The Commercialisation Of Space - Opportunities And Challenges For Business
Author: LawSphereX
Category: General Law
Published:
Updated:
THE COMMERCIALISATION OF SPACE: OPPORTUNITIES
AND
CHALLENGES
FOR BUSINESS S. S. Neha Sree, School of Excellence in law, The Tamilnadu Dr. Ambedkar Law University Dr. S. Maruthavijayan, Assistant Professor, School of Excellence in Law, The Tamilnadu Dr. Ambedkar Law University
ABSTRACT
The commercialization of space highlights an effective metamorphose ascend in the productive business sphere which is accumulating both prodigious opportunities and crucial menaces. This abstract traverse the exposure of witnessing the various private sectors such as spaceX, Blue origin, virgin Galactic, their implications in the space exploration and sense of growth, analyzing the drivers, sustainability, opportunities, and pitfalls correlated with this proliferating industry. From the rapid growth deployment of creative technologies to the space-based service provisions, the commercialization of space provides a wider landscape for business development and innovation.
Nevertheless, navigating the convolution of regulatory frameworks, handling lavish amounts in addition to addressing ethical considerations, remains crucial for sustainable success in this emerging field, the global economy and the nature of human exploration. Keywords: Technology innovation, space diplomacy, Economic growth, global governance, international cooperation, private space industry, space commercialization, NewSpace.
1 INTRODUCTION
The commercialization of space has unfolded a dynamic and speedy evolving frontiers, associated with both unparalleled opportunities and consequential challenges for doing businesses, striving to claim for final frontier. These burgeoning industries, driven by a compilation of cutting-edge technologies, declining launch cost, and a growing demand for space-based services for this new era of ’NewSpace’. Once the exclusive domain of government agencies, the cosmos is now being explored and exploited by various companies, each with their ambitious goals, technology advancement. From reusable rockets and satellite constellation to space tourism, asteroid mining, private companies like spaceX, Blue origin, virgin Galactic, Rocket lab, Astra, OneWeb etc.
, are reshaping the landscape of space exploration from telecommunication and Earth observation to resource extraction and space tourism, ushering in an unprecedented commercial activity and pushing the boundaries of human ambition beyond Earth. The enticement of space economy is not pave a way to denial. Companies are in the position to access vast resources, the distinct environment in space, opening new avenues for innovation and profit. Satellite constellation are delivering an extraordinary connectivity, enabling high speed internet access in remote regions and revolutionizing data collection and observation. Earth observing satellites provide valuable insights for disaster management, agriculture, environmental monitoring. However, this nascent industry is not without its challenges.
The high cost associated with space exploration and development remains a crucial hurdle, demanding substantial investment and risk strategies. Regulatory complexities, both national and international can create a meandering legal framework that can be obstacles to innovation and stifle growth. Moreover, ethical considerations associating with space resource extraction, space debris mitigation, strong and healthy international cooperation which all require careful consideration. Navigating these challenges are significant for the long-term sustainability and success of commercial space sector. Businesses must embrace innovation, forge strategic partnerships, and proactively engage with policymakers to ensure a future humanity and fosters a thriving space economy.
This introduction sets a stage for deeper exploration of the opportunities and challenges facing business seeking to thrive in this exciting and rapidly evolving field.
2 OBJECT OF THE STUDY
1. To Examine the role of technological advancements, government policies, market demand
in shaping the commercial space industry and their investments.
2. To Evaluate the need for international cooperation, responsible space exploration practices
ethical implications and sustainability of commercial space activities.
3. To determine the economic benefit, potential risk and challenges associated with security
concern, environmental impacts.
3 METHODOLOGY
This research includes doctrinal research using secondary sources such as Journals, Articles, News, Reports and Written Publications.
3 REVIEW OF LITERATURE
The United States House Science Subcommittee on Space: “three things in particular make space exploration and development a not-so-attractive proposition: lack of financing for new ventures on a mass scale, lack of secured insurance and an inability to forge self-sustaining commercial markets. ” Anthony Velocci, in Harvard International Review: “As private enterprise begins to undertake more of the space missions... they will be tested by the same rigorous measure of success that govern traditional business ventures: return on investment. ” Dr. Scott Pace, former Executive Secretary of the National Space Council: “Private companies are bringing new ideas and new capabilities to space, and they are driving down costs. This is a positive development for the future of space exploration. ” Dr.
John Logsdon, former director of the Space Policy Institute at George Washington University: “The private sector is playing a key role in commercializing space, but there are still challenges. We need to make sure that the regulatory environment is conducive to innovation, and we need to address the issue of space debris. ” Dr. George Whitesides, former CEO of Virgin Galactic: “The private sector is bringing a new sense of urgency to space exploration. We are not just focused on science, but on creating new businesses and new markets. ” Dr. Joanne Gabrynowicz, Professor of Space Law at the University of Mississippi: “International cooperation is essential for the sustainable development of space. We need to work together to establish clear rules of the road, and to address the issue of space debris. ” Dr.
Roger Launius, former Associate Administrator for History at NASA: “Government policies need to be flexible and forward-looking to encourage innovation in the private sector. We need to create an environment where private companies can thrive and contribute to the long-term goals of space exploration. ” Dr. Bhavya Lal, former Chief of Staff at NASA: “Sustainability is a critical concern for space commercialization. We need to make sure that we are not creating a new frontier of pollution and environmental degradation. ”
4. THE
ANALYSIS
OF BUSINESS PERSPECTIVE AND STRUGGLES OF SPACE COMMERCIALIZATION:
4.1 OPPORTUNITIES FOR BUSINESSES
4.1.1. New market and services:
1 Space tourism
Elon musk once said ‘ I want to die on Mars, just not on impact’. The space tourism market is rapidly grabbing a traction with companies like spaceX, Blue Origin, Virgin Galactic pioneering commercial space travel. This market particularly plays a role by offering a suborbital flights, orbital stays and the experience of lunar travel to private individuals. The virgin Galactic has introduced ‘spaceshiptwo’, it’s a flight will be release from 50. 000 feet for
6 minutes of weightlessness and breathing view. Zero G Corporation uses a modified Boeing
727-200 aircraft in order to offer a zero-gravity experience to it’s customers. The people inside the aircraft do not, actually, float in zero gravity, they just experience the same effect since the aircraft reaches a certain altitude and then pitches down with exactly the acceleration of gravity. The potential of profit is worthwhile, as there is a widening of modern highly influential demographic of affluent individuals showing interest towards unique and adventurous exposures. In this regard, public enterprises like NASA, ISRO, Roscosmos, JAXA, ESA, CNSA, CSA, ASA etc., play a significant role by establishing the regulations and safety standards to ensure passenger security and environmental sustainability.
2 Satellite-based services
The exigency for satellite services is enlarging rapidly, driven by applications in telecommunications, Earth observation (A NASA centre – Goddard Space Flight Centre is responsible for developing and operating Earth–observing satellites and conducting space science research), and GPS. Private entities are highly launching small satellites, or cubesats, which is in advantage of providing services like high – speed internet (by companies like spaceX (Starlink), OneWeb, Amazon(Kuiper)), remote sensing, and also performs as data analytics to various industries, including disaster management, agriculture and urban planning where public entities can collaborate with private enterprises to enhance data sharing capabilities, support environmental monitoring activities and improve safeguarding the public.
3 Space infrastructure
As the space economy grows, there is an increasing demand for robust infrastructure, including launch facilities, spaceports, and in-orbit servicing stations, this market demand encourages the private entities to invest in and develop these infrastructure ( Examples include SpaceX’s starbase, blue origin’s Glenn launch vehicle), government-funded research institutions like JPL (A NASA research and developmental centre responsible for designing, building and operating for robotic space craft) ensuring safety and efficient operation which encourages other private entities to throw off their interest by investing in it and the exploration for innovation.
4 Resource extraction
The concept, briefly, is “the exploitation of raw materials from asteroids and other minor planets, including near-Earth objects”. Asteroid mining will produce the world’s first trillionaire, according to Goldman Sachs, the investment company is very confident that technology is reaching the point where asteroid mining will actually be possible in the near future.
While resource harvesting on earth has been limited by numerous legal barriers, space has no hurdles limiting the financial interest of the companies keen on exploring the possibility The extraction of resource from outer space is an emerging area of interest where private entities usually draw boundaries by themselves in involving mining for water, metals and other materials in the Earth but this commercialization of space expand their view and broadening their business by giving hand to extraction from moon, asteroid and other celestial bodies that could support long -term space mission and potentially the resources from them brought back to earth shows efficient profit where public entities establish frameworks and international agreement to govern resource use.
At the moment companies such as Deep Space Industries and Planetary Resources are making their moves in order to “move in” fast, so they are currently working with the government of Luxembourg, which helps by funding the research and development of the necessary technology. “Our goal is to put into place an overall framework for the exploration and commercial use of resources from ‘celestial bodies’ such as asteroids, or from the moon,” said the deputy prime minister of Luxembourg, Etienne Schneider. Of course, there is still a long road ahead, since no actual mining missions have been planned but the figurative companies have analyzed the prospect thoroughly. Asteroid mining, like every other ambitious plan, has an extensive scientific and technological background on which it is based.
Asteroids vary both on size and composition, they are often classified according to the type of light they reflect. Studies on samples of meteorites that have fallen to earth have shown that there is a variety of materials that can be extracted. Firstly, platinum is one of the most valuable materials that could be harvested, not only for its use in luxury products but for its usability in the industry. Platinum is widely used in electronics and in chemical reactions as a catalyst. Car manufacturers, only, used $7 billion worth of platinum in 2012. Palladium, also, can be harvested form asteroids which has similar uses to platinum but it is harder. Finally, water is one of the primary resources that can be extracted. Actually, water is the core of Deep Space Industries’ work and it will be the first resource they will harvest.
“Water is the most abundant chemical compound in the Universe”, as they say, it is fundamental for life and it has a great value in space missions. It is vital in order to sustain life in space due to its uses for drinking, agriculture (on space stations) and radiation shielding. Moreover, water can be broken down to its primary elements (hydrogen and oxygen) and used as rocket fuel. In fact, it is the basis of the propulsion systems of small satellites such as DSI’s market - optimized Comet thruster. The company is confident that water will be the main exchangeable commodity in space in the near future, “Water is the core resource that will support businesses and the humans in space”, they say. This ensures efficient access to resources and promotes sustainable practices to minimize environmental impact.
4.1.2 Technological Advancements
1. Reusable launch vehicles: By the development of reusable launch vehicles has drastically
scale down the cost of accessing space. Companies like spaceX have pioneered this technology with their Falcon 9 rocket, which can land back on Earth after delivering payloads to orbit.
This capability allows for multiple launches with the same vehicle, lowering cost and increasing the frequency of launches. Other companies like Blue origin with its New Shepard uses reusable rocket technology and has the capacity to fit 6 passengers into it which gives 10 minutes space view showcase exploration to passengers, are also exploring reusable technology for suborbital flights. The reusable rocket will revolutionize the space travel as it reduce replacement cost and rocket fuel said by Elon musk.
2 Advancements in propulsion systems
Innovations in propulsion systems, such as iron thrusters and hybrid rockets providing a efficient ways to propel spacecraft. For instances, , NASA’s Dawn spacecraft utilized ion propulsions to travel to the asteroid belt, demonstrating how this technology can enable long-duration missions with less fuel. Private companies like Rocket Lab are also developing advanced propulsion systems for their Electro rocket, and the performance of payload capacity is highly concentrated by Blue Origin said by Dr. Erika Wagner, Blue origin a head of payload program.
3 Miniaturisation of satellites
This technology has led to rise of CubeSats and small satellites which are highly cheap for building and launching purposes. The companies like planet Labs and Spire Global are weighing small satellites for Earth observation and data collection. This miniature satellites are deployed for large constellation, providing more frequent and detailed data for various applications from agriculture to climate changing.
4 Artificial Intelligence and Robotics
This technology reduce human involvement and enhance mission capabilities in space application. For instances, NASA’s Mars rovers, such as perseverance, utilized AI to navigate and analyze the Martian surface autonomously. Private entities like Astrobotic are developing robotic systems for lunar exploration and focusing on delivering payloads to the Moon’s surface. As space travel concern government matter but according to Tom captain (vice chairman of aerospace and defence at consultancy Deloitte) which prioritize public spending into the hibernation, that technology improvement like Home isolation, Computerized Axial Tomography encourages the entities to look into the space exploration and investing in it.
4.1.3 Government support and regulations
Government offers grants, tax breaks and subsidies which encourage the private investment in space projects in addition to this they collaborate with private companies as joint ventures support in pooling resources, provide access to valuable data from space assets, facilitating research and development of private companies. The both public and private companies are benefited in space activities by government investment in infrastructure such as launch facilities, research center, ground station. The public -private partnerships are focused by regulations on contractual framework which defines the roles, responsibility and intellectual property rights as well as by effective regulations on dispute resolution mechanisms where the controversies arises between public and private partners.
The government also focus on regulation which strengths the accountability for public funds and transparency in decision making. The successful example for public private partnership in space are NASA ‘s Commercial Crew program: This program partnered with spaceX and Boeing to develop commercial spacecraft to transport astronauts to international space station, ESA’ Earth observation partnership. The international regulations, liabilities and insurance coverage in space: The well versed regulations for commercialization of space is outer space Treaty (International agreement) in which signed by most countries, establishes the principle of “national responsibility”, peaceful use of outer space, non-appropriation of celestial bodies and international cooperation. As per this treaty, the countries are liable for damages caused by space objects irrespective of who operates them.
Other relevant international regulations such as the liability convention which provides framework for resolving claims for damage caused by space object. It covers both ground and space damage, the registration convention which require the state to register their space object with United Nations, the rescue agreement which states about the procedure for the rescue of space astronauts and the return of spaces. The companies which involved in commercialization of spaces has space insurances provided by insurance companies like AIG, Lockton where they offers specialized insurances solution for space industry, Marsh McLennan where they provides risk management and insurance services for space ventures, Hiscox where offers insurance for space launches and satellites.
Basically insurances are claimed as coverage in which policies covers a range of risks, including launch failures, in-orbit accidents, damage to spacecraft, loss of data and liability for ground damage and as premium, which are high due to inherent risks involved in space activities. Factors like mission complexity, launch vehicle and payload value influence the cost.
Most of the regulations by government are governed by their respective national laws which differ according to their perspective such as license permitting for launching vehicle, operate satellites and conduct other space activities. These regulations often cover safety, environmental impact, and national security, regulations related to data ownership and Access which collected from space assets, especially data from commercial or scientific value and regulations related to address the potential impact on space debris and atmospheric pollution for the companies.
4.2 CHALLENGES
FOR BUSINESSES
4.2.1 High costs and risks
1. Significant Upfront Investment: Developing and launching space infrastructure requires
substantial upfront investment, often exceeding the financial capabilities of many companies, particularly startups. This can be a major barrier to entry.
2 Uncertain Returns on Investment
The market for commercial space services is still nascent and evolving, making it difficult to predict long-term returns on investment. The potential for high returns is there, but so is the risk of losing significant investments.
3 Potential for Technical Failures
Space is a harsh environment, and technical failures during launch, in-orbit operations, or during data collection can lead to significant financial losses, delays, and damage to reputation.
4 Regulatory Uncertainty and Legal Complexities
The legal and regulatory landscape for commercial space activities is complex and evolving, with international treaties, national laws, and industry best practices all playing a role. Navigating this complexity can be costly and time-consuming, adding to the overall risk of ventures.
4.2.2 Competition and Market Saturation
1. Increased Competition: The essence of growing number of players in the space industry,
filled with technological advancements and hardly lower barriers to entry, leads to intense competition for customers, government contracts, and affect the investment. This can drive down prices, make it harder to differentiate, and make it challenging for new entrants to gain a foothold.
2 Potential for Price Wars
As companies are competing for market share, they may often engage in price wars, lowering prices to attract customers. This can be detrimental to profitability, especially for startups with limited resources.
3 Market Consolidation
To survive in the field of commercialization of space many companies may merge or be acquired by larger players which leading to market consolidation and result in reduction in the number of independent companies. Some of the Real-World Examples under below:
1 Small Satellite Market
The small satellite market has seen a surge in companies offering launch services, satellite manufacturing, and data analytics. This intense competition has made negative view for launch prices and forced some companies to merge or be acquired. For example, Planet Labs acquired Spire Global, two prominent players in the small satellite market.
2 Earth Observation Data
The market regarding Earth observation data is turning up with increasingly piled up with companies offering a wide range of services, from weather forecasting to environmental monitoring. This result to price competition and a need for companies to differentiate themselves from other competitive companies by offering valueadded services and unique product features that meets the demand of customers.
3 Space Tourism
The emerging market of space tourism is put forth a rise in companies by offering suborbital and orbital flights. As a result of this competition which led to a race to lower prices and comes up with more innovative experiences, with companies like Virgin Galactic and Blue Origin vying for customers.
4.2.3 Sustainability, environmental and national security concerns
1. Sustainability and Environmental Concerns:
1 Space Debris
The growing number of launch vehicles and satellites contributes to space debris, which poses a risk of collision to operational spacecraft and acts as an obstacle to future space exploration.
2 Orbital Pollution
As the consequences of Satellites and rocket parts harmful chemicals release and particles into the atmosphere, potentially affecting the environment and climate.
3 Light Pollution
satellites are a big reason for the contribution to light pollution, especially large constellations, which result in disturbing astronomical observation as well as creating an impact on wildlife.
2 National Concerns
1. National Security: Space debris results in threatening national security by interfering with
military and intelligence satellites.
2 International Cooperation
Managing space debris requires international cooperation which is highly difficult to cope up due to different opinions of various countries to establish regulations and standards regarding responsibility for space activities.
3 Ethical Considerations for Space Research and Extraction
1. Resource Extraction: The potential for mining asteroids and other celestial bodies raises
ethical questions about resource ownership, environmental impact, and potential conflicts
2 Space Tourism
The rise of space tourism raises concerns about the environmental impact of space travel and the potential for harm to the fragile space environment. Reality Faced by Companies:
1 Regulation and Compliance
Space companies are facing increasing pressure from regulators to address sustainability and ethical concerns.
2 Investment and Public Perception
Investors and the public are increasingly scrutinizing companies’ sustainability practices and ethical considerations.
3 Innovation and Mitigation
Companies are investing in technologies and practices to mitigate space debris, reduce pollution, and ensure responsible resource extraction.
4.2.4 Geopolitical. tension
1. Militarization of Space:
1 Tensions and Arms Race
The potential for militarization of space raises concerns about an arms race in orbit, with countries developing space-based weapons systems.
2 Escalation of Conflict
The deployment of weapons in space could escalate existing conflicts or create new ones, potentially leading to a dangerous arms race
3 Disruption of Space Activities
Military activities in space could disrupt civilian space activities, including scientific research, satellite communications, and space exploration.
2 Ownership of Space Resources
1. Legal Uncertainty: There is no clear international agreement on the ownership of space
resources, leading to disputes and potential conflicts.
2 Commercial Exploitation
The growing interest in mining asteroids and other celestial bodies raises questions about the ownership and distribution of these resources.
3 National Claims
Some countries have asserted claims to specific areas of space or resources, creating tensions and potential for conflict.
3 International Agreements and Regulations
1. Outer Space Treaty: The 1967 Outer Space Treaty forbade the placement of mass destruction
weapons in orbit, but it fails to address various other military activities in space.
2 Lack of Enforcement
Existing international agreements are lack of efficient enforcement mechanisms which becomes to burden to prevent or address violations.
3 Emerging Regulations
New agreements and regulations are being developed to address the specific issues related to space debris, resource extraction, and responsible space activities, which were previously unknown to many countries, to grab the opportunities to expand their business by making use of regulations to address their losses, etc. Real-Time Incidents:
1 Anti-Satellite Tests
Countries have conducted anti-satellite tests, creating debris fields that pose risks to other spacecraft.
2 Space Force Development
Countries are establishing space forces to develop military capabilities in space, further fueling concerns about militarization.
3 Resource Extraction Disputes
Companies are facing legal challenges and disputes over their claims to space resources.
5 SUGGESTIONS
Here are some suggestions for improving the commercialization of space:
1. The government should provide initiatives in highlighting the difficulties faced by
companies to retain in space commercialization due financial struggles, lack of technology accessibility
2. By simplifying regulatory processes and by creating a high predictable environment would
encourage more businesses to enter the space sector.
3. There should be broadening of collaboration between countries which reduces cost risk and
shares resources and fill the space sectors with innovative ideas.
4. There should be encouragement in investing in the space infrastructure such as space station,
outer spacecraft which pages for working environment that result in growth of space sector.
5. Focusing on developing the space based services like broadband internet, Earth observation,
navigation create a new applications for space technology will drive further commercialization.
6. Encouraging research work and development regarding space based technologies as well as
services along with supporting entrepreneurship and will pave way for development of new services and products that can drive commercialization.
7. As the space sector improves, it’s necessary to address ethical and environmental concerns
related to space debris, pollution, resource extraction, and the potential for conflicts in space which stops the negative view of commercialization.
8. There should be easy available platforms to grab information of working condition of space
industries and to encourage the startup companies to do business in space exploration by creating awareness about the opportunities for businesses in that.
By focusing on these areas that can create more vibrant and sustainable space economy that benefits businesses, government and humanity as whole.
6 CONCLUSION
The commercialization of space presents a wealth of opportunities for businesses, offering access to new markets, resources, and technologies. However, navigating this frontier requires careful consideration of potential pitfalls. While the potential for profit is significant, the high costs, regulatory complexities, and inherent risks associated with space ventures demand a robust business model and a long-term vision. Successful ventures will require a balance between technological innovation, financial prudence, and a commitment to responsible space exploration, ensuring that the benefits of space commercialization are realized while safeguarding the future of this unique environment. The commercialisation of space widens once business views and prospects lead to successful economic growth by fostering hands-on improvement of economic benefits.
References:
1. Bamigboye, A. (2021). The Prospect of Investment Banking and Arbitration in the Space
Economy. DOI: 10. 31219/osf. io/kpx8
2. Brichta, M. (2022). Spin-In and Procurement Support as Key Components for Industry
Development in Emerging Space Countries. New Space, 10(3), 284-288. DOI: 10. 1089/space.
2021. 0014
3. Castaño, A. G. T. , Ramirez, L. J. R. , & Ramirez, R. A. V. (2022). Effect on the new
investments that the industry and commerce tax has on the business organizations of the municipality of Armenia Quindío-Colombia. Finance, Markets and Valuation, 8(1), 27-49. DOI: 10. 46503/phxs7354
4. Christensen, C. B. , Stroup, T. , Boensch, N. J. , Dolgopolov, A. V. , Herrera, C. R. , Jones,
T. , & Smith, P. M. (2022). The Commercial Satellite Industry: Key Indicators and Global Trends in the Context of Expanding Space Commerce. In ASCEND 2022 (p. 4251). DOI: 10. 2514/6. 2022-4251
5. de Waal A. A. (2018). The Probable Contribution of the Post-2030 Space Industry to Global
Economic Development. Post 2030-Agenda and the Role of Space: The UN 2030 Goals and Their Further Evolution Beyond 2030 for Sustainable Development, 71-82. DOI: 10. 1007/978-3-319-78954-5_6
6. Delphine, D. , Witte, P. A. , Hartmann, T. , & Spit, T. J. M. (2019). For the greater good?: A
critical reflection on assessing indirect economic effects caused by large transport projects. Open Journal of Civil Engineering, 9(2), 135-156.
7. World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2023, 20(03), 952 965 964 [8] Dennis,
A. C. K. , Wankuru, P. C. , Awiti, C. A. , Mutie, C. K. , Sanya, S. O. , Angelique, U. , ... & Lange, S. (2018). In Search of Fiscal Space: Government Spending and Taxation-Who Benefits? (No. 130556, pp. 1-88). The World Bank.
8 Dyer, J. (2015). Expanding Our Celestial Horizons
The Potential Impact of Developing a Space Sector Economy to the Future of Africa.
9 Gomber, P. , Koch, J. A. , & Siering, M. (2017). Digital Finance and FinTech
current research and future research directions. Journal of Business Economics, 87, 537-580. Doi. org/10. 1007/s11573-017-0852-x
10. Groshev, I. , & Koblov, S. (2021). Russia in the global market of Space technologies,
industry and services. Obshchestvo I ekonomika, 12, 81-103. DOI:10.
31857/S0207367600178256
11. Habiba, S. , Kazemi, H. , & Sadeghi, M. (2022). The Intellectual Property Rights and
Transfer of Technology in Space Industry. Space Science and Technology, 15(1), 111-124. DOI: 10. 30699/jsst. 2022. 1331
12. Iacomino, C. (2018). Evolution of innovation mechanisms to support the post-2030 agenda
goals: Case study on the European space exploration programme. Post 2030-Agenda and the Role of Space: The UN 2030 Goals and Their Further Evolution Beyond 2030 for Sustainable Development, 107-119. DOI: 10. 1007/978-3-319-78954-5_9.
13. Jaehnichen, T. (2020). The dynamics of economic action and the problems of its social
embedding Ethical challenges in view of the nascent commercial use of outer space. HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies, 76(1). DOI: 10. 4102/hts. v76i1. 5996
14. Kawamata, T. (2018). Geo-Political Economy and Ecosystem in Asian I&CT Markets. 22nd
Biennial Conference of the International Telecommunications Society (ITS): “Beyond the Boundaries: Challenges for Business, Policy and Society”, Seoul, Korea, 24th-27th June, http://hdl. handle. net/10419/190414
15. Khan, Z. , Wild, T. B. , Iyer, G. , Hejazi, M. , & Vernon, C. R. (2021). The future evolution
of energy-water-agriculture interconnectivity across the US. Environmental Research Letters, 16(6), DOI 10. 1088/1748-9326/ac046c 16. Khan, M. A. , & Sagar, P. (2015). Emerging trends and advanced SWOT analysis of ecommerce in Indian context. International Journal of Science Technology & Management, 4(2), 150-159.
17. Odularu, G. , Adetunji, B. , Odularu, A. (2020). Conclusion and Policy Recommendations:
Creating an Enabling Business Ecosystem for Fostering Trade Opportunities in the Digital Age.
In: Odularu, G. , Hassan, M. , Babatunde, M. (eds) Fostering Trade in Africa. Advances in African Economic, Social and Political Development. Springer, Cham.
18. oxford Analytica (2020), “Risks and opportunities 2021: Former Soviet states”, Expert
Briefings.
19. https://doi. org/10. 1108/OXAN-GA258502 [27] Pelicioni, L. C. , Ribeiro, J. R. , Devezas,
T. , Belderrain, M. C. N. , & Melo, F. C. L. D. (2018). Application of a bibliometric tool for studying space technology trends. Journal of Aerospace Technology and Management, 10.
DOI: 10. 5028/JATM. V10. 830