The Role Of Artificial Intelligence And Big Data In Securities Regulation And Insider Trading Detection
Author: LawSphereX
Category: Corporate & Insolvency
Published:
Updated:
THE ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND BIG
DATA IN SECURITIES REGULATION AND INSIDER
TRADING DETECTION
[How regulatory bodies are using AI to track suspicious trading activity: A comparative analysis of technological advancements in securities law enforcement - The ethical implications of AI-driven regulatory oversight] Ms. Drishti Garg, Law College Dehradun, Uttaranchal University Prof. Dr. Radhey Shyam Jha, Law College Dehradun, Uttaranchal University
ABSTRACT
In the digital age, artificial intelligence (AI) has recognized financial data security by revolutionized financial data security by providing cutting-edge tools for identifying, reducing, and averting cyber threats. This study examines the integration of AI technologies in the financial industry, emphasizing automated threat identification, predictive security analytics, and regulatory compliance. The foundations of AI in cyber security, the difficulties in protecting financial data, and the moral ramifications are important topics of conversation. Future development, are also looked at, including autonomous security operations, quantum-resistant cryptography, and the development of moral AI governance.
This study highlights the vital role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) plays in bolstering financial cyber security by examining the current practices, new developments, and regulatory environments. In addition to improving resilience against changing threats, the responsible deployment of AI – driven breakthroughs guarantees trust, compliance, and operational efficiency across financial ecosystems. Keywords: Artificial Intelligence (AI), Financial Data Security, Cyber security, Predictive Security Analytics, Automated Threat Detection, Regulatory Compliance, Ethical AI, fraud detection, behavior detection, data mining, AI-Powered Trade Surveillance, Insider Trading Detection, Explainable AI (XAI), SEBI Regulatory Framework.
1. Introduction
Financial institutions have previously unheard-of difficulties safeguarding sensitive data from ever-more-sophisticated cyber threats in today’s linked digital world. Ensuring strong financial data security has become crucial due to the quick digitization of financial services and the rise in data breaches. This paper examines how Artificial Intelligence (AI) might improve the security of protecting financial data. It looks at the fundamentals of protecting financial data as well as the major obstacles that organizations must overcome. Financial institutions may strengthen their defenses against fraud, data breaches and other cyber threats by utilizing AI-driven capabilities like anomaly detection, predictive analytics and automated reaction systems.
Additionally, AI redefines conventional methods to cyber security by streamlining operations and enhancing the efficacy of security measures. This opens the door to investigating how AI-driven solutions are revolutionizing the security of financial data, offering insightful information about their uses, benefits and moral dilemmas. Understanding AI’s revolutionary potential is crucial for retaining confidence and sustaining financial stability as financial institutions struggle with the challenges of managing sensitive data in digital era.
2. Challenges and Risks to Robust Financial Data Security
Rapid technological breakthroughs and more complex cyber threats make protecting financial data in the current digital era a major concern. A number of important issues need to be resolved in order to provide robust security safeguards for private financial data: i. Evolving cyber threats: Cyber criminals are always improving their strategies, using advanced techniques such as ransomware, malware, and phishing to target financial institutions. These threats pose serious dangers to the security of financial data by exploiting flaws in systems, networks, and user behavior. ii. Challenges with the Regulatory Compliance: Complying with stringent data privacy laws, including the privacy laws, including the CCPA and GDPR, makes financial data security initiatives more difficult. To protect consumer data from illegal access and
breaches, financial institutions must strike a balance between adhering to these regulatory frameworks and putting robust security measures in place. iii. Insider Threats: Insider such as partners, contractors, employees may purposefully or inadvertently compromise sensitive financial data. Sustained monitoring, through staff awareness initiatives, and strong access controls are all necessary to prevent insider threats. iv. Consequences of data breach: Data breaches can have serious financial repercussions, such as monetary losses, fines from the government, damage to one’s reputation, and legal obligations. Reducing the impact on financial institutions and their clients requires early notice and action. v.
Challenges in Modernizing Legacy Systems: A lot of financial organizations still use antiquated IT systems that might not be highly secure or easily interact with AI-powered solutions. These are compatibility, scalability, and resource management issues when integrating AI with current infrastructure. vi. Data volume and complexity: It can be difficult to monitor, analyze, and protect information from risks due to the enormous volume and complexity of financial data collected on a daily basis. AI offers practical ways for managing large datasets and identifying irregularities that can indicate impossible security lapses. A complete approach that incorporates regulatory compliance, proactive risk management, and
technology development is necessary to overcome these obstacles. Financial organizations can improves their security measures while maintaining the integrity and trust of financial data by using AI for threat detection, anomaly identification and automated responses.
3. Core Concepts of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Security
Since, AI offers sophisticated capabilities for real-time threat identification, response, and mitigation, it is completely changing cyber security. The core of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in security is the use of deep learning models and machine learning algorithms to evaluate massive datasets, identify trends, and make decisions on their own to improve security.
i. Machine learning algorithm – Supervised, unsupervised, and reinforcement learning algorithms are used by AI-powered security systems to detect irregularities, categorize dangers, and foresee possible security threats. While unsupervised learning find patterns in unlabeled data, supervised learning uses annotated datasets to train models. Systems can learn from encounters and improve their decision-making over time with reinforcement learning. ii. Behavioral Analytics in AI Security – AI makes it easier to create behavioral analytics models that specify typical user, device, and networks behavior patterns. Alerts are triggered by any departures from these established norms, enabling proactive threat detection and mitigation before any damage is done. iii.
Security and Natural Language Processing (NLP) – AI systems can now analyze and comprehend human language in real time thanks to natural language processing (NLP), which improves communication among security experts, automates responses to security incidents, and increases threat information collecting. iv. Using Predictive Analytics in Security – AI foresees possible security threats before they materialize by utilizing trend analysis and previous data analysis. By identifying irregularities and questionable activity, predictive analytics system enable preventative actions to lower risks. v. AI-Driven Automation and Orchestration – AI powered automation enhances security operations by handling routine tasks such as threat detection, incident response, and vulnerability management.
Orchestration ensures the seamless integration and coordination of security tools and processes across an organization. vi. Adversarial Machine Learning in Security – Given that attackers might try to influence AI Systems, adversarial machine learning approaches on spotting and thwarting malevolent efforts to trick AI algorithm and compromise security. vii. Making AI Explainable and Transparent – Maintaining explainability and openness is crucial for fostering confidence and comprehending the results of AI systems’ autonomous decision-making. Techniques such as explainability frameworks and
interpretable machine learning models aid in the clarification of AI-driven security judgments.
4. Case Study: BlackRock’s Measures to Stop Insider Trading
BlackRock, a well-known international asset management company that manages billions of dollars’ worth of investments in a variety of marketplaces, is the subject of this case study. BlackRock sought to put in place a strong insider trading may lead to large financial losses, fines from the government and damage to the company’s reputation.
5. Putting Insider Trading Prevention Techniques into Practice
BlackRock used a variety of cutting-edge strategies to successfully detect and stop insider trading: i. Data Integration: The Company combined data from multiple sources, such as corporate announcements, staff communications, and trading activity. This large dataset provided a thorough viewpoint on possible insider trading activity and served as the basis for a thorough investigation. ii. Using Machine Learning to Identify Insider Trading: To examine trading patterns and behaviors, BlackRock employed advanced machine learning (ML) algorithms, such as supervised learning approaches and anomaly detection models. The company was able to identify anomalous activity that diverged from normal patterns by training these models on historical trade data.
Transactions that happened right before significant market-moving news were specially targeted by the algorithms, which flagged them for additional examination (Johnson & Wang, 2021). iii. Utilizing NLP for Enhanced Detection: BlackRock used NLP techniques to analyze employee communications, such as emails and chat messages, in order to improve its detection capabilities. By monitoring language patterns and identifying keywords associated with sensitive information, the system was able to identify conversations that could be connected to questionable trading activities (Miller & Roberts, 2022). iv. Real-Time Monitoring and Alert System – BlackRock put in place a real-time monitoring system to keep an eye on staff communications and trading activity. The
compliance team received immediate notifications for additional review when the algorithms detected unusual trading patterns or reported questionable messages. The company was able to react quickly and reduce possible insider trading concerns before they became more serious because to this proactive approach.
6. Enhancing Global Regulatory Synergy Through AI (SEBI, SEC, ESMA)
According to research, AI-based risk assessment models make it easier to share data in real time with global regulatory agencies like the European Securities Commission (ESMA) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the United States. This technical development strengthens SEBI's compliance with international regulatory requirements and improves the efficacy of cross-border enforcement.
6.1 Empirical Evidence and Scholarly Perspectives
Broeders & Prenio (2018) highlighted the necessity of improved regulatory cooperation and the significance of Supervisory Technology (SupTech) as a key tool for international financial supervision. • Avramović (2023) looked at the Financial Conduct Authority's (FCA) AI-powered compliance systems in the UK, showing how technology-driven supervision is changing contemporary financial regulation.
6.2 Regulatory Implications and Strategic Impact
Artificial intelligence (AI)-powered monitoring solutions improve oversight and response by giving authorities cross-jurisdictional, real-time insight into insider trading activity. • A blockchain-based data-sharing platform facilitates smooth adherence to international financial norms by streamlining and expediting cross-border regulatory enforcement.
7. Suggestions for Policy
Enforce AI-Powered Trade Surveillance: To enhance the identification of illegal trading activity, SEBI should require all financial institutions and market intermediaries to use AI-
driven monitoring systems. Put Blockchain-Based Trade Recording into Practice: By using blockchain-based logging systems, transaction records will be impenetrable, increasing transparency and accountability after a trade. Improve International Regulatory Cooperation: To enable smooth cross-border enforcement and data sharing in insider trading investigations, SEBI should aggressively fortify alliances with global regulators such as the SEC (USA) and ESMA (EU).
8. The Future Unfolds: AI-Led Transformation of Financial Ecosystems
This study highlights how blockchain-based compliance technologies and AI-powered surveillance have revolutionized SEBI's capacity to identify and prevent insider trading. The study finds significant gains in detection accuracy, regulatory clarity, and evidential reliability by combining blockchain-enabled transaction logging through smart contracts with sophisticated machine learning models—more especially, CNN and LSTM architectures—for anomaly detection. The results show that while blockchain guarantees unchangeable, transparent, and auditable compliance records, AI systems perform noticeably better than traditional surveillance techniques. Additionally, by demonstrating how advancements in RegTech and SupTech can successfully bridge regulatory enforcement gaps, this work contributes to the conversation on Regulatory Arbitrage Theory and Behavioral Law & Economics.
In order to better prevent insider trading, it urges SEBI to implement blockchain-secured transaction records, AI-driven trade monitoring systems, and enhanced whistleblower safeguards.
8.1 Policy Recommendations for SEBI
The following legislative actions should be taken by SEBI in order to improve the enforcement of insider trading laws: • To enhance the real-time identification of questionable trading patterns, stock exchanges and financial institutions should be required to implement AI-powered surveillance. • For high-value transactions, enforce the usage of blockchain-based trade logging to protect data integrity and stop post-deal manipulation and tampering.
Encourage closer cross-border regulatory collaboration with international partners including the SEC (USA) and ESMA (EU), which will facilitate effective data exchange and coordination in investigations into insider trading. 8. 2 Future Directions for AI-Powered Financial Data Protection AI's trajectory in financial data security suggests ongoing innovation, which will drastically alter cybersecurity tactics used by the financial sector as a whole. The future of AI in protecting financial ecosystems is anticipated to be defined by a number of new developments as technology capabilities grow and cyber threats become more complex. a. Advanced Threat Intelligence Integration: AI systems will increasingly combine several threat intelligence streams, such as insights from global threat landscapes, realtime cybersecurity feeds, and dark web monitoring.
These technologies will improve predictive and preemptive threat detection by utilizing advanced analytics and machine learning, enabling financial institutions to remain ahead of changing cyber threats. b. AI-Powered Autonomous Response: An important development in cybersecurity will be the creation of autonomous reaction capabilities. AI systems will be able to identify, evaluate, and react to security threats on their own in real time, reducing the need for human participation. These automated reactions could involve implementing defensive countermeasures, starting containment procedures, or separating impacted systems. The entire resilience of financial systems will be strengthened by this progression, which will significantly increase reaction time and reduce the harm caused by cyber attacks. c.
Quantum Computing and Post-Quantum Security: AI will play a key role in developing next-generation security protocols and quantumresistant encryption methods once quantum computing becomes a reality. Financial institutions can create post-quantum cryptography solutions that are adaptive and protect sensitive data from quantum attacks' unparalleled computational power by utilizing artificial intelligence (AI). This ensures data security and integrity over the long run.
d. Explainable AI and Trust-Building: The transparency and interpretability of AIdriven cyber security choices will be greatly enhanced by the emergence of Explainable AI (XAI). AI models that provide transparent, intelligible insights into risk assessments and threat responses will be used by financial institutions more and more. Gaining the confidence of regulators, clients, and internal stakeholders will need a focus on explainability, which will guarantee prudent AI deployment in delicate financial situations. 8. 3 Prospective Research Paths Future studies should examine how blockchain-based compliance architectures may be improved, how AI surveillance tools can be extended to decentralized finance (DeFi) marketplaces, and how AI-generated trade alerts can be legally standardized across foreign regulatory regimes.
In order for SEBI to become a fully AI-enabled regulatory agency that can safeguard investors, maintain market integrity, and maximize enforcement effectiveness in the digital era, this paper lays out a strategic technology roadmap.
9. Conclusion: The Contribution of AI to Enhanced Cyber Security
The fundamental ideas of artificial intelligence (AI) in security cover a broad spectrum of tools and tactics that, when combined, improve the efficiency and robustness of cyber security defenses. Organizations can protect sensitive data and maintain business continuity in an increasingly digital and linked world by proactively detecting and eliminating threats through the use of AI-driven machine learning, behavioral analytics and predictive analytics.
REFERENCES
Aggrawal, N., & Pandey, A., 2025. Leveraging Internet of Behavior analytics to enhance retail stock trading: A strategic framework for optimized trading and market dynamics. In: Chhabra, G., Singh, T., Kumar, M. (Eds.), Mapping human data and behavior with the Internet of Behavior (IoB). IGI Global Scientific Publishing, pp. 435–496. https://doi.org/10.4018/979-8-3693-7545-7.ch015. • Al Mamun, A., Hossain, M. S., Rishad, S. S. I., Rahman, M. M., Shakil, F., Choudhury, M.
Z. M. E., Sultana, S., 2024. Machine learning for stock market security measurement: A
comparative analysis of supervised, unsupervised, and deep learning models. The American Journal of Engineering and Technology 6(11), 63–76. • Azuikpe, P. F. , Fabuyi, J. A. , Balogun, A. Y. , Adetunji, P. A. , Peprah, K. N. , Mmaduekwe, E. , Ejidare, M. C. , 2024. The necessity of artificial intelligence in fintech for SupTech and RegTech supervisory in banks and financial organizations. International Journal of Science and Research Archive 12(2), 2853–2860. • Avramović, P. , 2023. Digital transformation of financial regulators and the emergence of supervisory technologies (SupTech): A case study of the UK Financial Conduct Authority. Harvard Data Science Review 5(2). • Bauguess, S. W. , 2017. The role of big data, machine learning, and AI in assessing risks: A regulatory perspective. SEC Keynote Address: OpRisk North America. • Broeders, D. , Prenio, J. , 2018.
Innovative technology in financial supervision (SupTech): The experience of early users. Financial Stability Institute/Bank for International Settlements. • Cheng, G. , Lundblad, C. T. , Yang, Z. , Zhang, Q. , 2022. Detecting insider trading in the era of big data and machine learning. SSRN.
Retrieved from https://ssrn.com/abstract=4240205 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4240205. • CIO SEA, 2024. AI: The invisible hand steering blockchain’s evolution. The Economic Times, February 12. Retrieved from https://ciosea.economictimes.indiatimes.com/blog/aithe-invisible-hand-steering-blockchains-evolution/109388874. • Deo, S., 2022. The under-appreciated regulatory challenges posed by algorithms in FinTech: Understanding interactions among users, firms, algorithm decision systems & regulators. Doctoral dissertation, Hertie School. • Economic Times Legal, 2024. SEBI chief highlights AI integration and tech-driven reforms in capital markets regulation. The Economic Times, February 20. Retrieved From
https://legal. economictimes. indiatimes. com/news/regulators/sebi-chief-highlights-aiintegration-and-tech- driven-reforms-in-capital-markets-regulation/117272016. • Hajj, M. E. , Hammoud, J. , 2023. Unveiling the influence of artificial intelligence and machine learning on financial markets: A comprehensive analysis of AI applications in trading, risk management, and financial operations. JRFM 16(10), 1–16. • Harris, H. , 2022. Artificial intelligence and policing of financial crime: A legal analysis of the state of the field. In: Financial Technology and the Law: Combating Financial Crime, pp. 281–299. • Li, X. , Sun, S. X. , Chen, K. , Fung, T. , Wang, H. , 2015. Design theory for market surveillance systems. Journal of Management Information Systems 32(2), 278–313. • Maheshwari, S. , Chatnani, N. N. , 2023.
Applications of artificial intelligence and machine learning-based supervisory technology in financial markets surveillance: A review of literature. FIIB Business Review. • Manikantha, A. G. S. , 2021. To all stock exchanges: BSE Limited, National Stock Exchange of India Limited, New York Stock Exchange, June 11, 2021. • Mazzarisi, P. , Ravagnani, A. , Deriu, P. , 2024. A machine learning approach to support decision in insider trading detection.
EPJ
Data Science 13, 66. https://doi.org/10.1140/epjds/s13688-024-00500-2. • Murphy, D., Mueller, J., 2018. RegTech: Opportunities for more efficient and effective regulatory supervision and compliance. Milken Institute. • Priyadarshi, P., Kumar, P., 2024. A comprehensive review on insider trading detection using
artificial intelligence. J.
Comput. Soc. Sci. 7, 1645– 1664.https://doi.org/10.1007/s42001-024-00284-5. • Siering, M., Clapham, B., Engel, O., Gomber, P., 2017. A taxonomy of financial market manipulations: Establishing trust and market integrity in the financialized economy through automated fraud detection. Journal of Information Technology 32(3), 251–269. • Sinha, A., Hickok, E., Basu, A., 2018. AI in India: A policy agenda. The Centre for Internet & Society 5. • Taherdoost, H., 2022. Blockchain technology and artificial intelligence together: A critical
review
on applications. Applied Sciences 12(24), 12948. https://doi.org/10.3390/app122412948.
Nguyen, T. , Bate, I. , Derr, E. , 2022. Automated compliance blueprint optimization with artificial intelligence. arXiv preprint arXiv:2206. 11187. Retrieved from https://arxiv. org/abs/2206. 11187. • Sarker, I. H. , Hossain, M. S. , 2024. Compliance cards: Computational artifacts for automated AI regulation compliance. arXiv preprint arXiv:2406. 14758. Retrieved from https://arxiv. org/abs/2406. 14758. • Wachter, S. , Mittelstadt, B. , Floridi, L. , 2018. Using artificial intelligence to support compliance with the General Data Protection Regulation. arXiv preprint arXiv:1809. 05762. Retrieved from https://arxiv. org/abs/1809. 05762. • Mazzarisi, P. , Ravagnani, A. , Deriu, P. , Lillo, F. , Medda, F. , Russo, A. , 2024. A machine learning approach to support decision in insider trading detection. EPJ Data Science 13(66). https://doi. org/10. 1140/epjds/s13688- 024-00500-2. • Cheng, G.
, Lundblad, C. T. , Yang, Z. , Zhang, Q. , 2022. Detecting insider trading in the era of big data and machine learning.
SSRN
Electronic Journal. https://ssrn. com/abstract=4240205. • AlphaShots, 2024. The role of AI in detecting insider trading: The role of blockchain in supporting AI to track insider trading. AlphaShots Blog. Retrieved from https://blog. alphashots. ai/the-role-of-ai-in-detecting-insider-trading/the-role-ofblockchain-in-supporting-ai-to-track-insider-trading. • Kulothungan, V. , 2024. A blockchain-enabled approach to cross-border compliance and trust. 446–454. https://doi. org/10. 1109/tps-isa62245. 2024. 00060. • Minz, N. K. , 2024. Ethical considerations in AI applications in finance. Advances in Finance, Accounting, and Economics Book Series, 277–290. https://doi. org/10. 4018/979- 8-3693-2185-0. ch012. • Kulothungan, V. , 2024. A blockchain-enabled approach to cross-border compliance and trust. 446–454. https://doi. org/10. 1109/tps-isa62245. 2024. 00060. • Daah, C. , Qureshi, A.
, Awan, I. -U. , & Konur, S. (2024). Enhancing Zero Trust Models in the Financial Industry through Blockchain Integration: A Proposed Framework. Electronics. https://doi. org/10. 3390/electronics13050865. • Hertig, G. (2024). Financial Supervision and AI. Cambridge University Press, 431–451. https://doi. org/10. 1017/9781108980197. 023.
Kumar, P., & Manrai, D. R. (2024). A Study on Accelerating Digital Financial Inclusion for positioning India through AI-enabled Banking Services. International Journal For Multidisciplinary Research. https://doi.org/10.36948/ijfmr.2024.v06i04.25511. • McNulty, D., Miglionico, A., & Milne, A. (2023). Data Access Technologies and the ‘New Governance’ Techniques of Financial Regulation. Journal of Financial Regulation, 9(2), 225–248. https://doi.org/10.1093/jfr/fjad008. • Cozzi, F. (2020). Will Blockchain Technologies Strengthen or Undermine the Effectiveness of Global Trade Control Regulations and Financial Sanctions? Global Jurist, 20(2). https://doi.org/10.1515/GJ-2019-0047. • Kurshan, E., Shen, H., & Chen, J. (2020). Towards self-regulating AI: Challenges and opportunities of
AI
model governance in financial services. https://doi. org/10. 1145/3383455. 3422564. • White, R. M. , & Lyn, A. (2024). Ethical Implications in Money Laundering Detection. Advances in Business Strategy and Competitive Advantage Book Series, 123–158. https://doi. org/10. 4018/979-8-3693-3948-0. ch006. • Gajjar, T. , Parikh, S. , & Shekokar, K. (2025). Integrating Blockchain Technology with AI to Enhance Security Measures. Indian Scientific Journal of Research in Engineering and Management, 09(01), 1–9. https://doi. org/10. 55041/ijsrem40423. • Agrawal, D. , Tidake, V. M. , Banu, S. R. , Ahmad, A. Y. A. , Thethi, H. P. , Chauhan, S. S. , & Mirčetić, D. (2024). Blockchain and AI Integration for Transparent and Secured Financial Record Keeping. Advances in Finance, Accounting, and Economics Book Series, 72–76. https://doi. org/10. 1201/9781003596721-17. • Padilla, A. (2002).
Can agency theory justify the regulation of insider trading? Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics, 5(1), 3–38. https://doi. org/10. 1007/S12113-002-1015-6. • Mazzini, G. , & Bagni, F. (2023). Considerations on the regulation of AI systems in the financial sector by the
AI
Act. Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence. https://doi.org/10.3389/frai.2023.1277544. • Skandalis, M. M. (2017). The new era of anti-financial crime compliance. Retrieved from https://hstalks.com/article/928/the-new-era-of-anti-financial-crimecompliance/. • Khatib, N. U., & Rebecca, J. K. (2024). Integrating AI and blockchain technology for robust fraud detection mechanisms. International Journal of Research in Commerce and Management Studies, 06(03), 43–49. https://doi.org/10.38193/ijrcms.2024.6305.
Creating A Compliance-First Fintech Solution For Trade Finance: Balancing Innovation With Regulation. (2024). IOSR Journal of Economics and Finance, 15(6), 41–49. https://doi. org/10. 9790/5933-1506054149. • Sah, J. , Padma, S. , Ramakrishna, Y. , & Irfan, M. (2024). Risk Management of Future of DeFi Using Artificial Intelligence as a Tool. Advances in Finance, Accounting, and Economics Book Series, 257–278. https://doi. org/10. 4018/979-8-3693-6321- 8. ch011. • Jain, A. P. , Praveena, K. S. , Anandhi, R. J. , Kumar, S. A. , Alabdely, H. , & Srivastava, A. P. (2024). Blockchain and Machine Learning for Automated Compliance in Regulatory Technology. https://doi. org/10. 1109/csnt60213. 2024. 10546202. • Okenwa, C. D. , David, O. , Orelaja, A. , & Akinwande, O. (2024). Exploring the Role of Explainable AI in Compliance Models for Fraud Prevention.
International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering Management & Applied Science, 13(5), 232–239. https://doi. org/10. 51583/ijltemas. 2024. 130524.