SURESH KUMAR v. HRTC AND ANR

Court: High Court of Himachal Pradesh

Bench: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE L. NARAYANA SWAMY,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANOOP CHITKARA

Judgment date: 2020-12-23

Case summary

High Court of Himachal Pradesh judgment dated 2020-12-23. SURESH KUMAR v. HRTC AND ANR. Read the judgment and case details on LawSphereX.

Judgment text

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA CWP No 4605 of 2020 with CWP Nos. 4606, 4610, 4611, 4619, 4621, 4624, 4625, 4626, 4627, 4636, 4639, 4640, 4665, 4666, 4667, 4675, 4676, 4677, 4834, 6117, 6118, 6119, 6120, 6121, 6130, 6131, 6132, 6133, 6134, 6135, 6136, 6137, 6139, 6140, 6141, 6142, 6143, 6144, 6145, 6146, 6147, 6149, 6150, 6151, 6152, 6154, 6155, 6156, 6157, 6158, 6159, 6161, 6163, 6165, 6166, 6167, 6168, 6170, 6171, 6172, 6173, 6175, 6176, 6178, 6180 and 6183 of 2020. rd Date of Decision : 23 December, 2020. 1. CWP No. 4605 of 2020. Kartar Singh ……. Petitioner. Versus H. R. T. C. & Another ...... Respondents. 2. CWP No. 4606 of 2020. Sunny …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents. 3. CWP No. 4610 of 2020 Surjeet Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 4. CWP No. 4611 of 2020 Kuldip Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 5. CWP No. 4619 of 2020 Sunil Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 6.

CWP No. 4621 of 2020. Harish Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 7. CWP No. 4624 of 2020. Jitender Singh …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 8. CWP No. 4625 of 2020. Hamesh Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 9. CWP No. 4626 of 2020. Naresh Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 10. CWP No. 4627 of 2020. Satya Prakash …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 11. CWP No. 4636 of 2020. Suman Singh …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 12. CWP No. 4639 of 2020. Suresh Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 13. CWP No. 4640 of 2020. Sumit Sharma …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 14. CWP No. 4665 of 2020. Vijay Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 15. CWP No. 4666 of 2020. Binnu Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 16. CWP No. 4667 of 2020. Atul Sharma …...

Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 17. CWP No. 4675 of 2020. Shambhu Singh …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 18. CWP No. 4676 of 2020. Rakesh Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 19. CWP No. 4677 of 2020. Shashi Kant …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 20. CWP No. 4834 of 2020. Abhinav Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 21. CWP No. 6117 of 2020. Ghanshyam …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 22. CWP No. 6118 of 2020. Ashish Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 23. CWP No. 6119 of 2020. Roop Singh …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 24. CWP No. 6120 of 2020. Vijay Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 25. CWP No. 6121 of 2020. Ramesh Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 26. CWP No. 6130 of 2020. Deepak Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 27. CWP No. 6131 of 2020.

Kushal Chaudhary …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 28. CWP No. 6132 of 2020. Anish Kashyap …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 29. CWP No. 6133 of 2020. Mukesh …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 30. CWP No. 6134 of 2020. Hitender Mehta …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 31. CWP No. 6135 of 2020. Joginder Pal …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 32. CWP No. 6136 of 2020. Umeshwer Prakash …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 33. CWP No. 6137 of 2020. Raj Pal …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 34. CWP No. 6139 of 2020. Ajay Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 35. CWP No. 6140 of 2020. Suresh Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 36. CWP No. 6141 of 2020. Karam Chand …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 37. CWP No. 6142 of 2020. Jeewan Lal …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 38.

CWP No. 6143 of 2020. Lalit …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 39. CWP No. 6144 of 2020. Vijay Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 40. CWP No. 6145 of 2020. Kesav Ram …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 41. CWP No. 6146 of 2020. Amar Chand …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 42. CWP No. 6147 of 2020. Umesh Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 43. CWP No. 6149 of 2020. Mukesh Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 44. CWP No. 6150 of 2020. Nanak Chand …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 45. CWP No. 6151 of 2020. Ajay Singh …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 46. CWP No. 6152 of 2020. Mukesh Thakur …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 47. CWP No. 6154 of 2020. Daleep Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 48. CWP No. 6155 of 2020. Pradeep Singh …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another …..

Respondents 49. CWP No. 6156 of 2020. Vinod Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 50. CWP No. 6157 of 2020. Shadi Lal …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 51. CWP No. 6158 of 2020. Om Prakash Sharma …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 52. CWP No. 6159 of 2020. Jia Lal …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 53. CWP No. 6161 of 2020. Vishal …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 54. CWP No. 6163 of 2020. Labh Singh …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 55. CWP No. 6165 of 2020. Hari Krishan …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 56. CWP No. 6166 of 2020. Chetan Azad …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 57. CWP No. 6167 of 2020. Amar Chand …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 58. CWP No. 6168 of 2020. Shiv Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 59. CWP No. 6170 of 2020. Povinder Kumar …...

Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 60. CWP No. 6171 of 2020. Rup Singh …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 61. CWP No. 6172 of 2020. Roop Lal …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 62. CWP No. 6173 of 2020. Sukhdev Chaudhary …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 63. CWP No. 6175 of 2020. Hem Raj …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 64. CWP No. 6176 of 2020. Roshan Lal …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 65. CWP No. 6178 of 2020. Diwan Chand …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 66. CWP No. 6180 of 2020. Dinesh Kumar …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents 67. CWP No. 6183 of 2020. Kuldeep Braktu …... Petitioner Versus HRTC & Another ….. Respondents Coram: The Hon’ble Mr. Justice L. Narayana Swamy, Chief Justice The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Anoop Chitkara, Judge. Whether approved for reporting? No. For the petitioner(s) : Mr. Manohar Lal Sharma, Advocate.

For the respondents : Ms. Shubh Mahajan, Advocate, in CWP Nos. 4610, 4611, 4619, 4636, 4639, 4640, 4666, 4675, 4676, 4677, 6130, 6139, 6142, 6143, 6145, 6150, 6151, 6152, 6154, 6156 to 6159, 6166, 6168, 6170, 6175, 6176 and 6180 of 2020. Mr. Vikas Rajput, Advocate, in CWP Nos. 4605, 4606, 4665, 6117, 6120, 6121, 6131 to 6137, 6140, 6144, 6155, 6165, 6178 & 6183 of 2020. Mr. Vir Bahadur Verma, Advocate, in CWP Nos. 6146, 6147, 6163, 6167 & 6171 of 2020. Ms. Reeta Thakur, Advocate, in CWP Nos. 4626, 4667, 6118, 6119, 6141, 6149, 6161, 6172 & 6173 of 2020. Mr. Shyam Singh Chauhan, Advocate, in CWP Nos. 4621 & 4625 of 2020. Mr. Ajay Chauhan, Advocate, in CWP Nos. 4624, 4627 & 4834 of 2020. COURT PROCEEDINGS CONVENED THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCE Anoop Chitkara, Judge (oral). The petitioners, who are working as Piece Meal Workers with the respondent-Corporation, have come up before this Court seeking a direction to the respondents to convert their services on contract basis.

In this regard the petitioners have already made representations, which are still pending before the authorities concerned. Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? 2. Notice. Mrs. Shubh Mahajan, Mr. Vikas Rajput, Mr. V. B. Verma, Ms. Reeta Thakur, Mr. Shyam Singh Chauhan & Mr. Ajay Chauhan, Advocates appear and accept service of notice on behalf of the respondents. 3. In view of the nature of the order, we propose to pass, no response is required from the respondents. 4. Consequently, the petitions are disposed of with a direction to the respondents/authorities to decide the representations of the petitioners, in accordance with law, within one month. While deciding the petitioners’ representations, the respondents/authorities shall also take into consideration the judgment delivered by the learned Single Judge of this Court in CWPOA No. 1517 of 2019, titled Prem Singh versus Himachal Road Transport Corporation & Another , decided on 18. 12. 2019.

Liberty is reserved to the petitioners to approach this Court again, in case they still feel aggrieved and dissatisfied with the outcome of the representation. Pending application(s), if any, are closed. (L. Narayana Swamy) Chief Justice. (Anoop Chitkara) Judge rd 23 December, 2020 (ps/Himani)

Source: High Court of Himachal Pradesh. Dataset: Dattam Labs. CC BY 4.0. Text extracted automatically; compare with the source PDF for layout and accuracy.