M T SHIVAKUMAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court: High Court of Karnataka

Bench: P.S.DINESH KUMAR

Judgment date: 2020-12-22

Case summary

High Court of Karnataka judgment dated 2020-12-22. M T SHIVAKUMAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA. Read the judgment and case details on LawSphereX.

Judgment text

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU ND DATED THIS THE 22 DAY OF DECEMBER, 2020 BEFORE THE HON'BLE Mr. JUSTICE P. S. DINESH KUMAR WRIT PETITION NO. 1815/2020 (CS-EL/M) BETWEEN: 1 . M T SHIVAKUMAR S/O GADI THIMMEGOWDA, AGED 42 YEARS, 2 . NINGAIAH @ MUDAIAH S/O. MOLLEKEMPEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 3 . MARLINGAMMA W/O CHIKKONU, AGED 70 YEARS, 4 . CHANNEGOWDA @ KAPREGOWDA S/O DODDAGENDEGOWDA, AGED 80 YEARS, 5 . SHIVALINGAIAH S/O BOLEGOWDA, AGED 85 YEARS, 6 . M K PANCHALINGEGOWDA S/O KEMPEGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS, - 2 - 7 . MARICHANNAIAH S/O CHIKKALINGI CHANNEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 8 . SHIVARAMSHETTY S/O MULLANNA, AGED 65 YEARS, 9 . MUDDAIAH @ MOTAIAH S/O. MOLLEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 10 . M CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA S/O. MUDDALINGEGOWDA, AGED 62 YEARS, 11 . KRISHNAPPA S/O CHIKKAKADAIAH CHANNAIAH, AGED 55 YEARS, 12 . M CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA S/O GIDDAIANA LINGAIAH, AGED 68 YEARS, 13 . M C GUNDAIAH S/O CHANNAIAH, AGED 65 YEARS, 14 . M SHANKREGOWDA S/O HUCHEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 15 . K R MANJULA W/O. B.

SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, 16 . VENKATAMMA W/O. LAKSHMANA, AGED 45 YEARS, - 3 - 17 . JAYAMMA W/O CHIKKATHIMMAIAH, AGED 65 YEARS, 18 . GOPALAIAH S/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS, 19 . NINGAMMA W/O M. KARIGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 20 . M G SRIKANTA S/O GADDELINGAIAH, AGED 56 YEARS, 21 . SAVITHRAMMA W/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 22 . RAJU S/O. ANKEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 23 . CHIKKATHAYAMMA W/O MARICHANNAIAH, AGED 70 YEARS, 24 . MAYAMMA W/O CHAKKANANA KARIGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 25 . SHARADAMMA W/O SHIVARAMU, AGED 65 YEARS, - 4 - 26 . M GOPAL RAJU S/O KOMBAYYANA MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 27 . SHIVALINGAMMA W/O YANANI GOPA @ NINGAIAH, AGED 75 YEARS, 28 . PREMA W/O. H. RAJANNA, AGED 55 YEARS, 29 . LAKSHMAMMA W/O MARIGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 30 . LINGEGOWDA S/O CHANNIMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 80 YEARS, 31 . DODDANINGAMMA W/O K. R. NARASIMHAIAH, AGED 70 YEARS, 32 . RAJANNA S/O MOLLEMUDDANA MAHALINGAIAH, AGED 60 YEARS, 33 . GOWRAMMA W/O HUCHEGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 34 .

PANCHALINGAIAH S/O MADIGOPANA GADDEGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS - 5 - 35 . M DEVAKUMARA S/O MAYIGOWDA, AGED 56 YEARS, 36 . M G CHANDRASHEKARA S/O C GADDAIAH, AGED 62 YEARS 37 . SHIVANNA S/O. M. MUDDAIAH, AGED 68 YEARS, 38 . SHANKAREGOWDA S/O GOPEGOWDANA CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 57 YEARS, 39 . LAKSHMAMMA W/O LATE MARIGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 40 . SRI M NAGARAJU S/O PA-MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 41 . VENKATARAMU S/O HONNEGOWDA, AGED 76 YEARS, 42 . GIRIYAMMA W/O VENKATASHETTY, AGED 80 YEARS, 43 . KALEGOWDA C S/O. DODDANATHEGOWDA, AGED 68 YEARS, 44 . M. SUMITHRADEVI D/O M. G. MUDDAIAH, AGED 60 YEARS, - 6 - 45 . M G RAMACHANDRA W/O. GADDELINGAIAH, AGED 65 YEARS, 46 . T ANANDA S/O M. C. THATAPPA, AGED 57 YEARS, 47 . M SUNANDAMMA D/O M. G. MUDDAIAH, AGED 70 YEARS, 48 . SHIVALINGAIAH S/O MARIGOPEGOWANA GOPEGOWDA AGED 60 YEARS, 49 . JAYAMMA W/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 50 . M B SUNANDAMMA W/O M GOPALAIAH, AGED 55 YEARS, 51 . RAMAKRISHNA S/O CHIKKANATHEGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS 52 . M MALATHI D/O M. G.

MUDDAIAH, AGED 45 YEARS, 53 . SHIVARAMU S/O SIDDEGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 54 . GOPEGOWDA @ MUGA S/O GADDEGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS, - 7 - 55 . SANNAMMA W/O. KARIGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 56 . CHANNAMMA W/O CHAKKANANA HUCHEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 57 . PUTTALINGAMMA W/O CHAKKANANA DODDAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 74 YEARS, 58 . CHIKKOLAMMA W/O KARIGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 59 . SAROJAMMA W/O MARIGOWDA, AGED 64 YEARS, 60 . BHAGYAMMA W/O M. G. NARAYAN GOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 61 . CHANDRAU S/O M. KARIGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 62 . RAMANNA S/O CHAKKANANA KRISHNAPPA, AGED 50 YEARS, 63 . M B RAJU S/O BOREGOWDA, AGED 56 YEARS, 64 . S MAHESH S/O SHIVALINGAIAH AGED 35 YEARS - 8 - 65 . SHEKARA S/O MUTHAIAH, AGED 60 YEARS, 66 . PAPANNA S/O. BOREGOWDA, AGED 53 YEARS, 67 . BHARATHI W/O M. RAJANNA, AGED 56 YEARS, 68 . D VIJAYAMMA W/O. M. GOPALASWAMY, AGED 55 YEARS, 69 . ANANDA S/O. CHAKKANANA HUCHEGOWDA, AGED 56 YEARS, 70 . UMESHA S/O CHIKKABODDANNA, AGED 50 YEARS, 71 . YOGEESHA S/O C. GADDAIAH, AGED 49 YEARS 72 . MEENAKSHAMMA W/O M.

C. PANCHALINGAIAH, AGED 54 YEARS 73 . HUCHAMMA D/O BELLADAGOPEGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 74 . JAYAMMA W/O KENCHEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, - 9 - 75 . MALLESHA S/O M RAMANNA, AGED 50 YEARS, 76 . CHIKKAMARIYAMMA W/O DODDATHAMMAIAH AGED 60 YEARS, 77 . SUSHEELAMMA D/O BELLADAGOPEGOWDA, AGED 57 YEARS, 78 . S. VEDAVATHI D/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 48 YEARS, 79 . NINGAMMA D/O KENCHEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 80 . M K LALITHA D/O KENCHEGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS 81 . SUNANDAMMA W/O KADAYYANA CHANNAYYANA RAMANNA, AGED 60 YEARS, 82 . M R SUNDARA S/O M. G. RAJU, AGED 62 YEARS, 83 . M S HEMAVATHI D/O M. SHIVARAMU, AGED 46 YEARS, - 10 - 84 . M S YOGAMANI D/O M. SHIVARAMU, AGED 44 YEARS, 85 . M H SHIVAKUMARA S/O M HUCHAPPA, AGED 45 YEARS, 86 . BHAGYAMMA W/O CHIKKABODDANNA, AGED 52 YEARS, 87 . M J RAMEGOWDA S/O JAVAREGOWDA, AGED 53 YEARS, 88 . VENKATESH S/O THIMMEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 89 . M K JAYALAKSHMAMMA W/O M. K. PUTTACHARI, AGED 55 YEARS, 90 . SATHYA D/O KENCHEGOWDA, AGED 46 YEARS, 91 .

SARASI W/O MOODALAGIRISHETTY, AGED 50 YEARS, 92 . N D HAMSAVENI W/O M G RAMACHANDRA, AGED 55 YEARS, 93 . JAYARATHNAMMA W/O LINGACHARI, AGED 55 YEARS, - 11 - 94 . M. SUMITHRA W/O. GADDELINGAYYANA MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 52 YEARS, 95 . GANGADHARAIAH S/O KOLAIAH, AGED 57 YEARS, 96 . VASANTHAMMA W/O M. K. BORAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS 97 . SUSHEELAMMA W/O M. KARIGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 98 . CHANDRAMMA D/O BASAVAIAH, AGED 54 YEARS, 99 . RAJU S/O JAVAREGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 100 . CHALAVA S/O. MUTHAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, 101 . MAHALINGAIAH S/O M. B. LINGAIAH, AGED 70 YEARS, 102 . M CHANDRASHEKARA S/O M. G. MUDDAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, 103 . M R REKHA W/O M. G. RAMU AGED 52 YEARS, - 12 - 104 . SRI M G KRISHNAPPA S/O HUCHAPPANAGOPE GOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 105 . M R KOUSALYA W/O M G RAMU AGED 48 YEARS, 106 . KRISHNA S/O JAVAREGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 107 . M CHANDRASHEKARA S/O PA KARIYAPPA, AGED 62 YEARS, 108 . PUTTANARASAMMA W/O MUDDEERAIAH, AGED 70 YEARS, 109 . JAYARATHNA W/O B. SHIVALINGAPPA, AGED 57 YEARS, 110 .

M C SHANKREGOWDA S/O CHIKKALINGE GOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 111 . VENKATAIAH @ DODDATHAMMAIAH S/O THIMMEGOWDA, AGED 68 YEARS, 112 . K CHANDRASHEKARAIAH S/O M. C. KRISHNAPPA, AGED 65 YEARS, 113 . SHANTHAMMA W/O. MUNISWAMAIAH, AGED 65 YEARS, - 13 - 114 . M V SRINIVASA SHETTY S/O VENKATACHALA SHETTY, AGED 60 YEARS, 115 . G MUDDAIAH S/O GIDDAYYANA GOPEGOWDA, AGED 54 YEARS, 116 . M PANCHALINGEGOWDA S/O NACHEGOWDANA MARIGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS, 117 . KAMALAMMA W/O M. C. SHANKREGOWDA, AGED 58 YEARS, 118 . PANKAJA W/O GOPALAIAH, AGED 65 YEARS, 119 . PRASAD S/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 56 YEARS, 120 . M K RAJU S/O KARIGOWDA, AGED 54 YEARS, 121 . M S VIJAYASHANKARA S/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 57 YEARS, 122 . H N JAYARAMU S/O NATHEGOWDA AGED 50 YEARS, 123 . M C JAYARAMU S/O CHANNEGOWDA AGED 57 YEARS, - 14 - 124 . M K RAMAKRISHNA S/O. CHIKKALINGEGOWDA, AGED 62 YEARS, 125 . M S SHIVALINGAIAH S/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 48 YEARS, 126 . M CHIKKANNA S/O MARIGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 127 .

BHEEMA S/O KARIGOWDA, AGED 40 YEARS, 128 . M. N. RAMAKRISHNA S/O NINGEGOWDA, AGED 58 YEARS, 129. NANJUNDAIAH S/O GOWDAIAH, AGED 45 YEARS, 130 . RAJAMMA W/O. CHIKKAKEMPEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 131 . MALLESHA S/O KARIGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS, 132 . M T VENKATASWAMY S/O GADI THIMMEGOWDA, AGED 58 YEARS, - 15 - 133 . NANJAMMA W/O BELLEKERE KULLAIAH, AGED 75 YEARS, 134 . LOKESHA S/O GOPALAIAH, AGED 35 YEARS, 135 . CHANNAMMA W/O ANKEGOWDA, AGED 52 YEARS, 136 . MANGALAMMA D/O BELLEKERE KULLEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 137 . RATHNAMMA W/O M. C. MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 138 . ANKEGOWDA S/O BELLEKERE KULLEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 139 . MARICHANNAMMA W/O M. C. PANCHALINGEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 140 . JAYAMMA W/O. MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 141 . SAVITHA W/O. M. C. KEMPEGOWDA AGED 57 YEARS, 142 . SAVITHRAMMA D/O MEDDANA KENCHEGOWDA AGED 52 YEARS, - 16 - 143 . B C LEELAVATHI W/O M. C. MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 57 YEARS, 144 . SHIVALINGEGOWDA S/O NINGEGOWDA, AGED 72 YEARS, 145 .

M C SHANKREGOWDA S/O CHIKKAMOOGEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 146 . S N PRABHAVATHI W/O M. C. SHANKREGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS, 147 . LINGAIAH K C/O B SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, 148 . NANJAMMA W/O KULLINGI GOPEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 149 . RAMALINGEGOWDA S/O GOPEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 150 . CHIKKATHAYAMMA W/O RAMALINGEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 151 . JAYALAKSHMAMMA D/O DODDANATHEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 152 . SHARADAMMA W/O KRISHNEGOWDA, AGED 52 YEARS, - 17 - 153 . DODDATHAYAMMA W/O MUGUREGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS, 154 . ANAND S/O GONIBASAVEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 155 . L UMESHA S/O LINGEGOWDA, AGED 57 YEARS, 156 . SAVITHA W/O M N RAMAKRISHNA, AGED 50 YEARS, 157 . SUJATHA W/O K. CHANDRASHEKARAIAH, AGED 52 YEARS, 158 . PREMA D/O MEDDANAKENCHEGOWDA, AGED 42 YEARS, 159 . SAVITHRAMMA D/O KARIMUDDEGODA, AGED 55 YEARS, 160 . M D KRISHNA S/O DODDANATHEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 161 . M C SRINIVAS S/O. CHIKKAKARIGOWDA, AGED 58 YEARS, 162 . NAGARAJU M C S/O CHIKKAKARIGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, - 18 - 163 . M K BORAIAH S/O.

KARIGOWDA, AGED 57 YEARS, 164 . CHIKKATHAYAMMA W/O GADITHIMMEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 165 . M C MUDDEGOWDAZ S/O PATEL CHIKKAMOGEGOWDA, AGED 59 YEARS, 166 . BHAGYAMMA W/O KEMPEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 167 . SUDHA W/O SHIVANNA, AGED 50 YEARS, 168 . CHANNEGOWDA S/O DODANATHEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 169 . NAGAMMA W/O CHIKKAKEMPAIAH, AGED 65 YEARS, 170 . PANCHALINGEGOWDA S/O PATEL CHIKKAMOGEGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS, 171 . M C SHANKRA S/O CHIKKANATHEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 172 . M C PUTTARAJU S/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, - 19 - 173 . M C KEMPEGOWDA S/O CHANNEGOWDA @ KAPREGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 174 . ANANDA M K S/O KALACHANNEGOWDA, AGED 40 YEARS, 175 . SAROJAMMA W/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 57 YEARS, 176 . K C YASHODAMMA W/O M C SRIDHAR, AGED 56 YEARS, 177 . C CHIKKAKEMPAIAH S/O CHIKKANATHEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 178 . KRISHNEGOWDA S/O NINGEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 179 . RENUKAMMA W/O VENKATASWAMY, AGED 50 YEARS, 180 . M. C. RAJANNA S/O CHIKKANATHEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 181.

PRABHAVATHI D/O GADITHIMMEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 182 . M BALARAMU S/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, - 20 - 183 . M K CHANDRA S/O. KENCHEGOWDA, AGED 47 YEARS, 184 . M SURESH S/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, 185 . M K SHANKAR S/O PATEL KARIYAPPA, AGED 56 YEARS, 186 . M K YASHODAMMA D/O KENCHEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 187 . M S KRISHNA S/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 47 YEARS, 188 . KAMALAMMA W/O M. S. RAMESHA, AGED 50 YEARS, 189 . K N MOHAN KUMAR S/O K. R. NARASIMHAIAH, AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS, 190 . M VASANTHA S/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 191 . K N MAMATHA D/O K. R. NARASIMHAIAH, AGED 40 YEARS, 192 . UMESHA S/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 42 YEARS, - 21 - 193 . M SHANTHA D/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 194 . JAYAMMA W/O KENCHEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 195 . CHIKKENAMMA S/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 70 YEARS, 196 . M L ANANDA S/O. NINGANNA, AGED 45 YEARS, 197 . YASHODAMMA W/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 75 YEARS, 198 . RAMESHA S/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 48 YEARS, 199 . M N KRISHNA S/O NATHEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 200 . K NAGARAJU S/O M.

C. KRISHNAPPA, AGED 65 YEARS, 201 . BALARAMU S/O LINGANNA, AGED 55 YEARS, 202 . CHIKKALINGAIAH S/O. NATHAPPA AGED 57 YEARS, - 22 - 203 . PURUSHOTHAMA K S/O M. C. KRISHNAPPA, AGED 61 YEARS, 204 . BHAGYAMMA W/O NAGARAJU, AGED 58 YEARS, 205 . M N KRISHNA S/O. NINGEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 206 . LEELA W/O MAHADEVU, AGED 57 YEARS, 207 . LAKSHMAMMA W/O VENKATEGOWDA, AGED 54 YEARS, 208 . KADAMMA W/O M. B. KARIGOWDA, AGED 57 YEARS, 209 . MANGALAMMA W/O KENDEGOWDA, AGED 56 YEARS, 210 . M L NINGAMMA W/O NINGEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 211 . THIMMAIAH S/O MOLLEBETTEGOWDA, AGED 75 YEARS, 212 . CHANDRAMMA C/O MOLLEBETTEGOWDA, AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, - 23 - 213 . VIJAYALAKSHMI W/O H. RAMALINGEGOWDA, AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS, 214 . VENKATESHA S/O M. THIMMAIAH, AGED 45 YEARS, 215 . PUTTARAJU S/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 216 . M N SUJATHA W/O NINGAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, 217 . THAYAMMA W/O NINGAIAH, AGED 48 YEARS, 218 . KEMPEGOWDA S/O KARIGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 219 . KENDEGOWDA S/O NATHEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 220 .

M S GADDEGOWDA S/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 40 YEARS, 221 . JAYARAMU S/O MOLLEBETTEGOWDA, AGED 57 YEARS, 222 . THAYAMMA W/O VIJAYASHANKARA, AGED 49 YEARS - 24 - 223 . LAKSHMAMMA W/O H. RAJANNA, AGED 56 YEARS, 224 . RAMALINGAIAH S/O YA. GOPEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 225 . GOWRAMMA W/O. GOPALAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, 226 . M K RAJU S/O KALINGEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 227. SHIVAMMA W/O SHIVAPPA, AGED 78 YEARS, 228 . CHANNAMMA W/O KALINGEGOWDA, AGED 78 YEARS, 229 . CHANNAMMA W/O HUCHEGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 230 . SAROJAMMA W/O RAMEGOWDA, AGED 56 YEARS, 231 . M C MANJUNATHA S/O C. CHIKKACHANNAIAH, AGED 45 YEARS, 232 . INDIRA W/O GOPALA, AGED 55 YEARS, - 25 - 233 . M C ANANDA S/O C. CHIKKACHANNAIAH, AGED 43 YEARS, 234 . KEMPAMMA W/O VENKATARAMU, AGED 60 YEARS, 235 . VIJAYAMMA W/O B. RAMALINGAIAH, AGED 56 YEARS, 236 . K PANCHALINGAIAH S/O KEMPALINGAIAH, AGED 54 YEARS, 237 . SAKAMMA W/O MANCHEGOWDA, AGED 56 YEARS, 238 . KALAVATHI W/O M. C. JAYARAMU, AGED 48 YEARS, 239 . MAMATHA W/O JAYARAM, AGED 47 YEARS, 240 .

RAMALINGEGOWDA S/O SANNAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, 241 . PUTTALINGAMMA W/O MARIGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, 242 . NANJAMMA W/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 84 YEARS, - 26 - 243 . KANTHARAJU S/O. M. C. ANKAPPA, AGED 57 YEARS, 244 . SHANKARLINGEGOWDA S/O YAJMAN MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 56 YEARS, 245 . PUTTASWAMY S/O CHIKKANATHE GOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 246 . PUTTAMMA W/O KOLIMUDDANA MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 247 . MALLESHA S/O DOLLAIAH, AGED 40 YEARS, 248 . PADMAMMA W/O CHIKKANNA, AGED 48 YEARS, 249 . SHANKREGOWDA S/O KARIGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 250 . MANGALAMMA W/O CHANNEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 251 . PANCHALINGAIAH S/O MUGAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS, 252 . SHIVARAMU S/O MARIGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, - 27 - 253 . M J GANGADHARAIAH S/O JAVARAIAH AGED 50 YEARS, 254 . MAHESH M H S/O HUCHEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 255 . K C KAVITHA W/O SURESH, AGED 50 YEARS, 256 . M N SUNDAR S/O. NINGEGOWDA, AGED 42 YEARS, 257. SHANKREGOWDA M B S/O. BORALINGE GOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, 258 . SHIVAMMA W/O KRISHNA, AGED 50 YEARS, 259 .

M J KUMARA S/O JAVAREGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, 260 . GOPEGOWDA S/O GOPEGOWDANA CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 261 . V N PRAMOD KUMAR S/O. NAGARAJU, AGED 42 YEARS, 262 . M H MAMATHA D/O HUCHEGOWDA, AGED 43 YEARS, - 28 - 263 . YASHODA D/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, 264 . DEVARAJU S/O. MUDDAIAH, AGED 40 YEARS, 265 . GOWRAMMA W/O SHANKREGOWDA, AGED 54 YEARS, 266 . M C NAGARAJU S/O CHIKKEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 267 . SUKANYA W/O DORAISWAMY, AGED 50 YEARS, 268 . M C YOGARAJU S/O CHIKKALINGAIAH, AGED 57 YEARS, 269 . NATARAJU S/O THAMMAIAH, AGED 45 YEARS, 270 . CHANDRAKALA D/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 271 . THAYAMMA S/O M. MUDDAIAH, AGED 65 YEARS, 272 . NINGARAJU S/O NINGAIAH, AGED 48 YEARS, - 29 - 273 . VIJAYA W/O SHANKREGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 274 . THAYAMMA W/O KARIMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 70 YEARS, 275 . RAMALINGAIAH S/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA AGED 60 YEARS, 276 . M C LOKESHA S/O CHIKKALINGAIAH, AGED 48 YEARS, 277 . SHASHIKALA W/O SHIVANNA, AGED 45 YEARS, 278 .

M D RAMESH S/O DODDAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, 279 . SRINIVASU S/O THIMMEGOWDA, AGED 58 YEARS, 280 . PUSHPA W/O GOPEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS 281 . SHIVALINGAIAH S/O YA MUDDEGOWDA AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS 282 . SOMANNA S/O. THIMMEGOWDA, AGED 58 YEARS, - 30 - 283 . SHIVALINGAIAH S/O MUGUHUCHANA THAMMEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 284 . MEENAKSHI W/O PANCHALINGEGOWDA M C, AGED 50 YEARS, 285 . PUTTAMMA W/O PUTTALINGEGOWDA, AGED 57 YEARS, 286 . SUJATHA W/O M. G. CHANDRASHEKARA, AGED 45 YEARS, 287 . BHAGAYAMMA W/O G. MUDDAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, 288 . KRISHNA SHETTY S/O. VENKATACHALA SHETTY, AGED 58 YEARS, 289 . SHANKARA S/O. CHIKKABADDANNA, AGED 48 YEARS, 290 . M C NAGARAJU S/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 291 . BHAGYAMMA W/O SHANKREGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 292 . RAMESHA S/O KUNTALINGEGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, - 31 - 293 . M H SHOBHA W/O HUCHEGOWDA, AGED 36 YEARS, 294 . GANGADHARA S/O CHIKKASHETTY, AGED 58 YEARS, 295. YOGEESHA S/O KARIMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 296 . M C UMESHA S/O.

CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 46 YEARS, 297 . SHEELAMMA W/O SRINIVAS SHETTY, AGED 55 YEARS, 298 . VENKATACHALA SHETTY S/O MUDDEERAIAH, AGED 55 YEARS, 299 . BHAGYAMMA T W/O SHANKARLINGAIAH, AGED 54 YEARS, 300 . MUDDUVENKATAIAH S/O MUDDUVENKATAIAH, AGED 60 YEARS, 301 . M C BHASKARA S/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, 302 . SRI SHIVALINGAIAH S/O. GOPEGOWDA, AGED 69 YEARS, - 32 - 303 . RAJANNA S/O CHIKKEGOWDA, AGED 62 YEARS, 304 . SHANKARA S/O MUDDAIAH @ MOTAIAH, AGED 45 YEARS, 305 . SHIVANANJA @ THIMMASHETTY S/O. MUDUVASAIAH, AGED 60 YEARS, 306 . B SHIVALINGAPPA S/O. BUKKANNA, AGED 67 YEARS 307 . SHANKREGOWDA S/O. VENKATEGOWDA, AGED 58 YEARS, 308 . MUDDEGOWDA S/O DODDA MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 40 YEARS, 309 . PADMAMMA W/O ERASHETTY, AGED 65 YEARS, 310 . SUDHA B S W/O KRISHNA, AGED 50 YEARS, 311 . RAMANNA S/O KARIGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 312 . KRISHNA S/O. HONNAGIRIGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, - 33 - 313 . VIJAYANNA S/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS 314 . GURUBASAVACHARI S/O. PUTTASWAMACHARI, AGED 48 YEARS, 315 .

PRABHA W/O. KRISHNA, AGED 40 YEARS, 316 . MAHADEVI W/O RAJU, AGED 42 YEARS, 317 . M NAGESHA S/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 318 . GOWRAMMA W/O. MUNIAYYA, AGED 45 YEARS, 319 . M C UMESHA S/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 42 YEARS, 320 . SOMASHEKARA S/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 321 . BATTHEGOWDA S/O KARIGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 322 . SRI M S NAGARAJU S/O SHIVALINGAIAH, AGED 46 YEARS, - 34 - 323 . M. S. POORNIMA D/O SANNAIAH AGED 46 YEARS, 324 . KEMPAMMA W/O GUDDEGOPEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 325 . S SHIVAKUMARA S/O SHIVALINGAIAH M, AGED 47 YEARS, 326 . SUKANYAMMA W/O SHANKREGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 327 . VENKATESH S/O ERASHETTY, AGED 50 YEARS, 328 . M C KUMARA S/O CHANNEGOWDA, AGED 46 YEARS, 329 . M C SURESHA S/O CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 330 . DEVARAJU S/O THIMMEGOWDA, AGED 40 YEARS, 331 . CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA S/O GOPEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 332 . PRAKASHA S/O KARIGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, - 35 - 333 . SRI M C RAVIKUMARA S/O CHANNEGOWDA @ KAPREGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 334 .

M P NANDEESHA S/O PANCHALINGEGOWDA, AGED 33 YEARS, 335 . GOPALA S/O THIMMEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 336 . SHEKARA S/O MARIGOWDA, AGED 48 YEARS, 337 . GOWRAMMA W/O CHANNEGOWDA, AGED 65 YEARS, 338 . M K SRIDHARA S/O KALINGEGOWDA, AGED 45 YEARS, 339 . YOGEESHA M T S/O THAMMANNA, AGED 45 YEARS, 340 . DODDAMUDDEGOWDA M R S/O RAMEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 341 . SURESHA S/O CHANNAIAH @ ARAKAIAH, AGED 58 YEARS, 342 . SHEKARI S/O SHIVAPPA, AGED 55 YEARS, - 36 - 343 . SUNIYAMMA W/O M. C. NINGANNA, AGED 50 YEARS, 344 . DEVARAJU S/O MAHALINGAIAH, AGED 52 YEARS 345 . M K VIJAYAKUMAR S/O KALINGEGOWDA, AGED 40 YEARS 346 . M GIRISHA S/O. MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 41 YEARS, 347 . SRI SHANKARACHARI S/O. PUTTACHARI, AGED 52 YEARS, 348 . DEVARAJU S/O MARISHETTY, AGED 55 YEARS, 349 . M L UMESHA S/O M. B. LINGEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 350 . M RAMAKRISHNA S/O ARASIMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 54 YEARS, 351 . SRI M H PRABHAKARA S/O HUCHEGOWDA, AGED 40 YEARS, 352 . SUSHEELAMMA W/O KRISHNAPPA, AGED 56 YEARS, - 37 - 353 .

UMA W/O SATISHA, AGED 40 YEARS, 354 . NINGEGOWDA S/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 50 YEARS, 355 . SWETHA W/O RAMESHA, AGED 40 YEARS, 356 . SAROJAMMA W/O K. KRISHNAPPA, AGED 65 YEARS, 357 . JAYAMMA S/O DODDAKADAIAH AGED 65 YEARS, 358 . NATHAPPA S/O KARIGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 359 . SAVITHRAMMA W/O MUDDEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 360 . SHIVANNA S/O M. B. LINGEGOWDA, AGED 55 YEARS, 361 . GOWRAMMA W/O KALACHENNEGOWDA, AGED 60 YEARS, 362 . M K SHIVANNA S/O KENCHEGOWDA, AGED 58 YEARS, - 38 - 363 . M CHANDRASHEKARAIAH S/O M. MUDDEGOWDAZ AGED 57 YEARS, 364 . M C NAGESH MURTHY S/O PATEL CHIKKAMUDDEGOWDA, AGED 49 YEARS, 365 . SAVITHRAMMA W/O BYRAIAH, AGED 50 YEARS, ALL ARE R/AT MARAGOWDANAHALLI VILLAGE KERAGODU HOBLI MANDYA TALUK AND DISTRICT PIN – 571446. ... PETITIONERS (BY SRI. RAVINDRA PRASAD B, ADVOCATE) AND 1 . THE STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF CO-OPERATION, VIDHANASOUDHA, BANGALORE-560001. 2. THE DEPUTY REGISTRAR OF CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES, MANDYA – 571401. 3.

THE ASSISTANT REGISTRAR OF CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES, MANDYA – 571401. 4. MARAGOWDANAHALLI MILK PRODUCERS - 39 - CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD. , REPRESENTED BY ITS CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER HAVING ITS OFFICE AT MARAGOWDANAHALLI VILLAGE KERAGODU HOBLI MANDYA TALUK AND DISTRICT – 571401. …RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. NILOUFER AKBAR, AGA FOR R. 1 TO 3) THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT SECTION 20(2)(a-iv) AND (a-v) OF THE KARNATAKA CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES ACT, 1959 ARE ULTRA VIRES THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA AND ETC. THIS PETITION COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING: ORDER Heard Shri. Ravindra Prasad B, learned advocate for the petitioners and Smt. Niloufer Akbar, learned AGA for the State. 2. Shri. Ravindra Prasad B, learned advocate for the petitioners submits that elections have already been conducted. Therefore, this petition is rendered infructuous and accordingly prayed for its dismissal.

- 40 - He undertakes to send a memo to this effect. Once the memo is received, Registry shall keep the same in record. 3. In the circumstances, the petition is dismissed as having become infructuous. No costs. Sd/- JUDGE NBM

Source: High Court of Karnataka. Dataset: Dattam Labs. CC BY 4.0. Text extracted automatically; compare with the source PDF for layout and accuracy.