B.Srinivas Reddy v. State of Telangana
Court: High Court for State of Telangana
Bench: P.SAM KOSHY,SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
Judgment date:
Case summary
High Court for State of Telangana judgment dated 2025-10-15. B.Srinivas Reddy v. State of Telangana. Read the judgment and case details on LawSphereX.
Judgment text
[ 348e ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) WEDNESDAY,THE FIFTEENTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FIVE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P. SAM KOSHY AND THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO l. A. No. 1 OF 2025 IN/AND WRIT PETITION NO: 30456 OF 2025 Betwee n: 1. B-srinivas Reddy, S/o. Bhaskar Reddy, Aged about 54 years, School . Occ Assistant (Phy SC) ZPHS Dorepally, Kanagal (lt'1),. Nalgonda District' . 2. Kankanald Giridhar Reddy, S/o. Narsimha Reddy, Aged about 51 years, Occ. school Assistant (frhy. Sc), ZPHS Gopalpur, Elkathurthy (tvl)' Hanamkonda District. 3. Perne Yakaiah, S/o. Narsaiah, Aged about 57 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phv. Sc), ZPHS Ashwaraopally, Raghunathpally, Janagaon District. - +. tnaloiu Srinivasulu, S/o. N/allai;h, Aged about 57 years, Occ. S-chool. Assistant (Englith), ZPHS Boys Dharmakancha, Jangaon (M), Jangaon Districl "Shetty years, 5. Mad"am Shiva Kumar, S/o.
Sambaiah, Aged 52 . about Occ. school Assistant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Siddapur' Hasanparthy (lV), Hanamkonda District. Aged 6. Koduganti Sheshagiri Rao, S/o. Venkata Laxmi Narasimha Ramarao, about" 51 years, Occ. school Assistant (Phy. Sc)' ZPHS Shanigaram, Kamalapur (M), Hanamkonda District. 7. Revuri Raindkrishna Reddv, Sio. Narayana Reddy' Aged about 53 -years,Occ. School Assrstant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Singaram, lnavole (M)' Hanumakonda District. Occ. S-chool. Assistant B. Kusa Kalingam, S/o. Gattiah, Aged about 57 years, (English), ZPHS Kurchapally, Raghunathapally (M), Jangaon District. 55 Occ School S. bre6ranii Dayakar, S/o. sdtyanirayana, Agdd about -years, Hanumakonda Assistant (Enillish), (M), ZPHS'Pegadbpally, Hasanparthy District. years,Occ. School tO. gasin Raji Bapu Rao, S/o. shankar Rao a-bout 55 fged Aisistant'(English), ZPHS Shayampet Boys, Shayampet, Hanumakonda District. 1f . i. Venkateshwar Rao, S/o.
Janardhan Rao Aged about 58 years, Occ School Assistant (English) ZPHS Sthambampally, Khila Warangal Warangal Di{rict' r z. Atuguii ra'raricrraho, S/o. Veera Bhadrailh, Aged about 57 years, Occ. School Warangal District Assistant (English), ZPHS Khanapur, Khanapur (M), . . 57 years,occ. school Assistant 13. Pampari Kum-ar, s/o. Narsimhulu Aged about (Phv. Sc) ZPHS Kakkiralapallv, lnavole, Hanumakonda district. years, Occ. School Assistant t a. bfr. 'nati:ndram, S/o. Rajdshdm, Aged about 53 (English), ZPHS Bheerhdevarapally, Bheemdevarapally (M), Hanumakonda Diskict. 15. Srinivas Poola, S/o. Narsinga Rao Aged about 55 years,. ,- lc. School Assistant (English) ZPHS Thimmapur, Sangem, Warangal districl l6. Vemulapalli Mogili, S/o. Uppalaiah Aged about 51 years;. I :c. School Assistant (Phy. Sc) ZPHS Venkatapur,Damera,Hanamakonda distr r t 17. Anandas Thirupathaiah, S/o. Yellaiah Aged about 5ll years,Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS lbrahimpur,Ragunathpally,J:rr,r aon District. 18.
Kethini Rasudha Reddy, S/o. Narasimha Reddy Agetl bout 53 years,Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Punnel, lnavolu, Hant r rakonda District. . 19. B. Bharathi, Sio. Papi Reddy Aged about 54 years C r c. School Assistant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Punnel, lnavolu, Hanumakonda Distri,;l 20. Konda Surendar, S/o. Somaiah Aged about 57 years,t. ) ;0. School Assistant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Raghunathpally, Raghunathpally, JanJrr n District 21. Kaloori Anjaneya Chary, S/o. Ramgopal Aged about i ' years,Occ. School Assistant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Narmetta, Narmetta , Jangar>'t )istrict. 22. Medishetty Saraswati, S/o. Laxminarayana Aged about i 8 years,Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Kondaparthi, lnavole, Hantrm. (cnda District. 23. Mahadevapuram Anil Kumar, S/o. M. Gopala Krishna Sv amy Aged about 54 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Gudur, Kamalapur, Hanumakonda District. 24. Ravula Devendar, S/o. Narsaiah Aged about 58 years. l cc. School Assistant (Phy.
Sc), ZPHS Mallampally, Duggondi, Warangal Distr ( t 25. Bukkaraju Rajyalaxmi, S/o. Yadagiri Aged about f1 years,Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Narmetta, Narmetta, Jangar; I District. 26. Nathadi Sudhakar Reddy, S/o. Ramana Reddy Agec about 54 years,Occ School Assrstant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Keshavapur, Elkall t fthy . Hanumakonda District. 2T. Bandoju Srrnivasa Chary, S/o. sattaiah Aged aboul : 2 years,Occ. School Assistant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Kundaram, Lingala Ghanpur angaon Distrrct. 28. Sandi Sabitha, S/o. Yakoob Reddy, Aged about [, ysar5,Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Jeedikal, Lingalghan pur, Jan,; on District. 29- Sandaraja Madhavi, S/o. Ramaswamy, Aged atrout I 1 years,Occ School Assistant (English), ZPHS Ellanda, Wardhannapet, W I i ngal District. 30. B. Vinolya Kalpana, S/o. B. J. Anantha Rao, Aged abor 13 years,Occ. School Assistant (English),ZPHS Girls Parkal, Parkal, Hanuma x rada District. z 31. Ragula Venkateswarlu, S/o. Kistaiah, Aged about : years,C)cc.
School Assistant (English), ZPHS Pembarthi,Jangaon, Jangao r District. 32. Sathu Ramanadham, S/o. Rajamallu, Aged about ! 5 years,C)cc. School Assistant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Venkatapur, lnavole , Hanunr konCa District. 33. Maggidi Srivas, S/o. Venkat Rajaiah, Aged about t 3 years,Occ. School Assistant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Sriramulapally, Kamalapur. ll rnumakonda District. 34. Dasari Srinivas, S/o. Mallaiah, Aged about 56 years t lcc. School Assistant (Phy. Sc), ZPHS Madannapeta, kamalapur, Hanumako'r la District 35. Potharaju Anandam, S/o. Potharaju lllumallu, Aged ; Dout 52 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Pegadapally, Has: r parthy Hanumakonda District. 36. Kocharla Prabhakar, S/o. Pichaiah, Aged about ii years, Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Gajulamalkapuram. Pen ,ahad (M), Suryapet District. 37. M. Ramulu, S/o. Venkataiah, Aged about 56 years Occ. School Assrstant (English), ZPHS Raghunathpally, Raghunathpally (M), . angaon District. 38. T. Sammaiah, S/o.
Venkataiah, Aged about 57 years, Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Mekalagattu, Raghunathpally (lt/), Jarrr aon District. 39. Ch. Srinivas, , Sio. Shankaraiah, Aged about 58 years, Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Mallareddypally, Hasnaparthy (M), Ha r amkonda District. 40. Balne Nagabhushanam, S/o. Sathaiah, Aged about {7 years, Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Raghunathapally, Raghun: :hapally (M), Jangaon District, Telangana. 41. Koduri Srinivas, Sio. Rajaveeru, Aged about 59 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Deshrajpally, Ramadugu (tvl), Karimnagar District. 42. E. Devender Reddy, S/o. Kishta Reddy, Aged about 56 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Nustulapur, Thimmapur (M), Karimnagar District. 43. Gunda Srinivas, S/o. Lingamurthy, Aged about 57 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Kondapalkala, Manakondur (M), Karimnagar District. 44. Banda Rajireddy, S/o. Banda Anantha Reddy, Aged about 55 years, Occ.
Schooi Asaistant (English), ZPHS Bornapally, Huzurabad (w), Karimnagar District. 45. Kontham Arunadevi, D/o. Seetflaram, Aged about 55 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Nustulapur, Thimmapur (M), Karimnagar Districl 46. Bonagam Rdjesham, S/o. Venkatarah, Aged about 55 years, Occ. School Assisfant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Renikunta, Thimmapur (li4), Karimnagar District. 47. Gaddam Anitha, D/o. Swamy Ressy, Aged about 52 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy SC), ZPHS Sundaragiri, Chigurmamidi (tt/), Karimnagar District. 48. Veeragoni Anjaiah, S/o. Lingaiah, Aged about 56 years, Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Garrepally, Sulthanabad (M), Peddapally District 4g. Aar5pelti Srinivas, S/b. Nlrsinga Rao, Aged about 53 years, OccSchool Assidtant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Vegurupally, IVlanakondur (M), Karimnagar District. 50. Katta Venujopala Chary, S/o. Ramabrahmam, Aged about 55 ye? r. i' -Adsistant - Occ. school (Phy SC). ZPHS Eradapally, Shankarapatnam (l\,4), Karimnagar District. 51.
Pilli Laxmirajam, S/o-Rajanarsu Aged about 55 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Burugupally, Gangadhara (M), Karimnagar Distnct. ^ years, 52. Va(ulabharanam Vehugopal, S/o. Nambadri, Aged about 53 Occ. school Assistant (Phy SC) ZPHS Bommakal, Saidapur (M), Karimnagar District. 53. Rapelli Rajeshwar Rao, S/o. Komuraiah, Aged about 56 years, Occ. School Asiistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Lakkaram, Nlutharam (tVanthani) ([/), Peddapalli 54. M. Pavan' Ktimar, S/o. Rajaiah, Aged about 53 years, Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Singapur, Huzurabad (M), Karimnagar District.. 55. K. Srinivas, S/o. Narayana, Aged about 55 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Molangur, Shankarapatnam (! 1), Karimnagar District. 56. D. Srinivas, S/o. satyanarayana, Aged about 52 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Jangapally, Ganneruvaram (M), Karimnagar District. . ^ ST. Lakkakuia Ramprasad, S/d Thirupathaiah, Aged about 55 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy.
SC), ZPHS Singapur, Huzurabad (M), Karimnagar District. 58. S. Bhooniaiah, S/o. Mallaiah, Aged about 54 years, occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Burrugupally, Gangadhara (M), Karimnagar District. - S9. B. Vanisiee, D/o. Venkeswar Rao, Aged about 54 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Mulkanur, Chigurumamidi (M), Karimnag_ar D]strict . Shaheen, 60. Farhath S/o. Hussain, Aged about 53 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS Vedira, Ramadugu (M), Karimnagar District. 6l. Mambarisu Veena Rani, D/o. M. Venkateshwar Rao, Aged about 50 years, Occ. school Assistant (English), ZPHS Kothapally (H), Kothapalle (M)' Karimnagar District. 62. T. Laxma-na Chary, S/o. Brahmaiah, Aged about 54 years, Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Vedurugatta, Choppandandi (M), Karimnagar District. 63. Arigela Sammaiah, S/o. A. Mogilaiah, Aged about 55 y-ears, Occ. Scho. ol Asdistant (Phy. SC), Govemment High School, HuzurabO,Huzurabad (M)' Karimnagar District. 64. S. Thirupathi, S/o.
Venkataiah, Aged about 52 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. Science), ZPHS Bandalingahpally, Yellareddypally (M), Rajanna Sircilla District. 65. Basabathini Odelu Kumar, S/o. B. N4allaiah, Aged about 5 I years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. Science), ZPHS lndurthi School, )higurumamidi (M), Karimnagar District. 66. Ramaka Mallinatha Shastry, S/o. Vishwanatha Shastry, I ged about 55 years, Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Nawabpet )hig,rruthamidi (M), Karimnagar District. 67. Suddala Ramesh, S/o. Suddala Laxmipathi, Aged about 6 years, (f cc. school Assistant (P]ry Science), ZPHS Gattu Duddenapa! ' , L4anakondur (lv1), Karimnagar District. 68. Dobbula Babu, S/o. Rajamallaiah, Aged about 53 years )cc. school Assrstant (Phy SC), ZPHS tVlolangur, Shankarapatnam (tr/), Karirrr agar District. 69. Muddasani Chandrashekar Reddy, S/o. Venkat Re11y, Aged about 54 yea rs, Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Gattududc: rapa ly, fulanakondur (t\,4), Karimnagar District. 70.
Sreepathi Srinivas, S/o. Narsaiah, Aged about 55 years )cc. school Assistant (Phy SC), ZPHS Kolanur, Konaraopet (M), Rajanna Sirc i a Drstrict. 7'l . Gannu Vijaya Bhaskar Reddy, S/o Gannu Gali Reddv , ,ged about 53 years, Occ. School Assistant (English), ZPHS Wattipaly, Jar; evpur (lt,l), Siijdipet District. 72. Gollapalli Laxman, S/o. Rajamallu, Aged about 54 years, )cc. school Assistant (Phy SC), ZPHS Nallgonda, Thimmapur (M), Karimnagz I District 73. I\,4asham Praveen, S/o. Mondaiah, Aged about 55 years )cc. schocl Assistant (English), ZPHS Keshavapatnam, Shankarapatnam (lVl), (arirrnagar District. 74. Patha Maruthi, S/o. Raghavulu, Aged about 52 yea. :;. )cc. school Asslstant (Phy SC), ZPHS Nagulamalyal, Kothapalli (lr/), Karimnac:r Drstrict T5. Veeragoni Rajendra Prasad, S/o. Bhoomaiah, Agrti about 48 years, Occ School Assistant (English), ZPHS Chigurumamidr Chigurumamid'i 1M), Karimnagar District. 76. T Ajay Singh, S/o. Doulath Singh, (Phy. SC), Ait ,d about 52 years, Occ.
School Assistant, ZPHS Uppal, Uppal (M), I\rledcha | \Iatkajgiri Distriat. 77. P. Rajasekhar,- S/o. Veeranrta, (Phy. SC), Aged about i 5 years, Occ. school Assistant, ZPHS Anajipur, Bhongir (M), Yadadri Bhuverr; giri District 78. Thimmaiah, S/o. Kurmaiah, Aged about 56 years, r )cc. school Assistant (English), ZPHS (Boys) Badepally, Jadcheral (M), N/ah. il _, Lrbnagar District. 79. 1 Jayaraj, S/o. Thimothy, Aged about 56 years, r )cc. school Assistant (English), ZPHS Lingampally, Nawabpet (M), Mahabub I rgar District. - 80. D. Hari Prasad, S/o. Bheemappa, Aged about 50 years. 5cc School Assistant (English), ZPHS Vinjamur, Koilkonda (M), MahabJbnacz : Disrricr 81. S Ashok Kumar, S/o. Ramadas, Aged about 57 yeari CccSchool Assistant (! nglish), ZPIS Jadcherla, Kavaremmapet' Rc i d, Jadcherta (tV), I\,4a habubnagar District. 82. P. Narapa S/o. Venkat Reddy, Aged about :l years, leddy. Occ. school Assistant, (Phy. i! ), ZPHS Mallacheruvu, MallacheruvLr tr,/ ^ ), Suryapet District. ^ 83. A.
Ram Mohan Rao, S/o. Chandraiah, Aged about :+ years, bccSchool Assistant, (Maths) ZPHS Kapugallu, KodadlM), , Surya1r, t District. 84. B. Sridevi, Dio. B. Ram Reddy, Aqed abouf 51 veirs fcc School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS lkkurthi, Motikondur (M), Yadad-ri Bhcr giri District. - 85. K So_wlnyq, D/o. Malla Reddy, Aged about 55 years Occ. schoot Assistant ZPHS Vasalamarri, Thurkapally (M), Yidadr lhongiri _ flylCl, District. - 86. BV Ramesh Kumar, Slo BV Sdtyahdrayana, [r; rd aiout 58 years, Occ. School Assistant (Phy. SC), ZPHS N-aryanagLx em, Managala' (M), Suryapet District. 87. Samineni Srinivas Rao, S/o. Subha Rao, Aged abou 16 years, Occ. schopt Assistant, (Maths) ZPHS Tellabally, Nadigudem (M), S I yafet District. 88. M. Hari Haranath, S/o. Bhadraiah, Aged about 55 year:; Oic. school Assistant (English), ZPHS Kubeer, Kubeer (M), Nirmal Distrbt 89. P. Narender, S/o. P. Srinivas, Aged about 55 years Occ School Assistant (Phy SC), ZPHS Adlur, Kamareddy District. 90. K.
Narsimhulu, S/o. Damodar, Aged about 60 years, Occ. School Assistant (Bio Science), ZPHS Uppala, leeja (lt/), Jogulamba Gadwal District. g'1 . E. Chandra Shekar, S/o. Komuraiah Aged about 53 years,Occ. School Assistant (Phy. Sc) ZPHS Guriiala, Narsampet, Warangal r,. ,t]l,iar,r,O*a*, AND 1. State of Tetangana, School Education, rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government, Dr. B. R. Ambedkar Telangana Secretariat, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500022. 2. The Cbmmissioner and Director of School Education, 0/0 Director of School Education, Saifabad, Hyderabad - 500004. 3. The District Educational Officer, Telangana. ... RESPONDENTS Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue an order, direction or Writ more partrcularly one in the nature of Writ of Certioran or any other appropriate writ (i) after call for the records in O. A No. 8812l2002 and O. A. No.
872012002 and batch, dated. 05/1 1/2008 before the Honourable Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal, Hyderabad, and quash the orders passed in O. A. No. 88'12/2002 and O. A. No 872012002 and batch, dated. 05/1 1/2008 and (ii) consequently direct that the Writ Petitioners are entitled to seniority in the cadre of School Assistant pr/or to the date of appointment of the direct recruitees in DSC-2002 with all consequential benefits lA NO: 1 OF 2025 '1 Petition under Section 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to grant leave to the Writ Petitioners herein to file present Writ Petition IA NO: 3 OF 2025 '1 Petition under Section 51 CPC praying that in the ; rcumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Cou I may be pleased to direct the Respondents to extend the notional date of prorr:tion to the date of School Assistant w. e. f.
0110612002 any date earlier to the d. : e of appointment of the direct recruitees i. e. ,1711012OO2 with further direction { reserve .. he Head Master Grade-ll posts in favour of the Writ Petitioners in the r xist nq v:tcancies Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI G. VIDYASAGAR SENTOR Ci UNSEL REp SRI. SAI PRASEN GUNDA\, RAM Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 : SRI SANTHAPUR I iATYANARAYANA GP FOR SERVICES The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P. SAM KOSHY AND THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO I. A. No. 1 of 2025 In and WRIT PETITION No. 3O456 of 2o25 COMMON ORDER: (per Hon'ble Sn Juslice P. S. AIW KOSHY) Hoard Mr. G. Vidyasagar, lcarned Senior Counsel rcprcsentillg Sri Saiprascn (iundavaram and Mr. Santhapur Satyanaral'ana, Iearned Goverrlllrent Plcadcr lbr Scrvices-1. for respondent Nos. l and 2. 2. l-hc mattcr was takcn up on t. A. No. l of 2025.
$'hich is thc lt'ar c petition seeking lcave by the petitioncrs seeking to challenge thr: batch o['O. As Illcd be lbrc rhc "thc Andhra l)radesh Administrative Tribunal, I{yderabad. (tbr shorr 1'ribunal") and thc lead case of rvhich rvas O. A. No. 8720 and 88 I 2 ol 2022 and batch ritich stood I-rnally' disrnissed on 05. I I . 2008. l. l'hc grievance of the petitioners seems to be the disrnissal ol'the O. A. s h1' thc l ribunal vide alorcsaid order dated 05. 11. 2008. I'he point ol'issue that uas undcr considcralion belore the State Administrative Trihunal was in rospoct o['thc intcr' -sc seniority that was in bctween direct recruits and the promotees to lhc post ol'School Assistants. 4. I'he applicants beforc the Tribunal were fiom among the promotce categories wherc they were claiming promotion in tcrrns of thc GO. Ms No 538. dated 20. I 1. 1998, where the mode of selection to thc post of School Assislant was direct rccrLritment as also b1' rval' ol'promotions.
l-he said rtLl: also prescribed that in the crent. whcre rhe rnodc *'as b1'both modes, thc post 10 r: Iilled up br *ar ol- direcl rccruiLnrcnt shall bc 10-0. ,6 and balancc of 70Yo w. as to lr tillccl rrp b1 iial of' prorltoI tolt J -i. he cluinr olthc applicants hefirre the Iribunal was that rh: harl bcconre clieihlc lor prornolirin t() tlrc post ol'school Assistant either in the verr 20()i or in the carlv part o1' \ eur 1002. ,\t that poillt ol timc apprehcnding tho dir(. ( t rccruitr. nept process initiatcd b-r thc Depannrcnt il' is tinalizcd. the applicants be li r : rhe lribunal rr. ould bccou. rc . iunior to the dircct rccruits. ()nlv on the inactio r on thc part ol' thc I)cpanrncnr in not l'inalizing rhc promotion process of fillinc r p ol'posts ol School Assistants lo thc e\tent ot' 7006 of the vacancies. The o.. A. rvas lllod bclbrc the 'I'ribunal.
Arr irrtcrirn order rvas also grantcd by the Tribunrr at rhc l-irst instancc dircctin{r thc rcspontlcuts to indicate in thc appointment order: of the tlirect recruits that scrliorilr sllall hc lixcd suh. jecl to thc outcorne ol lhc al' cmcnLionccl batch ol 'lrrbunal. c). As bctirrc the Mi:anu,hile. horvevcr. pendine he o. As bclorc the Trihu. al. thc proccss ol'direct rccruitrnent initiatcd and got I ralizcd u. d . rders . l' appointrnerrt rvere issucd as per the diroction on 0g. 10. 20( l. Subscclucntll. thc applicarrts betirrc thc tribunal wcre given promotions almost I rring thc sarne pcriod ol timc ho* er er a littlc bit Iatcr io the appointment orders issu. ' I to the dircct recruirs i. e. sonrcri'here arotrnd 20 10. 2002 and 22. 10. 2002. Finally he hatch of petitions oarne up befirre thc lribunal fbr hearing on 05. 11. 200g and tr. Tribunal taking into consideration thc factual matrix of thc casc rnore particular. ll.
t rkin_rr note ol-the fact on 08 10'2002 thc claim of thc that direct rccruits have already been appointecl i applioantslorinlersescniorityovcrandabor,ethedirectrecruitsstooddismisscd. 6. l. hesaiddisrnissalolbatchol. o. Asrvaswithanobsctrationthattlrotlnlr rcrncdl',tlratrvasavailablerviththeapplicantswastoapproaclrthc(joverntlrenttrlr rclaxationol-thcrulcsparticularlyRule33(a)cllA. P-stateandSubordinatcSen,ice I{ulcs. 1996 perusal of the contents olthc petition and pleadings w'hat 1. [ lorvever. lrom the 'lribunal of the dismissing rvas no furthcr challcnge to thc order appcar. s is that therc 'l'ribuna[' thc large batch of potitions befbre the I had batch pctitioners are concernecl' adrnittedll ' thcl 8. ln so far as the present ol I rrotprelerredanypetitionbeforetheStateAdministrativc.
lribunaleitheratthotimc I i b1 the or bcing aggricied to the post of School Assistant I betbre their promotlon I to the petitiorlcrs hcrcirr' given to the direct recruits carlier appointment being i 'Ihe ! petitioners at no point of timc of appointment or in betwecn had approacl-red an1 'fribunal rclief so llr as seeking fbr an appropriate competcnt Cotrrt of law or the recetlt past' Thcl had madc is concemed till in the tixation of the inter se seniority cerlain rcprcscntations to the Government only in the recent past' g. Thc contention ofthe petitioners is that they were only recently made knou'n of thclactthatthebatchofO. AswhichwerefiledbeforetheTribunalgotdismisscdon 05. ll. 2005. ltisonlythereafterthatthepetitionersseemtohavestartedpursuingthe matter with the Government and have now approached this court secking leave to challenge thc order 'l'ribunir Passod bv the state Administrative in the barch ol o. As dccidcd on 05. 1 I . 2()()lt 10.
fhe iact rrhreh has caueht the mind of this Bench is rrrr it is hard t. acccpt that thc pctitionels \\cre not a\\,are ot'tirstll,the iiling of o. As rLr <l its disrnissal hcfirre thc Trihunal. Sc-condh. tlrerc does not sconr to bc any kccn rtercst shou,n b1 thc petitioners seckingr, firr scnioritv over and above the direct recn i s all thesc periods till recontll rrhcn thcr havc nrade corttrin represcntations and tl:d this r. rrit perition. Thcv * erc also ,ol r igilant cnough to tind out thc outcorr. rr rl- the batch ol o. As peuding bct'urc thc I ribrrnal il thev ,rvcre knowinq lully rvcll c a the matters pcn<ling belirrc rhc lrihunll und thc inrerim 'frib ordcr granted b1,the rrirl and the closurc ol- -fhis the Iriirunal subsctluentlv. I]cnoh hcncc drarvs an atl,1. ss interltrcncc that knorvinslr rvith rvid,-' opcn c\ cs petitioners [rave not showu irr Jrest to cllallcngc the order aggric'c<l of carlicr . r raising anl of the grievances : o far as rhc irtrer .
se senlont\ is concenrcil ll. lt is onlr n. ri *hc, rccent provisional seniority list tha ltrs published that thc pctitloncrs sccrn to lr. rr c oke-Lrp fiorn the slumbcr and har ,. lecidcd to agitatc the '' matter and no* approachcd this C. urt sceking leave to challcrr . c thc ordcr passcd by the'['ribrrnr. rl I I 12. (ii'cn the afbresaitl rnatrix ol thc casc, \{,c are not inclirr d to entertain the sard I leavc potition tirr thc rcasor. r that therc appears to be a delibcra,r rvaiver br. conduct on the part . ,1' thc pctitioncrs in I raising this issue at approp-r rte time or w,ithin a reasonable period ol- timc. Sccondlv. if at all the petitioners i r the reason that thcv \\ ere not party to any of the proccedings befbre the Tribunal and are now aegricved b1' -t or thc prorisional the rccent action on thc paft ol the t)epartrnent aggricved b1' I I itsclf be a cause ol- action cannot be scniorirl list publishecl. this $'ould in frcsh l'his t i !
a ground availablc lbr thc pctitioners lor grant of leavc to challengc tho ordcr pass. 'tl I by thc Tribunal that too \\a)' back on 05. 11. 2008' 13. [. or the alorcsaid rcasons, wc arc not inclined to enterlain the I. A. No. 1 ol'2025 and the samc accordingly stands re. iccted. consequently, thc writ Pctition also stands rcjectcd. No order as to costs. As a sequel. miscellaneous pctitions, pending ilany, shall stand closcd- SD/. A. SRINIVASA REDDY ASSISTANT RE. GISTRAR /,. g //TRUE COPY// l SECTION OFFICER To, ! of Telanoana' School '1 . The Principle Secretary to Government' State I Slir"trriat, Fyderabad, relansana Fducarion. Dr. B R nroEoirii"ili. llh, - 500022. and Director of Scho-ol Education' 0/0 Director of School z ftE i"-n-*issioner - - 500004' eJr"atio", Saifabad, Hyderabad officer, Telanga. ll s ihe Disirict Educational -5Al . . . . . "Cc pnis er'r b u N-oXvnRRtu'.
no'ocate [oPUCl ; o;; i;' sRi for the statb of Telangana at 5 Two ccs to Gp ron siiiv-riis-i ,n,gi'corrt Hyderabad [OUTI 6. Two CD CoPies BM LS \qr li I i ! I I I t HIGH COURT / DATED:1511012025 '- .. "' , '" -'-: ' ,,. l\ l'',. ,. / .. * I . :l I ffi ftr lti COMMON ORDER !. A. No. 1OF 2025 IN/AND WP. No. 3O456 of 2025 REJECTING BOTH THE l. A. No. 1 OF 20 25 AND ALSO WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTI; "*** &-"
Source: High Court for State of Telangana. Dataset: Dattam Labs. CC BY 4.0. Text extracted automatically; compare with the source PDF for layout and accuracy.