SHRI. KEVIZOBEI METHA AND 24 ORS v. THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS

Court: Gauhati High Court

Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA

Judgment date: 2024-03-11

Case summary

Gauhati High Court judgment dated 2024-03-11. SHRI. KEVIZOBEI METHA AND 24 ORS v. THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS. Read the judgment and case details on...

Judgment text

Page No. # 1/105 GAHC020005392021 THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) KOHIMA BENCH Case No. : WP(C)/269/2021 SHRI. KEVIZOBEI METHA AND 24 ORS PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER, GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL,PWD, UNDER SDEO, KOHIMA, KOHIMA, NAGALAND 2: SHRI. SALESIE KATIRY PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JAIL COLONY UNDER SDEO KOHIMA KOHIMA NAGALAND 3: SHRI. VISASUL NALEO PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JAIL COLONY UNDER SDEO KOHIMA KOHIMA NAGALAND 4: SMTI. IMLIKOKLA JAMIR PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PWD UNDER SDEO KOHIMA KOHIMA NAGALAND 5: SHRI. KEDUZO KEZO Page No. # 2/105 PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NAGA BAZAAR UNDER SDEO KOHIMA KOHIMA NAGALAND 6: SMTI. TSIASATSHU PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NAGA BAZAAR UNDER SDEO KOHIMA KOHIMA NAGALAND 7: SHRI. ARON SEB PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL RUMENSINYU UNDER SDEO TSEMINYU KOHIMA NAGALAND 8: SMTI. KUNILU PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MERHULIETSA UNDER SDEO KOHIMA KOHIMA NAGALAND 9: SHRI. TEMSUWAPANG IMCHEN PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PWD UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAND 10: SMTI. SHWENHILE KEPPEN Page No. # 3/105 PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL RUMENSINYU UNDER SDEO TSEMINYU KOHIMA NAGALAND 11: SMTI. VILAKHONUO LIVI PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PUFUCHAMA UNDER SDEO KOHIMA KOHIMA NAGALAND 12: SMTI. SHOVELU TUTSAO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PUFUCHAMA UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAND 13: SMTI. ZHAVINO SANTSU PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PUFUCHAMA UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAND 14: SHRI. NEITSHULIE PAPHINO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PUFUCHAMA UNDER SDEO KOHIMA KOHIMA NAGALAND 15: SHRI. MEZIHO KIKHI Page No. # 4/105 PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL K. KHEL VISWEMA UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAND 16: SHRI. NOSEZOL VITSU PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. PRIMARY SCHOOL K. KHEL VISWEMA UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAND KOHIMA KOHIMA NAGALAND 17: SMTI. NEILAKUOLE KIKHI PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. PRIMARY SCHOOL K. KHEL VISWEMA UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAND KOHIMA NAGALAND 18: SHRI. ROMEO WOCH PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KANDINU UNDER SDEO TSEMINYU KOHIMA NAGALAND 19: SHRI. PHAMO SEB PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL UNDER SDEO TSEMINYU KOHIMA Page No. # 5/105 NAGALAND 20: SHRI. KHIDIMO KEZ PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KANDINU UNDER SDEO TSEMINYU KOHIMA NAGALAND 21: SMTI. KENEIKHONUO KEYHO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL BAYAVU UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAND 22: SMTI. AVINI YEPTHO PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL BAYAVU UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAND 23: SHRI.

KENEIZELHOU LIEZIETSU PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL BAYAVU UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAND 24: SHRI. KHRIEKETUOLIE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MERHULIETSA UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAND Page No. # 6/105 25: SHRI. MUDOKHOYI NYEKHA PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MIDLAND UNDER SDEO KOHIMA NAGALAN VERSUS THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY, GOVT. OF NAGALAND, DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, KOHIMA, NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER KOHIMA NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT(MHRD) 124-C SHASTRI BHAVAN NEW DELH Advocate for the Petitioner : JOSHUA SHEQI Advocate for the Respondent : GOVT ADV NL Page No.

# 7/105 Linked Case : WP(C)/272/2021 SHRI. P. L. HAMNYEI AND 29 ORS PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL YANCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG NAGALAND 2: SHRI. T. BAONG PHOM GMS K-KHEL UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 3: SHRI. M. LONGSHEN PHOM GMS NYENCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 4: SHRI. WANTHAH PHOM GMS NYENCHINGL UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 5: SHRI. WAPONG PHOM GMS PONGO UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 6: SHRI. C. WANMEI PHOM GMS PONGOL UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 7: SHRI. CHINGKO PHOM GMS YANCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 8: SHRI. S. NYAMLONG PHOM GMS KANCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 9: SMTI. K. K. REBECCA GMS KANCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG Page No. # 8/105 LONGLENG-NAGALAND 10: SMTI. M. CHINGYUNG PHOM GMS NIAN UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 11: SMTI. H. LIANG PHOM GMS YONGNYAH UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 12: SHRI.

BONGLEI PHOM GMS YONGNYAHL UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 13: SMTI. P. PONGTHU GMS YOTAN UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 14: SHRI. L. PHANGTAU PHOM GMS YOTAN UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 15: SHRI. H. HAMDOK GMS YOTAN UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 16: SHRI. BAUOM PHOM GMS KANCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 17: SMTI. CHINGTAI L PHOM GMS NAMCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 18: SMTI. E. YENCHU PHOM GMS NAMCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 19: SHRI. Y. CHINGSHAU Page No. # 9/105 GMS YAONGYIMCHEN UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 20: SHRI. P. TEMJENMONGBA GMS YAONGYIMCHEN UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 21: SHRI. P. TONGPA PHOM GMS K-KHEL UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 22: SHRI. BAUNGAM PHOM GMS NYAN UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 23: SHRI. P. CHUNGSHAP PHOM GMS NAMCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 24: SMTI. C. CHOILUNG PHOM GMS NYENCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 25: SHRI.

METTING PHOM GMS PONGO UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 26: SMTI. A MANDANG GMS YANCHING UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 27: SHRI. TEHOMELI PHOM GMS YAONGYIMCHEN UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 28: SHRI. C. NYAPHONG PHOM GMS K-KHEL UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND Page No. # 10/105 29: SHRI. L. CHINGONG PHOM GMS NIAN UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND 30: SHRI. V. PHUHBOM GMS YONGYAH UNDER SDEO LONGLENG LONGLENG-NAGALAND VERSUS THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY GOVT.

OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER LONGLENG NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE AND DEVELOPMENT(MHRD) 124-C SHASTRI BHAVAN NEW DELHI ------------ Advocate for : JOSHUA SHEQI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS Page No. # 11/105 Linked Case : WP(C)/278/2021 SHRI. IMTIWAPANG LONGKUMER AND 78 ORS PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LIREMEN UNDER SDEO MANGKOLEMBA MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 2: SMTI. IMLIYANGLA GSM CHANGTONYA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAN 3: SHRI. BENDANGNUKSHI IMCHEN GSM UNDER SDEO CHUCHUYIMPANG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 4: SHRI. MANCHONG GSM LONGCHARA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 5: SHRI.

IMSUTENZUK AO GSM LONGCHARA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 6: SHRI. SUPONGTEMSU GSM MOANGSENYIMTI UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 7: SHRI. M IMTISUNEP GSM LIREMEN UNDER SDEO MANGKOLEMBA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 8: SMTI. NUNGSANGRENLA GSM AKHOYA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 9: SMTI. LIPOKSENLA GSM ALISUNGKUM Page No. # 12/105 UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 10: SHRI. IMNUKLOBA GSM CHANGTONGYA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 11: SHRI. IMLIKUMTET GSM ALISUNGKUM UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 12: SMTI. IMLIMENLA GSM CHUCHUYIMPANG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 13: SHRI. YIMSENDANGBA GSM LIRMEN UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 14: SHRI IMSUMONGBA GSM AKHOYA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 15: SMTI. MATSUNGTILA GSM MONGSENYIMTI UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 16: SHRI. MOASUNEP GSM MONGSENYIMTI UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 17: SHRI.

TAKOTIBA GSM LONGMISA UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 18: SMTI. BENDANGRENLA I. LONGKUMER GSM MOKOKCHUNG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 19: SMTI. SUPONGTULA LONGCHAR Page No. # 13/105 GSM CHANGDANG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 20: SHRI. CHUBAMOANG GSM ASANGMA UNDER SDEO CHANTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 21: SHRI. IMSUMOA GSM ASANGMA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 22: SMTI. IMNAMENLA GSM ASANGMAA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 23: SHRI. INTISUNEP KICHU GSM CHANGTONGYA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 24: SHRI. SUBONGCHIDEN GSM TZUDIKONG UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 25: SMTI. T. LIMAJUNGLA GSM TZUDIKONG UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 26: SHRI. B. AKANGYANGER WALLING GSM TZUDIKONG UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 27: SMTI. AIREN IMCHEN GSM LONGCHARA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 28: SHRI. MERENTOSHI AO GSM KHENSA UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND Page No.

# 14/105 29: SHRI. ONENTIBA GSM KHENSA UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 30: SHRI. DEO LONGCHAR GSM MANGMETONG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 31: SMTI. CHUBALA GSM MANGMETONG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 32: SHRI. C. LIMASASONG JAMIR GSM YIMYU UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 33: SMTI. TALISENLA GSM YIMYU UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 34: SMTI. WAPANGINLA GSM LONGJANG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 35: SHRI. MOASENBA GSM MOPUNGCHUKET UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 36: SHRI. YANGERLONG GSM MOPUNGCHUKET UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 37: SMTI. KILENSUNGLA GSM MOPUNGCHUKET UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 38: SMTI. RONGSENSHILU AO GSM ALONGTAKI Page No. # 15/105 UNDER SDEO MANGKOLEMBA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 39: SMTI. LIMASENLA GSM ALONGTAKI UNDER SDEO MANGKOLEMBA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 40: SHRI. T. SANGPANGER GSM ALONGTAKI UNDER SDEO MANGKOLEMBA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 41: SHRI.

YASHIMONGBA GSM CHANGDANG UNDER SDEO MANGKOLEMBA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 42: SHRI. TONGPANGNUNGSHI GSM LANGDANG UNDER SDEO MANGKOLEMBA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 43: SHRI. TALIGANGCHET GSM A AND B SECTOR UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 44: SMTI. NAROLA C JAMIR GSM A AND B SECTOR UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 45: SHRI. L. IMLISUNEP LONGCHARI GSM CHUCHUYIMPANG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 46: SMTI. WANGSHIENLA GSM IMRONG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 47: SHRI. MOANGNUNGBA JAMIR GSM LONGMISA UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND Page No. # 16/105 48: SMTI. LIPOKSENLA LEMTUR GSM LONGMISA UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 49: SENKANUNGSANG JAMIR GSM KOKOKCHUNG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 50: SHRI. T IMSU LONGKUMER GSM MOKOKCHUNG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 51: SHRI. IMSUMANEN S JAMIR GSM SUMI UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 52: SHRI.

KIKANUNGSANG LONGKUMER GSM SUMI UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 53: SHRI. SENTITEMSU GSM TEACHER COLINY UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 54: SHRI. WASANGPONG GSM TEACHER COLONY UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 55: SMTI. AKALA LONGKUMER GSM TEACHER COLONY UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 56: SMTI. IMTINUNGLA JAMIR GSM TOWN MIDDLE SCHOOL UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 57: SHRI. MERENUNGSANG GSM TOWN MIDDLE SCHOOL UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG Page No. # 17/105 MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 58: SHRI. TONGPANGSUNEP JAMIR GSM ALEMPANG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 59: SMTI. BENJONGWALA GSM ALEMPANG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 60: SHRI. MOANGKABA GSM KUMLONG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 61: SMTI. ASENLA LONGKUMER GSM KUMLONG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 62: SHRI. IMCHANOCHET GSM SALANGTEM UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 63: SMTI.

JUNGSHIMONGLA GSM SALANGTEM UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 64: SHRI. RONGSENSHILU JAMIR GSM SANKALEMBA UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 65: SHRI. CHUBAWAPANG GSM SANKALEMBA UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 66: SMTI. TEYONGTANGLA JAMIR GSM SANKALEMBA UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 67: SHRI. SALANGMEREN Page No. # 18/105 GSM MERAKIONG UNDER SDEO MANGKOLEMBA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 68: SMTI. KIYALA GSM MIRAKIONG UNDER SDEO MANGKOLEMBA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 69: SHRI. KIKUSUNGBA GSM ALEMPANG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 70: SHRI. RONGSENKABA LKR GSM SALANGTEM UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 71: SMTI. ARENGMONGLA AMER GSM MERKIONG UNDER SDEO MANGKOLEMBA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 72: SMTI. IMDONGLA SANGLIR GSM A AND B SECTOR UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 73: SHRI. MEYISAPONG GSM AKHOYA UNDER SDEO CHANGTONGYA MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 74: SMTI. TEMSUYALA GSM KHENSA UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 75: SHRI.

IMLITEMSU GSM LONJANG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND 76: SHRI. TAKACHIBA GSM SUMI UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG- NAGALAND Page No. # 19/105 77: SHRIO SENTIMAR AO GMS YIMYU UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG-NAGALAND 78: SMTI. NUNGSHITULA GMS KUMLONG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG-NAGALAND 79: SHRI. JOHN GMS MANGMETONG UNDER SDEO MOKOKCHUNG MOKOKCHUNG-NAGALAND VERSUS THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY GOVT. OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER MOKOCHUNG NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT(MHRD) 124-C SHASTRI BHAVAN NEW DELHI ------------ Advocate for : JOSHUA SHEQI Page No.

# 20/105 Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS Linked Case : WP(C)/271/2021 SHRI. W. IMLONGCHABA CHANG AND 50 ORS PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHABA UNDER SDEO TUENSANG NAGALAND 2: SHRI M CHUBA YIMCHUNGER GMS SANGKOR UNDER SDEO SHAMATOR TUENSANG NAGALAND 3: SHRI. HANKIU YIMCHUNGER GMS MANGKO UNDER SDEO SHAMATOR TUENSANG- NAGALAND 4: SHRI. K. LUNTSUBA YIMCHUNGER GMS SAngkor UNDER SDEO SHAMATOR TUENSANG- NAGALAND 5: SMTI. NAYONGNARO GMS YANGPHI UNDER SDEO TUENSANGI TUENSANG- NAGALAND 6: SHRI. Y. THRUNSO GMS MANKHO UNDER SDEO SHAMATOR TUENSANG-NAGALAND 7: SHRI. DANIEL B TIKHIR Page No. # 21/105 GMS THONOKNYU UNDER SDEO NOKLAK TUENSANG-NAGALAND 8: SMTI. S. MONGSHAI GMS THONOKNYU UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 9: SMTI. MONGHOI GMS ANGANGBA UNDER SDEO TUENSANG-NAGALAND 10: SHRI. N. YIMKONG GMS HAKUSHANG UNDER SDEO TUENSANG-NAGALAND 11: SHRI. M PUNGLANG GMS SANGSANGNYU UNDER SDEO TUENSANG-NAGALAND 12: SMTI. S.

RUTHSANGLA GMS KONYA UNDER SDEO TUENSANG-NAGALAND 13: SHRI. PANGSHA CHOLLEN GMS KONYA UNDER SDEO TUENSANG-NAGALAND 14: SMTI. ANTIMANG GMS CHINGMEILEN UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 15: SHRI. C. THSANSHIMONG YIM GMS CHINGMEILEN UNDER SDEO TUENSANG-NAGALAND 16: SHRI. KHONEYYEMJONG GMS CHINGMEILEN UNDER SDEO TUENSANG-NAGALAND Page No. # 22/105 17: SHRI. THANGPONG KHIAMNIUNGAN GMS THANG(NOKLAK VILLAGE) UNDER SDEO NOKLAK TUENSANG-NAGALAND 18: SMTI. SOMETNARO CHANG GMS HAKCHANG UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 19: SMTI. SUNGMOLEMLA CHANG GMS HAKCHANG UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 20: SHRI. O. SOMBA GMS HAKCHANG UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 21: SHRI. BINYEMJONG GMS TUENSANG UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 22: SMTI. YANGTSALILA GMS LONGTHROK UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 23: SHRI. JENDIR SANGTAM GMS LONGTHROK UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 24: SMTI. L. CHILLIAM GMS LONGTHROK UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 25: SHRI. Y.

MOKSHAKONGA GMS SANGSANGNYU UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 26: SHRI. P PESHIA KHIAMNIUNGAN GMS CHIPUR UNDER SDEO NOKLAK Page No. # 23/105 TUENSANG-NAGALAND 27: SHRI. YAMBEMONGKO GMS SANGSANGNYU UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 28: SHRI. SHOJIBA GMS SANGKOR UNDER SDEO SHAMATOR TUENSANG-NAGALAND 29: SMTI. CHONGLIO KHIAMNIUNGAN GMS HAKUCHANG UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 30: SHRI. IBOULOMCHU CHANG GMS KONYA UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 31: SMTI. K. ASONIA CHANG GMS TUENSANG UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 32: SMTI. CHINGOP GMS CHIPUR UNDER SDEO NOKLAK TUENSANG-NAGALAND 33: SMTI. M. MONGSHAI KHIAMNIUNGAN GMS THANGK UNDER SDEO NOKLAK TUENSANG-NAGALAND 34: SHRI. LONGALONG GMS THANG UNDER SDEO NOKLAK TUENSANG-NAGALAND 35: SHRI. KUSHEM YEMJONG GMS HAKUSHANG UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 36: SHRI. M. SENTICHUBA SANGTAM Page No. # 24/105 GMS ANGANGBA UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 37: SHRI. C. T.

AHETYJINGER GMS ANGANGBA UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 38: SHRI. MOYA SANGTAM GMS CHUNGTOR UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 39: SHRI. SERILI SANGTAM GMS CHUNGTOR UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 40: SHRI. LIRISE SANGTAM GMS CHUNGTOR UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 41: SHRI. TALITEMSU GMS TONGLONGSOR UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 42: SHRI. P. KHUMLONG SANGTAM GMS CHABA UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 43: SMTI. NAOME GMS CHABA UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 44: SHRI. KAIMANG CHINGMAK GMS TUENSANG VILLAGE UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 45: SHRI JOSHUA YIM GMS HUKER UNDER SDEO SHAMATOR TUENSANG-NAGALAND Page No. # 25/105 46: SMTI. T. ATOLA YIMCHUNGER GMS HUKER UNDER SDEO SHAMATOR TUENSANG-NAGALAND 47: SHRI. C. LAJI YIMCHUNGER GMS HUKER UNDER SDEO SHAMATOR TUENSANG-NAGALAND 48: SHRI. TIABA CHANG GMS YANGPI UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 49: SHRI. PATUN GMS TONGLONGSOR UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 50: SMTI.

LIRUJUNGLA T SANGTAM GMS TONGLONGSOR UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND 51: SHRI. PONGON M GMS YANGPI UNDER SDEO TUENSANG TUENSANG-NAGALAND VERSUS THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY GOVT. OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY KOHIMA Page No. # 26/105 NAGALAND 4:THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER TUENSANG NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT(MHRD) 124-C SHASTRI BHAVAN NEW DELHI ------------ Advocate for : JOSHUA SHEQI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS Linked Case : WP(C)/273/2021 SHRI. THUPUVOTO CURHA AND 93 ORS PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PFUTSERO-A UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO NAGALAND 2: SHRI.

WEKHROTSO SARA GMS LESHAMI UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK-NAGALAND 3: SHRI. ZUVOLHU RHAKHO GMS CHOZUBA TOWN-A UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK-NAGALAND 4: SHRI. VIVI NUWIRY GMS ZION COLONY PHEK TOWN UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK-NAGALAND 5: SHRI. SAPHO GMS NEW PHOR UNDER SDEO MELURI Page No. # 27/105 PHEK-NAGALAND 6: SMTI. ALIUKHIALIU GMS SUTHOZU NASA UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK-NAGALAND 7: SHRI. LALO LOMI GMS LESHEMI UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK-NAGALAND 8: SHRI. ZHOTO VERO GMS MIDDLE KHO UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK-NAGALAND 9: SHRI. RUKUVOTO SWURO GMS RUNGUZU NASA UNDER SDEO CHOSUBA PHEK-NAGALAND 10: SMTI. KEZUWE-U WETSA GMS PFUTSEROMI UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK-NAGALAND 11: SHRI. VEZOTO NYEKHA GSM SUTHOZU NASA UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 12: SMTI. VEHUSULU RUHO GSM RUKIZU UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 13: SHRI. K. THITATU GSM NEW PHOR UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 14: SHRI P HUNSHUNG GSM PHONKHUNGRI UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 15: SHRI. TSATHU GSMPHONKHUNGRI Page No.

# 28/105 UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 16: SHRI. KUDUHU MEDEO GSM SUTHOZU NASA UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 17: SHRI. BESUVEYI GSM DZULHAMI UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 18: SHRI. JOHN THEVURY GSM PHONKHUNGRI UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 19: SHRI. CHEPELO GSM PHEK VILLAGE UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 20: SHRI. VEVOSAYI KEYHO GSM DZULHAMI UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 21: SMTI. LHIECHEU THELE GSM ENHULUMI UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 22: SHRI. MUTUVE DAZO GSM PHEK VILLAGE UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 23: SHRI. DAVID KUPUNGHO GSM KUKEGWO UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 24: SHRI. CALVIN POCHURY GSM MELURI VILLAGE UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND Page No. # 29/105 25: SHRI. KUNULHO TETSEO GSM THUVOPISU UNDER SDEO CHOZUBAI PHEK- NAGALAND 26: SHRI. ISAAC NYUTHE GSM MELURI VILLAGE UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 27: SHRI. WEKHROLO KHUTSO GSM PFUTSERO-A UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 28: SHRI.

KHROPE KANUOH GSM LOSA BASA UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 29: SHRI. SEKHO TETSEO GSM ZION COLONY PHEK TOWN UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 30: SHRI DUPU VENUH GSM TSUPFUME UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 31: SMTI. METEVI LEAH GSM TSUPFUME UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 32: SHRI. KHRUSAYI VERO GSM RUNGUZU NASA UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 33: SHRI. PFUTSUDE NGATSI GSM ENHULUMI UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 34: SHRI. HICHOTE KEPFOH GSM LOSA BASA Page No. # 30/105 UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 35: SHRI. LEAVIKHO LEAH GSM PFUTSEROMI UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 36: SHRI. RUKUOTA DOZO GSM THUVOPISU UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 37: SHRI. POKUYI VERO GSM ZION COLONY PHEK TOWN UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 38: SMTI. THUKUTALU VENYO GSM THUVOPISU UNDER SDEO CHOZUBAI PHEK- NAGALAND 39: SMTI. LICHUMLA GSM KUKEGWO UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 40: SHRI. JIKHGIM GSM KUKEGWO UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 41: SMTI.

KUSA GSM MELURI VILLAGE UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 42: SHRI. VELACHO NEINU GSM MIDDLE KHO UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 43: SHRI. KHUVONEYI GSM KUTSAPO UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 44: SHRI. TSHEKHRO L MERO Page No. # 31/105 GSM ENHULUMI UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 45: SHRI. HUKUTO VENUH GSM KETSAPO UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 46: SHRI. LHIWEKHRO SARA GSM LESHEME UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 47: SHRI KOVI LEA GSM TSUPFUME UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 48: SMTI. MENELOU AKAMI GSM LOSA BASA UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 49: SHRI. VEVOSAYI CHOTSO GSM RUKIZU UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 50: SHRI. MUDUVEZO LOHE GSM YORBA-A UNDER SDEO CHOZUBAO PHEK- NAGALAND 51: SHRI. MULUSA VESWUH GSM YORBA-A UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 52: SHRI. VEZOSATO GSM DZULHAMI UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 53: SHRI. KHROPE WETSAH GSM KIKRUMA UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND Page No. # 32/105 54: SHRI. VENUTA THIRA GSM KIKRUNA UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 55: SHRI.

HAGAI THURR GSM NEW PHOR UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 56: SMTI. KUKUVELU GSM MATIKHRU UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 57: SMTI. APRILFU GSM MATIKHRU UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 58: SHRI. YITHATU GSM PHOLARY UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 59: SHRI. VEZOSA MEDEO GSM RUNGUZU UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 60: SHRI. RIECHUSIE GSM MELURI UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 61: SHRI. RUPETHO GSM ZHIPU UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 62: SHRI VEJUTA KHESOH GSM CHESEZU BASA UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 63: SHRI. NUTHITO NYEKHA GSM CHESEZU BASA UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA Page No. # 33/105 PHEK- NAGALAND 64: SHRI. VESOLHU NYEKHA GSM CHESEZU BASA UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 65: SHRI. BEDUVE RIO GSM CHOZUBA VILLAGE-A UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 66: SHRI. VELUZO KHESOH GSM CHOZUBA VILLAGE-A UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 67: SHRI. KHRUKUTHO GSM CHOZUBA VILLAGE-A UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 68: SMTI. VEZOTALU LOHE GSM YORBA-A UNDER SDEO CHOZUBA PHEK- NAGALAND 69: SHRI.

KHROWUTSO KAPFU GSM MATIKHRU UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 70: SMTI. KUNIELU JOE GSM PHOLARY UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 71: SMTI. LITSIRU GSM REGURI UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 72: SMTI. WEYIETSOLU GSM REGURI UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 73: SMTI. ACHIRU Page No. # 34/105 GSM REGURI UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 74: SMTI. TSATHAVI GSM SUTSU UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 75: SHRI. M. ISSAC GSM SUTSU UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 76: SHRI. A. MEZHIMU GSM HUTSU UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 77: SMTI. LUCHULI S. TRANYUL GSM HUTSU UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 78: SMTI. D. KOHILI GSM HUSHU UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 79: SHRI. WILSON GSM MELURI TOWN UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 80: SMTI. YUSIFI GSM MELURI TOWN UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 81: SHRI. ZHEPITU GSM MOLEN UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 82: SHRI. WHICHITU GSM MOLEN UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND Page No. # 35/105 83: SMTI.

MAKENNARO GSM ZHIPU UNDER SDEO MELURI PHEK- NAGALAND 84: SHRI. THUPUCUSO GSM PHOLAMI UNDER SDEO PFUTSEROI PHEK- NAGALAND 85: SMTI. MERCY NAKHRO GSM PHOLAMI UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 86: SHRI. KUDUTO SHIJOH GSM PHOLAMI UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 87: SMTI. KUPE-U KUPA GSM PFUTSERO-A UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAND 88: SHRI. VEMURA LOHE GSM MIDDLE KHO UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 89: SHRI. ZHOHU D VADEO GSM PHEK BASA UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 90: SHRI. THUJOVE CHIZO GSM PHEK BASA UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 91: SMTI. LHUVEZOLU KEYHO GSM PHEK BASA UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAND 92: SHRI. VEZITO TETSEO GSM KEREHUBA Page No. # 36/105 UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAN 93: SHRI. ZAMULE HOSHI GSM KEREHUBA UNDER SDEO PHEK PHEK- NAGALAN 94: SMTI. VEKHOSHELU RUHO GSM RUKIZU UNDER SDEO PFUTSERO PHEK- NAGALAN VERSUS THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY GOVT.

OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER PHEK NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT(MHRD) 124-C SHASTRI BHAVAN NEW DELHI ------------ Advocate for : JOSHUA SHEQI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS Page No. # 37/105 Linked Case : WP(C)/275/2021 SHRI. EFRAIM SEMA AND 67 ORS PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL DUNCAN LOTHA UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 2: SMTI. OLIVIA PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KHRIEZEPHE UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 3: SHRI. VITSILE ZUYIE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHUMUKEDIMA B1-IV UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 4: SHRI. Y.

YOUNGTSULA YIMCHUNGER PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KHUSHIBIL UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 5: SHRI. TSUYIPU PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHUMUKEDIMA TOWN UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 6: SHRI. SERAVO VESE Page No. # 38/105 PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JHARNAPANI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 7: SHRI. KAKHETO SUMI PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KASHIRAM AO UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 8: SHRI. ZHUVITHO PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JHARNAPANI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 9: SMTI. KROTE-U MERO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JHARNAPANI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 10: SHRI. RUOPFUKUOLIE PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MEDZIPHEMA KUKI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 11: SHRI. ROKOKHOLIE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL Page No.

# 39/105 MEDZIPHEMA KUKI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 12: SMTI. ZACHANO N. OVUNG PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL DUNCUN LOTHA UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 13: SHRI. NUCHIVE VESE PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KHRIEZEPHE UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 14: SHRI. H. BOANER HANGSING PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PHAIPIJANG UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 15: SMTI. GLORY ODYUO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL DUNCUN LOTHA UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 16: SMTI. NOSEVONO KWEHO PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KASHIRAM AO UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND Page No. # 40/105 17: SMTI. S. KIMSHANG PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KASHIRAM AO UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 18: SMTI. TIATEMSULA PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MOLVOM UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 19: SMTI. HATNEILHAI HANGSING PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL MOLVOM UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 20: SHRI. MEDO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PURANA BAZAAR-B UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 21: SHRI. THANGMINLEN PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MOLVOM UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 22: SHRI. SHEKHATO V. ZHIMO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER Page No. # 41/105 GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KHRIEZEPHE UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 23: SMTI. S. ACHAI PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PURANA BAZAAR-B UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 24: SMTI. RUKULU CHIZO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SINGRIJAN-C UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 25: SMTI. PUKHUTO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL VETERNARY UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 26: SHRI. TOKATO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PIMLA UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 27: SHRI. RUKUOVOTO NYEKHA PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SUGARMIL Page No.

# 42/105 UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 28: SHRI. PENKHELO TEP PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SUGARMIL UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 29: SHRI. RUKUNE SWURO PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SUGARMIL UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 30: SMTI. PHYOCHOBENI KHUVUNG PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SINGRIJAN-C UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 31: SHRI. H. KAIHO CHISHI PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL VISHYI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 32: SMTI. HEKATOLI PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL VETERNARY UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND Page No. # 43/105 33: SHRI. ZHOVETO VENUH PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHUMUKEDIMA B1-IV UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 34: SMTI. AVITOLI PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL VISHYI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 35: SHRI. QHESHETO ZHIMO PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL VISHYI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 36: SMTI.

BOLIHO PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SINGRIJAN-C UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 37: SHRI. KAVITO K. SUMI PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NIULAND TOWN UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 38: SMTI. MUGHALI ACHUMI PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER Page No. # 44/105 GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NIULAND TOWN UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 39: SHRI. ANITO SUMI PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NIULAND TOWN UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 40: SHRI. THENUVEHU SOHO PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL VETERINARY UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 41: SMTI. C. ESTHER MURRY PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SEMATILA UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 42: SMTI. ZHOVEHU VESE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SEMATILA UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 43: SMTI. HEKALI K. YEPTHO PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SEMATILA Page No. # 45/105 UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 44: SHRI. V.

TOHUTO CHISHI PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL XUKHUVI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 45: SHRI. ZAPOVE KEYHO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHAKHESANG COLONY UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 46: SMTI. KUVESULU KAPU PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHAKHESANG COLONY UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 47: SMTI. NUTSOLU PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHAKHESANG COLONY UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 48: SHRI. BESUTO MEDE-O PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL DUNCUN AO UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND Page No. # 46/105 49: SMTI. VINO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL DUNCAN AO UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 50: SMTI. SENTIMENLA PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL DUNCAN AO UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 51: SHRI. SHILUTEMSU PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL AO YIMTI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 52: SMTI. SENCHULE MAGH PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL AO YIMTI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 53: SMTI. TOSHELI Z. AWOMI PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL AO YIMTI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 54: SHRI. RITACHU PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER Page No. # 47/105 GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MIDLAND UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 55: SMTI. VINGUSEIU YASHU PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MIDLAND UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 56: SMTI. Y. NOGHULI SWU PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MIDLAND UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 57: SMTI. ATHRILA JOE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KHUSHIBIL UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 58: SHRI. M. RIPUNG PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KHUSHIBIL UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 59: SHRI. BESUSA VENYO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PURANA BAZAAR-B Page No. # 48/105 UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 60: SHRI. VENE-O PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL NAGA UNITED UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 61: SMTI. AZOLE DOULO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NAGA UNITED UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 62: SHRISEVEZO TUNYI PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NAGA UNITED UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 63: SHRI. HENGOULEN LHOUJEM PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PHAIPIJANG UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 64: SHRI. KAMKHOLEN HAOLAI PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PHAIPIJANG UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND Page No. # 49/105 65: SHRI. THONSEN KEZ PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHUMU B1-IV UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 66: SMTI. K. ROSELINE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHUMU TOWN UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 67: SMTI. HINENYA MAGH PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHUMU TOWN UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND 68: SMTI. METSIKHONO VISEZUO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL MEDZI-KUKI UNDER SDEO DIMAPUR NAGALAND VERSUS STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY Page No. # 50/105 KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER DIMAPUR NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT (MHRD) 124-C SHASTRI BHAVAN NEW DELHI ------------ Advocate for : JOSHUA SHEQI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS Linked Case : WP(C)/276/2021 SHRI. HEIGUM KULIM AND 28 ORS PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MHAINAMTSI UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 2: SMTI. PHENWANGLIU PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NEW CHALKOT UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 3: SMTI.

KOKOLE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MHAINAMTSI UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 4: SMTI. LUNGSILE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL Page No. # 51/105 BEISUMPUIKM UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 5: SHRI. MASENKAMBO NEWMAI PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JALUKIELO UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 6: SHRI. KIMKHOHOI CHANGSAN PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NEW CHALKOT UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 7: SMTI. AHEILE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NEW CHALKOT UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 8: SMTI. KARAILA PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PHANJANG UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 9: SMTI. NZEINEILE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PEREN TOWN UNDER SDEO PEREN Page No. # 52/105 NAGALAND 10: SMTI. MAITONKAMLIU PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SAMJUIRAM-A UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 11: SHRI. KHENWANG KONYAK PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL PHANJANG UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 12: SMTI. PHALPICHONG HAULAI PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PHANJANG UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 13: SHRI. AZHATO NYEKHA PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JALUKIE-B UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 14: SMTI. BINO PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL BEISUMPUIKAM UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 15: SMTI. ALENO Page No. # 53/105 PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LIREMEN UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 16: SHRI. VEKHOTO NIENU PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JALUKIE JANGDI UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 17: SMTI. MURHETSOLU RHAKHO PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JALUKIE JANGDI UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 18: SMTI. KIMNEICHONG SINGSONG PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JALUKIE JANGDI UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 19: SHRI. SOLOMON PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL BEISUMPUIKAM UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 20: SHRI. HAIREUCIBE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER Page No. # 54/105 GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JALUKIE TOWN SECTOR-A UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 21: SHRI. IREILUNG PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JALUKIE TOWN SECTOR-A UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 22: SHRI. ISIHANGBE PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JALUKIELO UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 23: SHRI. BESETO VESE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL JALUKIELO UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 24: SHRI. NZEUGUMBE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PEREN TOWN UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 25: SHRI. GEMPIBE PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PEREN TOWN UNDER SDEO PEREN Page No. # 55/105 NAGALAND 26: SHRI. ZUTAVE VERO PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL B-JALUKIE UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 27: SMTI. ICHIULE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL B-JALUKIE UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 28: SHRI. KERANGLUIBO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SANJUIRAM-A UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND 29: SMTI. KADINSILIU PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SANJUIRAM-A UNDER SDEO PEREN NAGALAND VERSUS THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 OSR REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY GOVT. OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR Page No. # 56/105 DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER PEREN NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT(MHRD) 124-C SHASTRI BHAVAN NEW DELHI ------------ Advocate for : JOSHUA SHEQI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 OSR Linked Case : WP(C)/270/2021 SHRI. N.

PUCHING AND 55 ORS PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL T/CHINGKO UNDER SDEO MON NAGALAND 2: SHRI. K. THAWANG KONYAK PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL SHINGNYUI UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 3: SHRI. L METHWANG PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL MON TOWN -C UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND Page No. # 57/105 4: SHRI GINGTOK KONYAK PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL HONPHOI UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 5: SHRI WANGRON PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL HONGPHOI UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 6: SHRI. PONGHOK PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL WANCHING UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 7: SHRI. BANGJEI L KONYAK PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL WANCHING UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 8: SHRI. M PENKHAO KONYAK PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGWA UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 9: SMTI.

HONGNYU KONYAK PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL CHANGLANGSHU UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 10: SHRI HAMJEI KONYAK PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL NAGINIMORA-C UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND Page No. # 58/105 11: SMTI. P SHELAO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL CHANGLANGSHU UNDER SDEO TOBU-NAGALAND 12: SMTI. APANG KONYAK PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL SHANGNYU UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 13: SHRI. TAIGANG K KONYAK PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL S/WAMSA UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 14: SMTI JUYING KONYAK PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL S/WAMSA UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 15: SHRI. P. WANGLANG KONYAK PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL S/WAMSA UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 16: SMTI. YEILONG KONYAK P PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGZANG UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 17: SMTI .

L AYEIH PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL TIZIT VILLAGE Page No. # 59/105 UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 18: SHRI. NAHLEI KONYAK PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL TIZIT VILLAGE UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 19: SMTI. LYDIA KONYAK PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL NAGINIMORA-C UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 20: SMTI. MANSHEN KONYAK PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL NAGINIMORA UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 21: SMTI. Y. NGAMYAO KONYAK PART TIME KNITTINGINSTRUCTOR GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL HONPHOI UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 22: A. SHAMWAN KONYAK PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL TIZIT TOWN-B UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 23: SHRI. H. YANBOH KONYAK PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL CHENMOHO UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 24: SMTI. C. MONGLONG KONYAK PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL Page No. # 60/105 T/CHINGKHO UNDER SDEO MON -NAGALAND 25: SHRI.

KHAHWANG W KONYAK GMS T/CHINGKHO UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 26: SMTI. MARY KONYAK GMS MON TOWN A UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 27: SMTI. M NEANGMAI KONYAK GMS SHAMNYU A UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 28: SHRI. PHONGNYEI KONYAK GMS NGANCHING UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 29: SMTI. H. THENGLI KONYAK GMS LONGWA UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 30: SMTI. EASTER KONYAK GMS ABOI TOWN A UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 31: SHRI. E. PULANG KONYAK GMS ANGPHANG UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 32: SHRI. K MANCHEN KONYAK GMS Page No. # 61/105 ANGPHANG UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 33: SHRI. DAVID HONGKAM GMS ANGPHANG UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 34: SMTI. PHOYA KONYAK GMS LONGZANG UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 35: SMTI. TENLANG MANJO KONYAK GMS PESSAO UNDER SDEO TOBU - NAGALAND 36: SHRI. Y. BUPAI NAKSA KONYAK GMS PESSAO UNDER SDEO TOBU - NAGALAND 37: SHRI. MANNYEI KONYAK GMS MON TOWN C UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 38: SHRI. M NOKE KONYAK GMS MON TOWN A UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 39: SHRI.

T JAIYING KONYAK GMS MON TOWN A UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 40: SMTI. NAHNYAM WANGSU GMS Page No. # 62/105 TIZIT TOWN C UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 41: SHRI. PANGWANG GMS MON TOWN A UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 42: SHRI. MANKAP KONYAK GMS CHENMOHO UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 43: SHRI. TINGKEI KONYAK GMS LAOKKUN UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 44: SHRI. ISSAC KONYAK GMS SHANGNYU UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 45: SHRI. WENKHANG KONYAK GMS CHENMOHO UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 46: SHRI. PANGNYEI KONYAK GMS NANGCHING UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 47: SHRI. Y MANPHEN KONYAK GMS LONGWA UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 48: SMTI. NEKE NEANGMAI GMS Page No. # 63/105 PESSAO UNDER SDEO TOBU - NAGALAND 49: SHRI. MANSHAK P KONYAK GMS ABOI TOWN A UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 50: SHRI. P PANGLOI GMS ABOI TOWN A UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 51: SHRI. BUANG KONYAK GMS NGANGCHING UNDER SDEO ABOI - NAGALAND 52: SHRI. HONGPHONG KONYAK GMS LONGZANG UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 53: SMTI.

TOIMEI KONYAK GMS LAOKKUN UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 54: SMTI. ZENGPHE KONYAK GMS TIZIT TOWN B UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND 55: SHRI. N CHANGLANG KONYAK GMS CHANGLANGSHU UNDER SDEO TOBU - NAGALAND 56: SHRI. SHIJONG GMS Page No. # 64/105 WANCHING UNDER SDEO MON - NAGALAND VERSUS THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY GOVT. OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER MON NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT(MHRD) 124-C SHASTRI BHAVAN NEW DELHI ------------ Advocate for : JOSHUA SHEQI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS Linked Case : WP(C)/277/2021 SHRI. R.

CHUMBEMO ODYUO AND 59 ORS PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL NYIRO CENTRE UNDER SDEO Page No. # 65/105 WOKHA NAGALAND 2: SMTI. NYANBENI S. NGULLIE PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NYIRO CENTER UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 3: SMTI. KHRIEVONUO PFUSENUO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NYIRO CENTER UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 4: SHRI. C. THUNGBEMO PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL WOZHURO UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 5: SHRI. PICHAMO TUNGOE PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL YAMHON OLD UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 6: SHRI. T. STEPHEN LOTHA PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LIPHI UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND Page No. # 66/105 7: SMTI. JAMBENI MOZHUI PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL YAMHON OLD UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 8: SHRI. N. RENCHAMO LOTHA PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL LIPHI UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 9: SHRI. RENTSAMO NGULLIE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NUNGYING UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 10: SMTI. SORENPENI NGULLIE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LAKHUTI-A UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 11: SHRI. CHEMPENTHUN PATTON PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LAKHUTIA UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND Page No. # 67/105 12: SMTI. A. MHONLUMI PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGSA UNDER WOKHA NAGALAND 13: SHRI. PITHONGO HUMTSOE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL RACHAN UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 14: SHRI. M. ROBIN JUNGIO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGTSUNG UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 15: SHRI. TSENTHUNGO KITHAN PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL AKUK UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 16: SHRI. K. MHONYAMO KIKON PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL AKUK UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND Page No. # 68/105 17: SHRI. Y. ROLLEN KIKON PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MEKOKLA UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 18: SHRI. N. KHYOLAMO KIKON PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MEKOKLA UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 19: SHRI. RENBI KIKON Y PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MEKOKLA UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 20: SHRI. C. YANITHUNG TUNGOE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL YAMHON OLD UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 21: SMTI. YANCHANO LOTHA PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL RACHAN UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA Page No. # 69/105 NAGALAND 22: SMTI. APENI PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL RALAN UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 23: SHRI. CHICHAMO L. PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL RALAN UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 24: SHRI. ZUTHUNGO N.

KIKON PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL YIMPANG UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 25: SHRI. M. KHUMDEMO PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL YIMPANG UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 26: SHRI. EPHYOTHUNG YANTHAN PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL YIMPANG Page No. # 70/105 UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 27: SHRI. RALANTHUNG ODYUO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL L/LONGIDANG UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 28: SMTI. C. ELIYANI MURRY PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL L/LONGIDANG UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 29: SHRI. MERICHAN PATTON PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL L/LONGIDANG UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 30: SHRI. IKATO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL AMBOTO UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 31: SMTI. KAVITOLI CHOPHI PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL Page No.

# 71/105 AMBOTO UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 32: SHRI. LONGSHIBEMO PATTON PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LIPHI UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 33: SHRI. RENPONTHUNG LOTHA PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGCHUM UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 34: SHRI. BENJAMIN KIKON PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGCHUM UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 35: SHRI. Z. ROBIN OVUNG PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGCHUM UNDER SDEO BHANDARI WOKHA NAGALAND 36: SMTI. C. SENCHILO EZUNG PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR Page No. # 72/105 GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGTSUNG UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 37: SMTI. W. THUNGCHANO HUMTSOE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGTSUNG UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 38: SHRI. F. EKONTHUNG KHUVUNG PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHUDI UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 39: SHRI. R. MHATHUNG YANTHAN PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL CHUDI UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 40: SHRI. LICHAMO TSOPOE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MESHANPHEN UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 41: SHRI. R. EKONTHUNG JAMI PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MESHANPHEN Page No. # 73/105 UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 42: SMTI. Y. EMILO LOTHA PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MESHANPHEN UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 43: SHRI. A. MHONTHUNG LOTHA PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHANGSU UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 44: SHRI. NRIBEMO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHANGSU UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 45: SMTI. S. ABENI LOTHA PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHANGSU NEW UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 46: SHRI. T. ZUCHANBEMO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGLA UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND Page No. # 74/105 47: SMTI. MHONBENI TSOPOE PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGLA UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 48: SHRI. N. NRIYIMO PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL NUNGYING UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 49: SHRI. YANTSOTHUNG NGULLIE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGIDANG UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 50: SMTI. ECHUNGMONGI EZUNG PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL N. LONGIDANG UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 51: SHRI. T. MHATHUNG EZUNG PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGSA UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 52: SMTI. LOIS KHUVUNG PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER Page No. # 75/105 GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGSA UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 53: SHRI. NCHUMBEMO N. EZUNG PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGSA-A UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 54: SHRI. CHONBENTHUNG TSOPOE PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGSA UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 55: SMTI. MERIBENI EZUNG PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGSA-A UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 56: SHRI.

THUNGBEN T. HUMTSOE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL WOKHA VILLAGE UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 57: SHRI. N. MYANBEMO PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL WOKHA VILLAGE Page No. # 76/105 UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 58: SMTI. AJANO N. HUMTSOE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL WOKHA VILLAGE UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 59: SHRI. THABEMO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL WOZHURO UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND 60: SMTI. ABENI T. OVUNG PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL WOZHURO UNDER SDEO WOKHA NAGALAND VERSUS STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER WOKHA NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY Page No. # 77/105 MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT (MHRD) 124-C NEW DELHI ------------ Advocate for : JOSHUA SHEQI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS Linked Case : WP(C)/274/2021 SHRI. T. PITHONGSE AND 45 ORS PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT HIGH SCHOOL SITIMI TOWN UNEDR SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 2: SHRI. TSELISE SANGTAM PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGYA UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 3: SHRI.

JAMES ACHIM PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PUNGRO UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 4: SMTI. VILIKA SUMI PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. HIGH SCHOOL LONGMATRA UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 5: SHRI. ATSACHUM T. SANGTAM Page No. # 78/105 PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. HIGH SCHOOL YANGPHI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 6: SHRI. KIUTIMEW PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. HIGH SCHOOL CHOMI KIPHIRE NAGALAND 7: SMTI. LAKSHILA YIMCHUNGER PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. HIGH SCHOOL CHOMI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 8: SMTI. T. SHATSOTHSI PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SAMPHURE UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 9: SMTI. SIYALA YIMCHUNGER PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PUNGRO UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 10: SMTI. LENRIHLA YIMCHUNGER PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL Page No. # 79/105 PUNGRO UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 11: SHRI.

KHONYAMONG YIMCHUNGER PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MIMI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 12: SHRI. CHIMUSHU PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL METONGER UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 13: SMTI. T HOTONI YEPTHO PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL YANGPHI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 14: SHRI. Z. NAGAHO SUMI PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MIMI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 15: SHRI. KIUTSUMONG YIMCHUNGER PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KHONJIRI Page No. # 80/105 UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 16: SHRI. TSUSUTHONG TIKHIR PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL METONGER UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 17: SHRI. LITSARI. T. SANGTAM PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SALOMI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 18: SMTI. AKALI SUMI PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL OLD MONGER UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 19: SHRI. C.

THSATINGSE PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL OLD MONGER UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 20: SHRI. YOKHABA S. SANGTAM PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGMATRA UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE Page No. # 81/105 NAGALAND 21: SHRI. AHETO PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SEYCHOUNG UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 22: SHRI. SALENTHONG YIMCHUNGER PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KHONJIRI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 23: SHRI. ANGUKATO PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. HIGH SCHOOL PHISAMI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 24: SMTI. TSIMONGTHSI PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PHISAMI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 25: SMTI. T LITONGLA PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. HIGH SCHOOL YANGPHI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 26: SMTI. NIOJILA L. YIMCHUNGER PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL MIMI Page No. # 82/105 UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 27: SMTI. ROSE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL OLD MONGER UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 28: SHRI. S. TSIKHASE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. HIGH SCHOOL SITIMI TOWN UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 29: SMTI. LILANGLA P. SANGTAM PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KIPHIRE STATION-B UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 30: SMTI. Y. ATOLI PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL METONGER UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 31: SHRI. ZUVLENKI PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL CHOMI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 32: SHRI. YANGTSIPI I PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER Page No. # 83/105 GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGYA UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 33: SHRI. T. LIKHUMLA PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL AMAHATOR UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 34: SHRI. S. THSAROPI PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL AMAHATOR UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 35: SHRI. LAKIMONG SANGTAM PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT.

MIDDLE SCHOOL SEYOCHUNG UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 36: SMTI. SEPILA SANGTAM PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL LONGYA UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 37: SHRI. JOHN YIMCHUNGER PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SALOMI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND Page No. # 84/105 38: SHRI. TOSHIBA KHEPHURE PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SALOMI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 39: SHRI. SEPIKYU S. SANGTAM PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KIPHIRE STATION-B UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 40: SMTI. AOLA PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL KIPHIRE STATION-B UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 41: SHRI. HOVIKA PART TIME HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SANGPHURE UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 42: SHRI. SEPICHO PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SANGPHURE UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 43: SMTI. A. YANGTSASELA PART TIME KNITTING INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL 44: SHRI. T. SELITHRONG Page No.

# 85/105 PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL PHISAMI UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 45: SHRI. IHOTO A. SUMI PART TIME CARPENTRY INSTRUCTOR GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SITIMI TOWN UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND 46: SHRI. T. YANGSERI SANGTAM PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVT. MIDDLE SCHOOL SEYOCHUNG UNDER SDEO KIPHIRE NAGALAND VERSUS THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY GOVT. OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER KIPHIRE NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY Page No.

# 86/105 DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT(MHRD) 124-C SHASTRI BHAVAN NEW DELHI ------------ Advocate for : JOSHUA SHEQI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS Linked Case : WP(C)/279/2021 SHRI. MUGHASHETO H ASSUMI AND 46 ORS PART TIME DRAWING TEACHER GOVERNMENT MIDDLE SCHOOL AQUBA OLD UNDER SDEO AGHUNATO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 2: SHRI KIVIKA Y GMS D C HILL UNDER SDEO ZUBHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 3: SHRI. KAKHEHO SEMA GMS AQUABA UNDER SDEO AGHUNATO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 4: SHRI. MUGHAHO G ACHUMI GMS APUKITO UNDER SDEOZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 5: SHRI. SAMUEL H KESHO GMS APUKITO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 6: SHRI. NIGHATO AYE GMS AIZUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 7: SMTI. VITOHOLI SUMI Page No. # 87/105 GMS AQUABA UNDER SDEO AIZUTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 8: SHRI. KAVI SUMI GMS AKULUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 9: SMTI.

TOLI GMS AKULUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 10: SHRI. IKHETO L SEMA GMS AKULUTO UNDER SDEO AGHUNATO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 11: SMTI. KINIHOLI GMS AOYSAKILIMI UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 12: SHRI. ATSATO GMS AOYSAKILIMI UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 13: SMTI. BOTOLI GMS DC HILL UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 14: SMTI. ALOMI K. SHOHE GMS DC HILL UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 15: SHRI. AKAHO YEPTHO GMS THOKIHI UNDER SDEO AGHUNATO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 16: SMTI. TOPENI S GMS THOKIHI UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND Page No. # 88/105 17: SMTI. VILIKA GMS AQUABA OLD UNDER SDEO AGHUNATO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 18: SHRI. KHEKITO GMS AKULUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 19: SMTI. HOLOKALI GMS THOKIHI UNDER SDEO AGHUNATO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 20: SMTI. KIVITOLI N YEPTHO GMS ALAHUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 21: SMTI. LOVI SWU GMS SATAKA OLD UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 22: SHRI.

G TITO SUMI GMS SATAKHA OLD UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 23: SHRI. GHOKHETO KATHO GMS APUKITO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 24: SMTI. AVILO X CHOPHI GMS SAHUBOTO UNDER SDEO AGHUNATO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 25: SMTI. NAGAHOLI GMS SAHUBOTO UNDER SDEO AGHUNATO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 26: SMTI. ATOKALI K GMS SAHUBOTO Page No. # 89/105 UNDER SDEO AGHUNATO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 27: SHRI. PULOTO H AWOMI GMS ASUKHUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 28: SMTI. KHEKALI GMS ASUKHUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 29: SHRI. HOVITO GMS ASUKHUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 30: SHRI. KAHO GMS KILOMI UNDER SDEO PUGHOBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 31: SHRI. BOTOSHE K KIHO GMS KILOMI UNDER SDEO PUGHOBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 32: SHRI. K. KIVIBO SUMI GMS CHISHOLIMI UNDER SDEO PUGHOBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 33: SHRI. K VIYITO SWU GMS CHISHILOMI UNDER SDEO PUGHOBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 34: SHRI. MUGHATO K KIHO GMS CHISHILOMI UNDER SDEO PUGHOBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 35: SHRI.

MUGHAVI A TUCCU GMS PROJECT UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND Page No. # 90/105 36: SHRI. MUGASHE YEPTHO GMS PROJECT UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 37: SMTI. LIVI AWOMI GMS PROJECTI UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 38: SHRI. KITOKA K TUCCU GMS SOUTH POINT UNDER SDEO PUGHOBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 39: SMTI. TOGHUKALI N GMS SOUTH POINT UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 40: SHRI. OTOKA K ACHUMI GMS SOUTH POINT UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 41: SMTI. VINOVI N ZHIMOMI GMS ALAHUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 42: SHRI. KANITO K JIMO GMS OLD TOWN UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 43: SMTI. VITOKALI GMS OLD TOWN UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 44: SHRI. HONIVI SEMA GMS KILOMI UNDER SDEO PUGHOBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 45: SMTI. LOVITOLI GMS OLD TOWN UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO Page No. # 91/105 ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 46: SMTI. JUBILTOLI GMS AIZUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND 47: SMTI.

XUVILI M ACHUMI GMS ALAHUTO UNDER SDEO ZUNHEBOTO ZUNHEBOTO-NAGALAND VERSUS STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECREATARY GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 2:THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR DIRECTORATE OF SCHOOL EDUCATION KOHIMA NAGALAND 3:THE MISSION DIRECTOR NAGALAND EDUCATION MISSION SOCIETY KOHIMA NAGALAND 4:THE DEO ZUNHEBOTO NAGALAND 5:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT (MHRD) 124-C SHASTRI BHAVAN NEW DELHI ------------ Advocate for : JOSHUA SHEQI Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for STATE OF NAGALAND AND 4 ORS Page No. # 92/105 BEFORE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA ORDER Date : 11. 03. 2024 Heard Mr. Joshua Sheqi, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. N. Angami, learned Govt. advocate appearing for respondent nos. 1, 2 and 4, Mr. C. T. Jamir, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.

Aliba Ozukum, learned counsel for respondent no. 3 and Mr. Yangerwati, learned CGC appearing for respondent no. 5. 2. Common questions of fact and law arise for determination in all these writ petitions. The learned counsel and senior counsel for the appearing parties have jointly submitted that all this cases are tagged together and common orders are passed in these matters and therefore, they have jointly prayed that the matter be heard together by taking the record of W. P. (C) No. 269/2021 as the lead case. Accordingly, these matters have been heard together. 3. In brief, the case of the petitioners is that the petitioners in all these writ petitions were appointed as Part-Time Instructors (hereinafter referred to as PTI for short) and they were posted in different schools during the year 2015-16 in a fixed pay of Rs. 10,000/- per month under the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan programmes.

The engagement was initially for a period of six months subject to further extension and it is projected that the services of the petitioners were extended from time to time. It is the case of the petitioners that in course of their service period, by a Page No. # 93/105 communication dated 27. 08. 2018, the fixed pay of the petitioners was reduced from Rs. 10,000/- per month to fixed pay of Rs. 7,000/-per month. 4. The under Secretary to the Govt. of Nagaland, Department of School Education, by a communication dated 29. 05. 2019, informed the Director of School Education, Nagaland that the fund provision has not been made to meet the salaries of the PTI in the Project Appraisal Board Outlay and accordingly, it was reiterated that no further extension beyond 30. 06. 2018 will be considered. Notwithstanding that the all Nagaland PTI (SSA) had represented before the Government for extension of their services, the Director of School Education, Nagaland, issued a notice dated 26. 06.

2019, informing all the PTIs that in pursuance to government directive dated 29. 05. 2019, no further extension beyond 30. 06. 2018 will be admissible. 5. Claiming that the petitioners were performing the duties till the month of June, 2019, the petitioners approached this Court and by filing WP(C) Nos. 158/2019 to WP(C) No. 168/2019, prayer was made for payment of salaries and extension of service. This Court disposed of those writ petitions vide separate orders dated 19. 09. 2019. The relevant portion of the said order dated 19. 09. 2019 is extracted below: “In view of the writ petitioners’ claim that they have rendered their services as part time employee with the respondent authorities for the period mentioned above, I deem it appropriate to dispose of this writ petition with a direction to respondent authorities, more particularly, the respondent Nos. 3 and 4, the Principal Director, Director of School Education, Kohima and the Mission Director, Page No.

# 94/105 Nagaland Education Society, Kohima to verify as to whether the writ petitioners did actually render their services as part time employee for the period June, 2018 to June, 2019. If on such verification made it is found that the writ petitioners have actually rendered their services for the period mentioned above, the respondent authorities, more particularly, the respondent Nos. 3 and 4 shall release their salaries for the period mentioned above. The necessary verification as indicated hereinabove and the payment of salaries thereof, if entitled to, shall be completed within a period of 2 (two) months from today. Writ petition is disposed of in terms of the above. ” 6. In these writ petitions, it is projected that a writ petition, being WP(C) 188/2019, was subsequently filed only for salary for the duties performed as the petitioners therein were under the impression that there was not fund provision for their salary or extension of service.

The said writ petition was disposed of by order dated 21. 10. 2019. The said order is quoted below: “Heard Mr. Joshua Sheqi, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners and also heard Mr. N. Angami, learned Government Advocate appearing for the State respondents No. 1, 3 & 5. It is submitted by Mr. Joshua, learned counsel for the petitioners that the petitioners were appointed as part time instructors in different Schools under SSA between the year 2015-2016 and since the day of their appointment they have continued to work uninterruptedly till 26. 06. 2019 on which a notification No. ED/ SSAPTI/ EXTN/18/2017/747, dated 26. 06. 2019, was issued by the Additional Director, Directorate of School Education, Government of Nagaland which states that there would be no further extension of their service beyond 30. 06. 2019. It is also submitted by the learned counsel that the petitioners have no longer any grievance other than for the non payment of their salaries between 30. 06.

2018 till the date the notification stated above was issued i. e. 26. 06. 2019. Mr. Joshua submitted that since the Page No. # 95/105 petitioners were working continuously till the date the notification was issued they should be paid their salaries for that period. He also submitted that in similar cases filed by similarly situated persons, this Court had directed the State respondents to pay the salary of those persons for the period they were working, therefore, this writ petition may also be disposed of with the same direction. Mr. N. Angami, learned Government Advocate submits that this writ petition may be disposed of in line with the directions given in the writ petitions W. P. (C) No. 158/2019, W. P. (C) No. 159/2019, W. P. (C) No. 160/2019, W. P. (C) No. 161/2019, W. P. (C) No. 162/2019, W. P. (C) No. 163/2019, W. P. (C) No. 164/2019, W. P. (C) No. 165/2019, W. P. (C) No. 166/2019 W. P. (C) No. 167/2019 & W. P. (C) No. 168/2019.

In view of the submissions of both the learned counsels and in view of the fact that the order dated 26. 06. 2019 was issued by giving retrospective effect, the respondents are directed to pay the salary of the petitioners for the period between 30. 06. 2018 to 26. 06. 2019, if on verification, they are found to have worked during the same period. The writ petition stands disposed” 7. The petitioners project that they were mislead by communication dated 29. 05. 2019 by the under Secretary to the Govt. of Nagaland, Department of School Education wherein it was stated that fund position has not been made to make the salaries of the PTIs in the Project Appraisal Board outlay and that no extension beyond 30. 06. 2018 will be considered. Pursuant to above, the Director of School Education, Nagaland had issued notice dated 26. 06. 2019, discontinuing the services of the petitioners as PTIs beyond 30. 06. 2018.

It is projected that the petitioners had doubted the stand of the State respondent and therefore, made RTI application and on receipt of RTI reply, to their shock they found that salary provisions have been made for payment to 2633 PTIs for Page No. # 96/105 the year 2019-20, 2020-21 and 2021-22 and that approval was made for a total fund of Rs. 7193. 52 crore which is inclusive of the salaries of the PTIs to the extent of Rs. 5,31,72,000/- per year. Accordingly, it is projected that in 28 months till October, 2021, the State respondents had diverted and or misappropriated a sum of Rs. 12,40,68,000/- at the rate of Rs. 7,000/- per PTI per month. 8. Accordingly, by filing these writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioners have made the following prayers: “A. Quash and set aside the letter No.

DSE/SSA/APPT/ INSTRUCTORS/2012/499 dated Kohima the 29th May, 2019 (ANNEXURE-27) falsely declaring/claiming that the salary for PTI has not been made by the Project Appraisal/Approval Board outlay. B. Quash and set aside the Notice No. ED/SSA- PTI/EXTN/18/2017/747, dated Kohima the 26th June, 2019 (ANNEXURE- 29) denying extension of service to the petitioners. C. Direct the Chief Secretary to constitute an enquiry committee to enquire into the mismanagement/diversion/misappropriation of the salary of the petitioners. D. Direct the State Respondents to reinstate the services of the petitioners' w. e. f. July 2019 with all pay consequential benefits till reinstatement. E. Direct the State Respondents not to disturb the services of the petitioners so long as the funding under Samagra Shiksha continues. ” 9.

The learned counsel for the petitioners has meticulously referred to the writ petitions, affidavits exchanged by the parties and documents appended thereto in support of his contention that in the previous round of litigation, the State Government has mislead not only the petitioners but also this Court by suppressing material facts that in the project approval board by the minutes of Page No. # 97/105 meeting held on 07. 05. 2019 had approved the annual work plan and budget for the year 2019-20 under Samagra Siksha for the State of Nagaland which included salary for 211 Art Education PTI, 211 Health and Physical Education PTI and 211 any other PTI, totalling 633 PTI with financial support of Rs. 5312. 72 lakh. 10.

The learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that on having approval of the annual plan for 2019-20 of Samagra Siksha for the State of Nagaland with further budgetary support for the year 2019-20 and 2020-21 for similar amount, there was no justification for the School Education Department to terminate the service of the petitioners beyond 30. 06. 2018. It was submitted that assuming that there might have been a default on part of the Department of School Education and Literacy, Ministry of Human Resource Development, Govt. of India in making full payment of the approved amount of Rs. 5312. 72 lakh, the Director of School Education, Nagaland could have discontinued engagement of some PTIs but they could not have terminated all the PTIs when they were receiving funds from the Govt. of India for payment of salary to PTIs. Hence, it was submitted that notwithstanding that the hereinbefore referred communication dated 29. 05.

2019 was placed in the earlier batch of writ petitions, the prayers made in these writ petitions were not hit by the principles of res judicata because this is a case where the State respondents had presented an incorrect fact in the earlier round of writ petitions, which was later on found to be false. It was also submitted that the State respondents have targeted only the PTIs and discontinued their service whereas all other categories of teachers are continuing in service and receiving their salaries and accordingly, it is submitted that the petitioners Page No. # 98/105 have been discriminated against by the State respondents. 11. The learned senior counsel for the respondent no. 3 has raised a preliminary issue of maintainability of these writ petitions on two grounds. Firstly that the notice dated 26. 06. 2019 regarding discontinuation of extension beyond 30. 06. 2018 was challenged by filing WP(C) Nos. 158/2019 to WP(C) No. 168/2019 which was all disposed of by order dated 19.

09. 2019 without granting them any relief save and except payment of salary for the period from June 2018 to June, 2019. Secondly, on the ground that the prayer in WP(C) 188/2019 was only for salary between 30. 06. 2018 to 26. 06. 2019 and that in the said writ petition, a specific stand on behalf of the petitioners has been recorded in the order dated 21. 10. 2019 to the effect that the petitioners have no longer any grievance other than for non-payment of their salaries between 30. 06. 2018 to 26. 06. 2019. Accordingly, it is submitted that the present writ petitions were barred by the principle of estoppel and res judicata. It was submitted that in the minutes of the meeting of the Project Approval Board held on 07. 09. 2019, on which reliance is placed by the petitioners, it was clearly stated as follows- “An amount of Rs. 7193. 52 lakh was estimated as support for teacher salary as per norms of the scheme, including 633 contractual instructors/ teachers.

State was advised to relook at the requirement of teacher/ headmaster posts and rationalise deployment of teachers as all teachers are the responsibilities of the State. There is no dual cadre of teachers- only financial support for additional teachers salary would be provided under the Samagra Siksha. Any additionality as per terms and conditions for recruitment of the teachers in State is to borne by the State. ” Page No. # 99/105 12. The learned senior counsel for the respondent no. 3 has submitted that a specific stand taken in the affidavit in opposition filed by the respondent no. 3 is that the discontinuation of the service of the petitioners was done by order dated 25. 09. 2019, issued by the Director of School Education, Nagaland due to fund constraint for payment of their salaries.

It was further submitted that a specific stand was taken that in most of the cases, the fund released to Nagaland Education Mission Society was much lesser than the fund approved by the Project Appraisal Board (also called Project Approval Board) and thus, discontinuation of service of the petitioner was sought to be justified. It was further submitted that the respondent no. 5, through the under Secretary, Ministry of Education, in their affidavit-in-opposition has taken a specific plea that salary and service conditions of PTIs fall under the domain of the State Government and that by filing additional affidavit, the respondent no. 5 has vindicated the stand of the State respondent no. 3 that the actual central disbursement was less than the total outlay. 13. The learned CGC as well as the learned Govt. advocate for respondent nos. 1, 2 and 4 have both supported the submissions made by the learned senior counsel for respondent no. 3. 14.

In connection with the record of the lead case, i. e. W. P. (C) 269/2021, perused the writ petition; affidavit-in-opposition by respondent nos. 1, 2 and 4; affidavit-in-opposition by respondent no. 3; affidavit-in-opposition by respondent no. 5; two additional affidavit-in-opposition by respondent no. 5; affidavit-in-reply by the petitioner against affidavit-in-opposition filed by respondent no. 3; affidavit-in-reply by Mission Director, Samgra Siksha (respondent Page No. # 100/105 no. 3) against to the additional affidavit-in-opposition by respondent no. 5. 15. In respect of the relief claimed vide prayer (B) of W. P. (C) 269/2021, it is seen from the orders dated 19. 09. 2019, passed by the coordinate Bench of this Court in WP(C) Nos. 158/2019 to WP(C) No. 168/2019 that the notice bearing no. ED/SSA- PTI/EXTN/18/2017/747 dated 26. 06. 2019, issued by the Director of School Education, Nagaland to the PTIs was under challenge in the said series of writ petitions.

Therefore, the said prayer having been rejected, the prayer (B) of these writ petitions are barred under the principles of res judicata, as the said prayer was directly and substantially in issue in the previous series of writ petitions. In this regard, it may be stated that the Supreme Court of India in the case of Samir Kumar Majumdar Vs. Union of India & Ors. , (2023) 0 INSC 836: (2023) 0 Supreme (SC) 975 has held that in interest of the State there should be end of litigation and no party ought to be best twice in a litigation for one and the same cause. 16. The learned senior counsel for the respondent no. 3 had pointed out that on behalf of the petitioners in W. P. (C) No. 188/2019, a clear stand was taken before this Court to the effect that the petitioners had no grievance other than for non-payment of their salaries between 30. 06. 2018 to 26. 06. 2019, which was a relief granted to them.

Thus, the Court is of the considered opinion that the prayers made in this writ petition are hit by the principles of constructive res judicata, as per the principles of Explanation IV to section 11 CPC. It is no longer res integra that the said provision applies to a writ petition as successive writ petitions cannot be filed for one relief and again for another relief on the ground of omission Page No. # 101/105 to make all prayers in earlier writ petition. If one requires any authority on the point, reference may be made to case of State of Orissa Vs. Laxmi Narayan Das (Dead) through LRs, (2023) 0 INSC 619: (2023) 0 Supreme (SC) 629, and the case of M. J. Exporters Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of India & Ors. , (2021) 13 SCC 343. It may also be stated that the previous set of litigations were filed to challenge the notice dated 26. 06. 2019. The government directives vide communication dated 29. 05. 2019 was mentioned in the said notice dated 26. 06. 2019. From the order dated 19. 09.

2019 referred above, it is not known whether the said communication dated 29. 05. 2019 was assailed by the petitioners or

Source: Gauhati High Court. Dataset: Dattam Labs. CC BY 4.0. Text extracted automatically; compare with the source PDF for layout and accuracy.