SMTI. MOARENLA AND 99 ORS v. TEMJEN TOY, IAS AND 9 ORS

Court: Gauhati High Court

Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KAKHETO SEMA

Judgment date: 2024-06-25

Case summary

Gauhati High Court judgment dated 2024-06-25. SMTI. MOARENLA AND 99 ORS v. TEMJEN TOY, IAS AND 9 ORS. Read the judgment and case details on LawSphereX.

Judgment text

Page No. # 1/21 GAHC020003382024 THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) KOHIMA BENCH Case No. : I. A. (Civil)/95/2024 SMTI. MOARENLA AND 99 ORS BILL ASSISTANT, SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL), TULI, MOKOKCHUNG, NAGALAND VERSUS TEMJEN TOY, IAS AND 9 ORS THE FINANCE COMMISSIONER TO THE GOVT. OF NAGALAND, NAGALAND, KOHIMA 2:DINESH KUMAR IAS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY DEPT. OF PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS NAGALAND KOHIMA 3:SHRI K. D. VIZO THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY DEPT. OF POWER NAGALAND KOHIMA 4:ER. SHIKATO SEMA THE ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF DEPT. OF POWER NAGALAND KOHIMA 5:SHRI SENTIYANGER IAS Page No. # 2/21 FINANCE COMMISSIONER GOVT. OF NAGALAND 6:SHRI R. RAMAKHRISHNANAN IAS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY P AND AR DEPT NAFALAND KOHIMA 7:ER. NRIBEMO MOZHUI ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF DEPT. OF POWER NAGALAND KOHIMA 8:SHRI ANOOP KHINCHI COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY DEPT. OF P AND AR NAGALAND KOHIMA 9:SMTI.

ASANGLA IMTI IAS THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY DEPT. OF POWER NAGALAND KOHIMA 10:ER. WABANGMEREN JAMIR THE ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF DEPT. OF POWER NAGALAND KOHIM Advocate for the Petitioner : SUPONGWATI WALLING R ATSULA KIPS Advocate for the Respondent : Linked Case : COP(C)/6/2020 MOARENLA AND 99 ORS BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND Page No. # 3/21 2: PURTULA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) CHANGTONGYA NAGALAND 3: MARLILA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) CHANGTONGYA NAGALAND 4: N. ATULA AO BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) TULI NAGALAND 5: RONGSENLEMLA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) YISEMONG NAGALAND 6: M. ALEMLA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) TULI NAGALAND 7: ZANTHUNGO PATTON BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) SANIS NAGALAND Page No.

# 4/21 8: BENATHUNG LOTHA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) WOKHA NAGALAND 9: LOTHUNGI ODYUO BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) WOKHA NAGALAND 10: IMNA AO BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) WOKHA NAGALAND 11: KAINI ROSE MARY BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) WOKHA NAGALAND 12: ASANGLA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 13: AOKUMLA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT. DIVISION Page No. # 5/21 DIMAPUR NAGALAND 14: KISILU RENGMA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 15: RONGSENMENLA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 16: Y. AKALA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 17: VESOPOLU CHAKHESANG BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO.

1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 18: MOASUNEP BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) Page No. # 6/21 NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 19: VIKIYE SEMA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) CHANGTONGYA NAGALAND 20: AKOKHE SEMA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 21: ARIANG PANEI BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO. 2 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 22: PANGERLEMLA AO BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO. 2 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 23: AVILI ACHUMI BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) Page No. # 7/21 NO. 2 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 24: TIAPENLA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO. 2 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 25: KATILA AO BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 26: A.

MOALEMLA BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 27: SUSUKALA BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 28: TEMJENLIBA AO BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 29: VIHOLI AWOMI BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) Page No. # 8/21 NO. 3 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 30: TEMJENYAPANG BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 31: IMSUTOSHI BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 32: TIAJUNGLA BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 33: BANGJUNGLEMLA BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 34: LAMPHA KONYAK BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MON NAGALAND 35: M. NOKYOI KONYAK BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MON NAGALAND Page No. # 9/21 36: Y. LILANG MONYU KONYAK BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MON NAGALAND 37: Y.

JAIYING BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MON NAGALAND 38: IRENE BELHO BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 39: PUCHOSULE SALE BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 40: NRUBENI LOTHA BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 41: KETUESENUO SEKHOSE BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 42: NEINGUNUO Page No. # 10/21 BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 43: TEISOVINUO ANGAMI BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO.

1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 44: YENLIN KONYAK BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MON NAGALAND 45: KHUTOLI CHISHI BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) CHUMUKEDIMA NAGALAND 46: YASANARO BILL ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) DIMAPUR NAGALAND 47: KHALONYI THERIE BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PFUTSERO NAGALAND 48: ZHIELHITO-U MERO BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PFUTSERO NAGALAND Page No. # 11/21 49: ECHUNGBENI BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 50: SHIEZO BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PHEK NAGALAND 51: VEVOLU BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PHEK NAGALAND 52: KENEISANO BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PHEK NAGALAND 53: SETALU BILL ASSISTANT SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PHEK NAGALAND 54: L. WENNYIM KONYAK METERREADER EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MON NAGALAND 55: B.

LONGAU PHOM METER READER Page No. # 12/21 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MON NAGALAND 56: PHUTON KONYAK METER READER EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MON NAGALAND 57: TSATHRILI SANGTAM METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 58: RUOKUOVITUO MEPFU-O METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 59: JOSEPH METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PHEK NAGALAND 60: LIRUSIE METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PHEK NAGALAND 61: SHEKHOTA Page No. # 13/21 METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PHEK NAGALAND 62: K. KHESOH METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PHEK NAGALAND 63: VETAZO METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PHEK NAGALAND 64: DINO BASUMATARI METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 65: TSOPOTHUNG METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO.

1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 66: Y. NOKHAM K METER READER EXCECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MON NAGALAND Page No. # 14/21 67: C. WONPE PHOM METER READER EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MON NAGALAND 68: YEKAHO V. METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 69: SALUVI SEMA METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 70: TOKISHE METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 71: NEITSUPE WETSAH METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) PFUTSERO NAGALAND 72: N. TAZUNG METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) Page No. # 15/21 CHANGTONGYA NAGALAND 73: ABEN LOTHA METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO.

2 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 74: CHENYAWA MAGH RENGMA METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) WOKHA NAGALAND 75: TIMOTHY LOTHA METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 76: MOTSUO LOTHA METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) WOKHA NAGALAND 77: KINSAMO LOTHA METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) SANIS NAGALAND 78: SEYEIKIETUO METER READER Page No. # 16/21 SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 79: WONIMO METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) SANIS NAGALAND 80: DAVID YEPTHO METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) WOKHA NAGALAND 81: HOSHIKA METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) SANIS NAGALAND 82: INAVI I. CHISHI METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) SANIS NAGALAND 83: G. HEVIS WOTSA METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) WOKHA NAGALAND 84: H. EYENGBEMO KIKON METER READER Page No.

# 17/21 SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) WOKHA NAGALAND 85: TOMUKAM METER READER EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) TUENSANG NAGALAND 86: KHRIEZOTUO DZUVICHU METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE KOHIMA ELECT DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 87: H. NOKRUMBA YIMCHUNGER METER READER EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) TUENSANG NAGALAND 88: PUCHIO KHIAMNUNGAN METER READER EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) TUENSANG NAGALAND 89: TALITSUDEN METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 90: K. L. MEREN Page No. # 18/21 METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 91: K. PANGERLEMLA METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 92: RISANG AO METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 93: MOATEMJEN JAMIR METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO.

1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 94: KISHETO METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 95: LAMMANG METER READER Page No. # 19/21 SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL)NO. 1 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 96: NYIMTHUNGO LOTHA METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO. 2 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 97: IMTITOSHI METER READER SUB-DIVISIONAL OFFICER(ELECTRICAL) NO. 2 OFFICE DIMAPUR ELECT DIVISION DIMAPUR NAGALAND 98: NUNGSHIYANGER METER READER EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 99: SAKUMEREN METER READER EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND 100: RONGSENMEREN METER READER EXECUTIVE ENGINEER(ELECTRICAL) MOKOKCHUNG Page No. # 20/21 NAGALAND VERSUS TEMJEN TOY IAS AND 6 ORS THE FINANCE COMMISSIONER TO THE GOVT. OF NAGALAND NAGALAND KOHIMA 2:DINESH KUMAR IAS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY DEPT. OF PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS NAGALAND KOHIMA 3:K. D.

VIZO THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY DEPT. OF POWER NAGALAND KOHIMA 4:ER. SHIKATO SEMA THE ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF DEPT. OF POWER NAGALAND KOHIMA 5:SHRI SENTIYANGER IAS FINANCE COMMISSIONER GOVT. OF NAGALAND 6:SHRI R. RAMAKHRISHNANAN IAS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY P AND AR DEPT NAFALAND KOHIMA 7:ER. NRIBEMO MOZHUI ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF DEPT. OF POWER NAGALAND KOHIMA ------------ Advocate for : JUSTIN MAGH Advocate for : appearing for TEMJEN TOY IAS AND 6 ORS Page No. # 21/21 BEFORE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KAKHETO SEMA ORDER 25. 06. 2024 Heard Ms. R. Atsula Kips, learned counsel for the applicant. The present application has been filed for impleadment of:- (i) Shri Anoop Khinchi, IAS, Commissioner & Secretary to the Government of Nagaland, Department of P&AR, Nagaland, Kohima (ii) Smti. Asangla Imti, IAS, Commissioner & Secretary, Department of Power, Nagaland, Kohima, and (iii) Er. Wabangmeren Jamir, Engineer-in-Chief, Department of Power, Nagaland, Kohima, as the respondent Nos.

8, 9 and 10 in COP(C)/6/2020. The petition for impleadment is allowed. Sd/- JUDGE Comparing Assistant

Source: Gauhati High Court. Dataset: Dattam Labs. CC BY 4.0. Text extracted automatically; compare with the source PDF for layout and accuracy.