranging from images to texts or numbers. Scientists create mathematical formulas called algorithms that process this data. These algorithms are considered as the brains of AI. The systems are trained by feeding the 1Frana, P. L. (2023) What policymakers need to know about Artificial Intelligence, Atlantic Council. Available at: http://www. atlanticcouncil.
org/in-depth-research-reports/issue-brief/what-policy-makers-need-to-know-aboutartificial-intelligence/ (Last accessed: 28 July 2024). massive data which makes it possible for recognizing patterns and making predictions. This is called machine learning. From the science fiction of yesteryears, AI has rapidly evolved into a tangible reality and made its impact felt. It has now exploded into the global stage transforming industries and redefining human potential. Core human rights principles When we look into the human rights related to AI it can widely range from the fundamental rights such as freedom of speech, freedom of equality to other core human rights such as privacy, accountability and safety. The rapid development in this sector has raised questions about their impact on human rights.
When we delve into the depths of the AI system, we tend to ask ourselves questions such as “Are the AI driven decisions fair and equitable? ”, “Do AIpowered surveillance systems have clear legal and ethical boundaries to protect civil liberties? Practically speaking, AI systems must be developed and trained on diverse datasets to avoid perpetuating existing biases. There should not be discrimination on the basis of race, gender, religion or other protected liberties. These potential human rights and their impact should be assessed before deployment. Measures should be in place to mitigate negative impacts and maximise benefits. These principles provide a foundation for ensuring that AI is developed and used in a way that respects human dignity. But in case of mass surveillance, who should be accountable for the actions and outcomes of AI systems?
Introducing central theses: AI as a force for good and the ethical dilemma surrounding it AI can be considered as a double-edged sword. It is a potential force for driving the developments happening around us. We make use of AI in our daily activities with or without our knowledge. From Google search engine to any social media platforms,all use AI to curate content based on our experiences and increase their engagement with the community. It has its immense impact on science, healthcare, policy making and education. However, the shadow side of AI cannot be ignored. There have been increased concerns about data privacy and job displacements. If not developed and deployed properly, it can possess a serious threat to existing inequalities, civil liberties and can even pose an existential threat to humanity.
AI as a tool for good As AI technologies advance, it is crucial to ensure that their benefits are maximised while minimising potential harm. Let's delve deeper into the ways AI can be a catalyst for positive change. AI-driven applications in healthcare can lead to earlier diagnoses and more personalised treatments, thereby promoting the right to health. In policy making, AI can utilise the vast data, identify patterns and make more accurate predictions adhering to people’s needs. While in the educational field, it can help to make AI-powered personalised learning platforms catering to individual student’s needs and therefore promote the right to education. It holds great potential for addressing the gaps global education systems are struggling with.
2 The role of developers, policymakers and society The AI developers play a significant role in ensuring that AI systems are developed and deployed ethically. They have to ensure that while deploying these systems, human rights and civil liberties are not harmed. This includes mitigating the risks involved in the deployment, prioritising privacy-preserving methods of ensuring transparency in AI algorithms. There should be an interdisciplinary approach while developing these systems. AI can be used as a powerful tool for formation of policies and their implementation, which helps in efficiency advancements, improvements in the quality of public services and time saving on other administrative tasks. It also has its impact on the stages of the policy cycle, ranging from agenda setting to policy formation.
3 AI can also be used as a tool to enable policymakers to formulate more effective policies parallel to societal needs, make better decisions, and improve communication and engagement with stakeholders. 4Policymakers should make sure that there are mechanisms in place for redress and accountability when AI systems cause harm. International Cooperation is crucial when it comes to address the global nature of AI and ensure consistent standards across the globe. As far as the role of society goes, the civil organisations or the general public should educate themselves about the good and bad sides of AI. Public awareness and education are crucial to foster informed and critical engagement. 2 Willige, A. (2024) From virtual tutors to accessible textbooks: 5 Ways Ai is transforming education, World Economic Forum. Available at: https://www. weforum.
org/agenda/2024/05/ways-ai-can-benefit-education/ (Last accessed: 28 July 2024). 3 Wirjo, A. et al. (2022) Artificial Intelligence in economic policymaking, Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation. Available at: https://www. apec. org/docs/default-source/publications/2022/11/artificial-intelligence-in-economicpolicymaking/222_psu_artificial-intelligence-in-economic-policymaking. pdf (Last accessed: 28 July 2024). 4 Berryhill, J. et al. (2019) Hello, world, OECD iLibrary. Available at: https://www. oecdilibrary. org/governance/hello-world_726fd39d-en (Last accessed: 28 July 2024).
The ethical dilemma The ethical dilemma of AI development and deployment Artificial Intelligence stands as a forefront of technological advancements, heralding transformative potential across various sectors. But this development and deployment of AI can pose severe ethical dilemmas considering the impact it has on the individuals, societies and global systems. As AI technologies advance, it is crucial to ensure that their benefits are maximised while minimising potential harm. AI offers tremendous benefits for all societies but it also presents risks. These risks can include division between the privileged and the unprivileged or the replacement of independent thought and judgement with automated control. 5AI technology has put forward game-changing promises to do things like improve efficiency, bring down costs, or accelerate research and development.
But these promises have been tempered with worries that these complex, opaque systems may do more societal harm than economic good. 6 One significant ethical dilemma is the question of bias and fairness. Type “greatest leaders of all time” in your search engine and you will probably see a list of the world’s prominent male personalities. How many women do you count? One study of UNESCO highlighted this issue. There are many examples of gender bias originating from stereotypical representations deeply rooted in our societies. 7 Another critical dilemma is privacy. AI systems usually require high amounts of data to be collected, stored and used. This can pose a great risk for privacy. The potential misuse of personal information cannot be looked down upon.
There have been increasing cases of deepfake on social media where a person’s voice or face can be used for spreading misinformation or committing financial frauds. Another major concern regarding AI is job displacement. While it can enhance creativity and productivity in the working systems, it also threatens to displace existing jobs particularly in
5 Jones, K. (2023) AI governance and Human Rights | Chatham house , Chatham House. Available at:
https://www.chathamhouse.org/2023/01/ai-governance-and-human-rights (Last accessed: 28 July 2024) 6Pazzanese, C. (2020) Ethical concerns mount as AI takes bigger decision-making role, The Harvard Gazette. Available at: https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2020/10/ethical-concerns-mount-as-ai-takes-biggerdecision-making-role/ (Last accessed: 28 July 2024).
7 Artificial Intelligence
Examples of ethical dilemmas (no date) UNESCO. org. Available at: https://www. unesco. org/en/artificial-intelligence/recommendation-ethics/cases (Last accessed: 28 July 2024). the sector of manufacturing or retail. This displacement can have far-reaching economic and social consequences, increasing inequalities and creating economic instability. Addressing this ethical dilemma requires the development of reskilling and upskilling programs for affected workers, implementing social safety nets and policies to support displaced workers, and encouraging the creation of new job opportunities in AI-related fields. The questions which arise from this issue of job displacement is accountability and control. Who will be responsible for increasing unemployment in various countries even if it is led by rapid decision making and increased productivity?
The increasing autonomy of AI systems raises questions on accountability and control. The human rights framework provides an essential foundation that can provide guardrails for efforts to exploit the enormous potential of AI, while preventing and mitigating its enormous risks. 8 The deployment of AI in decision-making processes without adequate oversight can undermine due process and lead to unjust outcomes. AI technology brings major benefits in many areas, but without the ethical considerations, there is a risk that it will reproduce real world biases and discrimination, increasing divisions and threatening fundamental human rights and freedoms. 9As AI is being increasingly integrated into our lives, the question now is: can we harness the potential of AI while also safeguarding human rights?
10 AI in the court of law Artificial Intelligence is revolutionising many aspects of our lives, including the legal sector. Although AI has not been introduced vastly in the field of law, many say that AI can make the legal decisions better and faster. AI can compile the big databases together and form a unified judgement which would cater to the individual’s needs. But how will it truly understand the needs of every party? How will we ensure that the system being used is devoid of any bias or unfairness? Let's take an example of a facial recognition system. There have been studies where this technology has shown to have higher error rates for certain racial groups leading to 8 Türk, V. (2023) Artificial intelligence must be grounded in human rights, says high commissioner , United Nations. Available at: https://www. ohchr.
org/en/statements/2023/07/artificial-intelligence-must-be-groundedhuman-rights-says-high-commissioner (Last accessed: 28 July 2024). 9 Ethics of Artificial Intelligence (no date) UNESCO. Available at: http://www. unesco. org/en/artificialintelligence/recommendation-ethics (Last accessed: 28 July 2024). 10 Anneroth, M. (2021) AI bias and human rights: Why ethical ai matters - ericsson, ericsson. com. Available at: https://www. ericsson. com/en/blog/2021/11/ai-bias-what-is-it (Last accessed: 28 July 2024). wrongful arrests and other forms of discrimination. 11 AI transcription tools create quick records of court events and hearings. This speeds up the process and cuts the cost of judicial services. It also makes records easier to access, allowing people to review them almost right after a proceeding ends.
The human aspect of stenography isn’t just about transcribing words; it’s about understanding context and nuance. And while AI has made leaps and bounds in this area, questions about accuracy persist: How do we verify or disprove any claims of inaccuracy? These are challenges that we need to address as we continue to integrate AI into the courtroom. 12 Case studies Deepfakes and misinformation Deepfakes have the technology to manipulate the voices or faces of individuals posing a serious threat about privacy and increasing the concerns about data breaching. While this technology can be helpful in entertainment and creative industries, its misuse poses much greater threats to human rights. Deepfakes are often considered a crisis of human rights. It is the hyper realistic synthetic media created using artificial intelligence.
These fabricated videos or images can be used to manipulate public opinion, damage reputations and even commit fraud. It presents a considerable threat to the right to privacy due to the use of personal images,audios or videos that depict the individual and use it for further spreading misinformation. The biggest threat of deepfake is that they can be used to target specific communities, race or gender which intensifies existing forms of discrimination, breaching the right to equality. 13 There have been alarming cases about cybersecurity. Cybercriminals can employ deepfakes to impersonate an individual and commit crimes. Meanwhile these deepfake creation tools are becoming increasingly sophisticated making it difficult to track down the criminals. They also use deepfake to fabricate and manipulate evidence posing a threat to the right to fair trial.
14 11Artificial Intelligence: Examples of ethical dilemmas (no date a) UNESCO. Available at: http://www. unesco. org/en/artificial-intelligence/recommendation-ethics/cases (Last accessed: 28 July 2024).
12 Artificial Intelligence and the law
Navigating legal challenges Clio. Available at: http://www.clio.com/resources/ai-for-lawyers/artificial-intelligence-and-the-law/ (Last accessed: 28 July 2024).
13 Ameer, S.S. (2024) Deepfakes
A crisis of human rights, RSIL. Available at: https://rsilpak. org/2024/deepfakes-a-crisis-of-human-rights/ (Last accessed: 28 July 2024). 14Ibid 13 Biggest threat to Politics During 2024 elections, the Government had made it clear that they see AI generated deepfakes as a big problem. One of which can be highlighted here is when Google Gemini was asked if the India’s Prime Minister was a fascist. This incident stimulated wide discussions about deepfake. On the contrary, Political Parties themselves use deepfake in their ranging from multilingual public addresses and personalised video messages to creating lifelike videos of deceased leaders in their political campaigning. 15 Looking at all these incidents one question which would arise in our minds is, in our relentless pursuit of technological advancements have we inadvertently created a monster?
Conclusion: Artificial intelligence presents both immense opportunities and significant challenges for human rights. While AI has the capability to decorate human life, its development and deployment have to be guided through robust moral frameworks. Ensuring transparency, duty, and fairness in AI systems is paramount. International cooperation and collaboration are important to deal with the complicated troubles at the intersection of AI and human rights. By proactively shaping the destiny of AI, we can harness its benefits whilst mitigating its risks, safeguarding the distinction and rights of all people. As we continue to explore the frontiers of AI, it is vital that we stay vigilant in shielding human rights and making sure that AI serves as a tool for the advantage of all humanity. 15 Mukherjee, M.
(2024) Ai deepfakes, bad laws – and a big fat Indian election, Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism. Available at: https://reutersinstitute. politics. ox. ac. uk/news/ai-deepfakes-bad-laws-and-big-fatindian-election (Last accessed 28 July 2024).