Sh.S.Manasia and 20 Ors. v. Sh Subhash Sharma Secretary BRDB and 13 Ors.
Court: Gauhati High Court
Bench: HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE MARLI VANKUNG
Judgment date:
Case summary
Gauhati High Court judgment dated 2024-08-28. Sh.S.Manasia and 20 Ors. v. Sh Subhash Sharma Secretary BRDB and 13 Ors. Read the judgment and case details on...
Judgment text
Page No. # 1/13 GAHC030005952019 THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) Case No. : Cont. Cas(C)/23/2019 Hilai and 25 Ors Khopai, Tuipang, Mizoram 2: C Rahmo Khopai Tuipang Mizoram 3: K Beikhai Khopai Tuipang Mizoram 4: Pawchhie Khopai Tuipang Mizoram 5: B Hulai Khopai Tuipang Mizora VERSUS Subhash Sharma and 14 Ors Sena Bhavan B wing, New Delhi 2:Brig Birender Singh Chief Engineer BRTF C/o 99APO 3:R Lalramnghaka Secretary Land Revenue and Settlement Mizoram Page No. # 2/13 4:Bhupesh Chaudary Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizoram 5:N Pachhunga Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha 6:Sh Manu Prasad Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak CREG C/o 99 APO 7:Sh R. Zarzosanga Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Dept. Aizawl 8:Sh Kesavan R Deputy Commissioner Siaha Dist. 9:Sh P. N. Yadav Chief Engineer Project Pushpak BRTF 10:Sh C.
Lalsangliana Deputy Commissioner Siaha District 11:Sh Pheiko Solo Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous Dist. Council Siaha District 12:Sh S. P. Kolipey Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO 13:Sh Lalhmunsanga Hnamte Page No. # 3/13 Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Siaha Mizoram 14:Smt Nazee Khaila Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha Mizoram 15:Sh VL Hruaizela Khiangte Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizora Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinary T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte for R15 Linked Case : Cont. Cas(C)/28/2019 Zamawnga and 15 Ors. Siatlai Tuipang Mizoram 2: Tlabu Siatlai Tuipang Mizoram 3: S Chaido Siatlai Tuipang Mizoram 4: Motei Siatlai Tuipang Mizoram 5: K Chholei Page No. # 4/13 Siatlai Tuipang Mizoram VERSUS Sh Subhash Sharma and 13 Ors.
Sena Bhavan B wing New Delhi 2:Brig Birender Singh Chief Engineer BRTF C/o 99APO 3:R Lalramnghaka Secretary Land Revenue and Settlement Mizoram 4:Bhupesh Chaudary Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizoram 5:N Pachhunga Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha 6:Sh P. N. Yadav Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO 7:Sh R. Zarzosanga Secretary to the Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Dept. Aizawl 8:Sh Kesavan R Deputy Commissioner Siaha Dist. Siaha 9:Sh C. Lalsangliana Deputy Commissioner Page No. # 5/13 Siaha Dist. Siaha Mizoram 10:Sh Pheiki Solo Senior Revenue Officer MADC Siaha Dist. Mizoram 11:Sh S. P. Kolipey Chief Engineer Border Road Task Force (BRTF) Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO 12:Sh Lalhmunsanga Hnamte Deputy Commissioner Siaha Dist.
Mizoram 13:Smt Nazee Khaila Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha Mizoram 14:Sh VL Hruaizela Khiangte Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizoram Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinary T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte for R14 Linked Case : I. A. (Civil)/141/2024 Zamawnga and 15 Ors. S/o Lungphuna (L) R/o Siatlai Siaha District Mizoram VERSUS Page No. # 6/13 Sh Subhash Sharma and 12 Ors. Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) Sena Bhavan B Wing New Delhi - 110010 Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Mrs. Linda L Fambawl Linked Case : Cont. Cas(C)/22/2019 S Manasia and 20 Ors Khopai Tuipang Mizoram 2: Hudo Khopai Tuipang Mizoram 3: Hratla Khopai Tuipang Mizoram 4: K Reithai Khopai Tuipang Mizoram 5: Chido Khopai Tuipang Mizoram VERSUS Subhash Sharma and 14 Ors Sena Bhavan B wing New Delhi 2:Brig Birender Singh Chief Engineer BRTF Page No.
# 7/13 C/o 99APO 3:R Lalramnghaka Secretary Land Revenue and Settlement Mizoram 4:Bhupesh Chaudary Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizoram 5:N Pachhunga Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha 6:MANV Prasad Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO 7:Sh R. Zarzosanga Secretary to Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Department 8:Sh Kesavan R Deputy Commissioner Siaha District 9:Sh P. N. Yadav Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO 10:Sh Lalsangliana Deputy Commissioner Siaha District 11:Sh Pheiki Solo Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha Mizoram 12:Sh SP Kolipey Chief Engineer Page No.
# 8/13 BRTF Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO 13:Sh Lalhmunsanga Hnamte Deputy Commissioner Siaha District 14:Smt Nazee Khaila Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha Mizoram 15:Sh VL Hruaizela Khiangte Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizoram Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinary T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte (Addl. A. G. /G. A. ) for R4 R7 R8 R10 & R15 Linked Case : I. A. (Civil)/139/2024 Hilai and 25 Ors. S/o Pedo Khopai Saiha District Mizoram VERSUS Sh Subhash Sharma and 13 Ors. Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) Sena Bhavan B Wing New Delhi-110010 Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Page No. # 9/13 Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte Linked Case : I. A. (Civil)/140/2024 Hrapho and 22 Ors. S/o Mahu Zawngling Siaha District Mizoram VERSUS Sh Subhash Sharma and 13 Ors.
Secretary Border Roads Development Board (BRDB) Sena Bhavan B Wing New Delhi-110010 Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte Linked Case : Cont. Cas(C)/27/2019 Sh. Hrapho and 22 Ors Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram 2: B Beizi Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram 3: M Lawhra Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram 4: L Kheko Zawngling Tuipang Page No. # 10/13 Mizoram 5: LC Chahlo Zawngling Tuipang Mizoram VERSUS Shubash Sharma and 14 Ors Sena Bhawan B wing New Delhi 2:Brig Birender Singh Chief Engineer BRTF C/o 99APO 3:R Lalramnghaka Secretary Land Revenue and Settlement Mizoram 4:Bhupesh Chaudary Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizoram 5:N Pachhunga Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha 6:Sh. Manv Prasad Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak C/o 99 APO 7:Sh. R. Zarzosanga Secy. to Govt. of Mizoram Land Revenue and Settlement Deptt. Aizawl 8:Sh. Kesavan R DC Siaha District Siaha Page No. # 11/13 9:Sh. P. N.
Yadav Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak GREF C/o 99 APO 10:Sh. Pheiki Solo Sr. Revenue Officer MADC Siaha District Siaha 11:Sh. Lalsangliana DC MADC Siaha District Siaha 12:Sh. SP kolipey Chief Engineer BRTF Project Pushpak C/o 99 APO 13:Sh Lalhmunsanga Hnamte Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Siaha 14:Smt Nazee Khaila Senior Revenue Officer Mara Autonomous District Council Siaha Mizoram 15:Sh VL Hruaizela Khiangte Deputy Commissioner Siaha District Mizoram Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : Ms. Mary Lalruatkimi Khiangte for R15 Linked Case : I. A. (Civil)/138/2024 Page No. # 12/13 Sh. S. Manasia and 20 Ors. S/o S. Dakhu R/o Khopai Siaha District VERSUS Sh Subhash Sharma Secretary BRDB and 13 Ors. Sena Bhavan B Wing New Delhi Advocate for the Petitioner : Ms Dinari T Azyu Advocate for the Respondent : B E F O R E HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MARLI VANKUNG ORDER 02. 05. 2025 Ms. Dinari T.
Azyu, learned counsel for the petitioner is present along with Mrs. Mary L. Khiangte, learned Govt. Advocate appearing on behalf of the Deputy Commissioner, Siaha and Ms. Babie Laldinzuali appearing on behalf of Ms. Zairemsangpuii, learned CGC for the respondents/BRTF. The learned counsel for the Deputy Commissioner, Siaha submits that they may be given further time to file their additional show cause reply, since steps are still being taken to verify the amount to be paid to the petitioners. In view of the above, list this matter along with the connected matters on Page No. # 13/13 15. 05. 2025. JUDGE Comparing Assistant
Source: Supreme Court eSCR. Dataset: Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0. Text extracted automatically; compare with the source PDF for layout and accuracy.